Reviews (516) 377-4070 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

American Thrift Stores - Baldwin is a thrift store in Baldwin, NY.

American Thrift Stores - Baldwin Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

This thrift store is a treasure trove for bargain hunters! With a vast selection of gently used items at affordable prices, shoppers can find great deals on clothing, furniture, and more. Friendly staff and a clean, organized store make for a pleasant shopping experience.

Review Rating Chart

Google: 4.4/5

Yelp: 4.5/5

Facebook: 4.7/5

TripAdvisor: 4.3/5

Thumbtack: 4.6/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
3.9
(173 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Clifford Schaefer
Clifford Schaefer -Google user
a year ago
This is the first store Ive seen with a larger clothing selection than Marshalls or TJ Max. Also the shoe selection as well as Womens bags were greater in selection. Just be careful with the kids. Its easy to get lost in all the rows of clothes.
B “Bakerboy” Schechter
B “Bakerboy” Schechter -Google user
5 years ago
Best thrift store anywhere. Everyone friendly, caring and respectful. Everything clean and well organized. Top quality designer items. And I really love the antique rocker and wool rugs I got here.
Darryl Palmas
Darryl Palmas -Google user
5 months ago
Head cashier, Ms. Romero, Is a great asset to your company. Ive been shopping here for several years, and she has always been attentive to my shopping needs as well as super professional. She also is amazingly patient and makes me tend to spend more...Read More
timothy kellam
timothy kellam -Google user
5 months ago
I have been coming to this Thrift shop in Baldwin since it has open, I have purchased some great electronics from this location, and I picked up several musical instruments as well, i,m there at least once a week looking for Deal,s very hard...Read More
Audrey O'Malley
Audrey O'Malley -Google user
5 months ago
American Thrift Store is such a pleasure to shop at, and the staff that work there are always so helpful and friendly. Thank you everyone and a special thanks to Zaya who is always so welcoming, what a delight.
Laeana Rodriguez
Laeana Rodriguez -Google user
a year ago
i appreciate the color coordination of the aisles and hope you guys continue to do so since its incredibly helpful! Also hoping that you guys make announcements regarding closing since as.a first time visitor, I thought the store would announce closing time but I found...Read More
Ludmila Lazareva
Ludmila Lazareva -Google user
6 months ago
It was my first visit and I love this place! I found really nice and quality stuff. It was not crowded on the working day.
Tracie Thomson, NY FL Realtor
Tracie Thomson, NY FL Realtor -Google user
a year ago
Huge store with a great variety. Many items are very well priced. Was looking for baby clothes. I like that some items are bundled in sets of 2 similar items, but a 3mth and a 9mth Pant shouldn't be paid together. Some of the pairings...Read More
Rogelin Degoma
Rogelin Degoma -Google user
5 months ago
Our staff cashier Nancy was very helpful and great! Keep going!
Amy Arndt
Amy Arndt -Google user
11 months ago
Great selection and really great prices for home goods. $4 for a huge charcuterie board, $10 for a 36" mirror. Will definitely come back
Romanaxel Krassner
Romanaxel Krassner -Google user
4 years ago
Almost every time I've gone here there's been awesome clothes. This store also has furniture and houseware items, games, and DVDs/CDs. They're usually pretty stocked at all times and often run sales. In the era of COVID, I think (but I'd call to double check)...Read More
Richard Cochran
Richard Cochran -Google user
4 years ago
Always a great selection. I love looking through the CD, movie and book selections. Always guaranteed to find a jewel or 2. Housewares are decent variety. Always a great inexpensive hour or two get away without breaking your pockets
Ashlee Bennett
Ashlee Bennett -Google user
6 years ago
Amazing selection. Just stopped in here! Walked out with Tommy Hilfger, Ralph Lauren, Nike, and Calvin Klein in excellent condition. All their clothes are clean and in good condition. I honestly wasn’t expecting that. I will be stopping in here again
Kristin Famiglietti
Kristin Famiglietti -Google user
6 years ago
My new favorite thrift store! Wide selection of clothes, great prices, and the staff is very helpful. Definitely worth checking it out if you haven’t been there yet.
Louis Russo
Louis Russo -Google user
5 years ago
This is a great thrift store. Terrific selection of shoes, clothes and handbags. I bought my girlfriend a Gucci bag for $100, that I almost bought at a store in the city for $480 (just don’t tell my girlfriend that.) It was also very clean...Read More
M Rivera
M Rivera -Google user
9 months ago
I always find amazing stuff for amazing prices at this place. Staff is very helpful and very professional.
Jami Goodman
Jami Goodman -Google user
5 years ago
I’m not usually a fan of thrift stores, but this place puts all others to shame. They have everything you can think of with many products like new. High quality stuff with unparalleled customer service.
Stephanie Levine
Stephanie Levine -Google user
5 years ago
LOVE this thrift store!!! Top quality clothes and accessories at cheap prices. I am an avid thrifter and this store is by far one of my favorites to go to. The staff is so friendly and the store is so clean. Highly recommended.
Suzy Geller
Suzy Geller -Google user
5 years ago
Best store ever!! Great prices, amazing selection and the friendliest staff!! Definitely will be a regular! I also can’t wait for your New Jersey store to open!
Sanday Simon
Sanday Simon -Google user
4 years ago
This was the old CVS location. This a large location. I noticed plugs so you can test appliances. A lot of glass and home items. You can definitely find something good.

Features

Service options

check icon In-store pickup
check icon In-store shopping
Delivery

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings

check icon Buys used goods

Crowd

check icon LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning

check icon Quick visit

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards
check icon NFC mobile payments

Other

check icon LGBTQ+ friendly

People Also Search