Reviews (208) 235-1311 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Fifth Street Bagelry is a bagel shop in Pocatello, ID.

Fifth Street Bagelry Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Fifth Street Bagelry is a local favorite for fresh, chewy bagels and a wide selection of delicious spreads. Customers love the friendly service, cozy atmosphere, and generous breakfast sandwiches. The coffee pairs well with the bagels, making it a great spot for a morning treat. Many visitors praise the quick service and reasonable prices, making it a go-to place for both locals and newcomers looking for a satisfying meal.

Review Rating Chart

Google: 4.7/5

Yelp: 4.5/5

Tripadvisor: 4.5/5

Facebook: 4.8/5

Zomato: 4.3/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.7
(964 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Lisa Warner
Lisa Warner -Google user
4 months ago
Great place for bagels and coffee! Lots of varieties of cream cheese- bagels and coffee options. We will definitely be back to try more options! There were lots of different toppings you could add and create your own favorite bagel sandwich. Highly recommend!
Dine inBreakfast$1–10Atmosphere: 5No wait
Wyatt G Tippit
Wyatt G Tippit -Google user
2 months ago
5th street Bagelry is the best breakfast spot and bagels are wonderful. My wife and I drive 55 minutes just to enjoy the breakfast and coffee. We highly recommend sitting down and enjoying the atmosphere and great coffee.
Dine inBreakfast$10–20Atmosphere: 5
Ignacio Rodríguez
Ignacio Rodríguez -Google user
a year ago
Very limited parking / 5⭐ bagels / good spot for hanging out or casual dates First of all the food was really good as far as bagels go. You can choose any bread and then the style of bagel you want. You can also choose 3...Read More
Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 47 Layer Bar
abigail bibler
abigail bibler -Google user
2 years ago
I cannot say enough good things about this place. I live out of town and always make a few trips to 5th Street when I’m in town. Their bagels are the best I’ve ever had and they have a plethora of options to choose from....Read More
Blue
Blue -Google user
a year ago
Fifth Street Bagels has fantastic food, drinks, and service. We enjoyed having breakfast here on the little patio area, and hope to come again soon.
Ana
Ana -Google user
2 years ago
LOVED THIS PLACE!! We came to visit pocatello, and I ended coming 3 days in a row due to how much I liked fifth street bagelry! …
Sarah Roberts
Sarah Roberts -Google user
2 years ago
We came here for breakfast on Saturday and the bagels are the best I’ve ever had. They are even better than Einstein bagels, they are so fresh and have great flavor and texture. I ordered the egg Florentine breakfast sandwich on Asiago and it was...Read More
Allie Tomlinson
Allie Tomlinson -Google user
7 months ago
It is impossible for me to drive through Pocatello without stopping for the best bagels in the WORLD. i get the pilgrim, add avocado, spinach and sprouts 😇 …
Kendra Scheid
Kendra Scheid -Google user
5 months ago
Staff is always polite and fun to speak to. The food is superb and really convenient. Our favorite thing is to grab a few to go and head up the mountain for breakfast. 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Dave Chappell
Dave Chappell -Google user
3 months ago
Amazing bagels 🥯 I also love their many sandwitch options. This place is always a stop every time I pass through the area.
Dine inBreakfast$1–10Atmosphere: 5No waitDifficult to find parkingFree parking lot, Free street parkingEvery small parking area
Sepehr Honarvarnazari
Sepehr Honarvarnazari -Google user
7 months ago
Everything was just amazing! The staff was super kind and willing to go above and beyond, the atmosphere was so nice, and the food was just scrumdidlyumscious.
joshua felts
joshua felts -Google user
a week ago
Fifth Street Bagelry: Local Legend and Must-Try Bagels (5/5 Stars!) Fifth Street Bagelry isn't just another bagel shop; it's a true neighborhood institution. This spot is genuinely unique—you can tell immediately by the line out the door that it's locally well known and beloved for good...Read More
Take outBreakfast$10–20Atmosphere: 4Moderate noise
Julianne Ersfeld
Julianne Ersfeld -Google user
a month ago
I'm an NYC native and very particular about my bagels. I was so pleasantly shocked at how good my breakfast sandwich was! I had the Florentine but there were so many amazing breakfast sandwich options, it was hard to choose. They also had a great...Read More
Dine inBreakfast$1–10Atmosphere: 5Highly recommend
Nalani Collins
Nalani Collins -Google user
a week ago
I ordered from Doordash the Cactus Jack and Soup de Jour and not knowing the soup, just craving some warmth. Omg, it was Roasted Tomato something and it was amazing with my perfect bagel sandwich. Yummm! And thank you for the quality and care.
Food: 5
Kiley Kemmer
Kiley Kemmer -Google user
2 months ago
This was my first time being in and I got a bagel sandwich. I was pleased with all the options! And my sandwich was so good and fresh! Yum! Pretty darn quick service as well which was nice. Little spendy but I enjoyed it.
Take outBreakfast$10–20Atmosphere: 5Suitable for all group sizes
Travis Richardson
Travis Richardson -Google user
a week ago
I want to express the euphoria created by the absolute masterpiece of the Monday Special "Ham-Apeno" sandwich. …
M
M -Google user
4 months ago
Veggie sandwich with hummus subbed for cream cheese was a great vegan lunch. Very fresh veggies. Bagels aren't mind blowing, but pretty good! Would be great to have a vegan cream cheese option.
Blake Bowler
Blake Bowler -Google user
4 months ago
We used to live in pocatello back in 2009 and now live in SLC and will drive from there just to have their bagels. It is a must stop for the whole family, and my son loves the Reeds chocolate milk. Best bagels ever
Paul Roth
Paul Roth -Google user
Edited 2 weeks ago
Excellent food. Service at lunchtime is not fast, but I couldn't expect better. Atmosphere is functional.
Yajaira Castro
Yajaira Castro -Google user
3 months ago
First time here! Food was amazing definitely recommended the California Club with a Parmesan bagel toasted, it was delicious! We didnt realize they closed at 4 and they didnt mind us staying a few minutes after to finish our food!

Features

Service options

check icon Drive-through
check icon In-store pickup
check icon In-store shopping
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in
Delivery

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options

check icon Breakfast

Amenities

check icon Wi-Fi

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards
check icon NFC mobile payments