Reviews (317) 573-4400 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Amanda's Exchange is a consignment shop in Carmel, IN.

Amanda's Exchange Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.3
(371 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Lonnie Perry
Lonnie Perry -Google user
Edited 6 months ago
A nice assortment of consigned goods. Women's, juniors, and children's apparel, purses, jewelry, furnishings, and several home accents decorations are all available in abundance at this boutique. Many brands you want at fantastic pricing. There is a small area of men's clothes. Visit their online...Read More
D. B.
D. B. -Google user
6 years ago
Fun on my 1st visit here. Beautifully displayed items mostly very gently used. Some a bit worse for wear so be sure to fully inspect each piece. Top designers and trendy items. Some priced reasonable and other items are more expensive. It is worth the...Read More
Dawn Johns
Dawn Johns -Google user
a year ago
If you are looking to refresh your Spring and Summer wardrobe shop Amanda’s Exchange. Do a closet clean out first & drop off your items that may be on someone else must have list for this season. From clothes, to jewelry, purses, furniture, rugs and...Read More
Anne Roberts
Anne Roberts -Google user
Edited 3 years ago
Amanda's exchange is an awesome place to find nice clothes, awesome furniture, and very nice discounted items. They also have very nice name brand purses. Love this resale shop.
Steven Rogers
Steven Rogers -Google user
5 years ago
Good atmosphere. Fiancée found a nice dress for a good price - only $20. We went there looking for furniture though, which was not successful. They had some, but it was all super expensive. We were trying to budget shop (like $100) and thought it...Read More
D Scalos
D Scalos -Google user
Edited 4 months ago
Marketplace is so fun and busy!! Always fun to see the interesting things they provide. Great customer service!
Lynnette Vinson
Lynnette Vinson -Google user
4 years ago
This is a really neat place to shop with decent prices! I never walk out empty handed! These beautiful Michael Kors less than 50.00
Laurie Hammond
Laurie Hammond -Google user
3 years ago
Very organized clean funky and fun shopping experience. Daughter got some amazing boots for 30 bucks and an adorable duster for 8 bucks. We'll be back 👍 …
Hayden Smith
Hayden Smith -Google user
a month ago
My wife needed a new dress for a business event I am going to. We searched all of the fashion mall and several other stores. Then I remembered she found this place once before and off we went. She ended up finding a formal prom dress...Read More
Zainul Hasanali
Zainul Hasanali -Google user
2 months ago
This place is awesome! So much cool stuff. All high end. Staff are very knowledgeable about each piece. We go at least once a week to see what's new.
Laurie Anderson
Laurie Anderson -Google user
Edited a month ago
Always an awesome and unique experience! I love all the fun, interesting, one of a kind items they sell. Prices are not bad either, but some of the home items are a bit overpriced for secondhand. Fun environment, great employees. Will definitely shop there again!
Rachel Tabler
Rachel Tabler -Google user
8 months ago
To help with the scary environmental impact the clothing industry has created, I very rarely buy new clothing. And I am for sure skipping the fast fashion. I love that I can get so many like new pieces for my wardrobe at Amanda’s that...Read More
Becky August
Becky August -Google user
2 months ago
Very nice store... Organized well. Pricier than a thrift store, but most things are from nicer brands. They have sales regularly and clearance.
M Paige
M Paige -Google user
6 months ago
This is a Super neat little shop! I love how they have it organized by brand and clothing type. One side of the shop is all clothing, while the other side of the shop is household items and furniture. Definitely one of my new favorite...Read More
Leo
Leo -Google user
7 months ago
This place is massive, organized, and has anything a woman could ever want. I do enjoy their small men's section, where they promote the men's consignment store, Newman and Co. The two businesses are related and I found the service at Amanda's to be awesome,...Read More
Adi Zych-Poplardo
Adi Zych-Poplardo -Google user
9 months ago
Very cute place! The items are in excellent condition. It was so much fun to look around and find some bargains ! Lee was super helpful and made me feel comfortable shopping around. She has great eye and made some suggestions that worked wonderfully for...Read More
Lauren Hoffman
Lauren Hoffman -Google user
a year ago
Went with a friend to look for a wedding guest dress and oh boy…found a Kate Spade green leaf fanny pack with super cute inside + a neon windbreaker + the dress . I could’ve stayed all day. Great selection and very reasonable prices. First...Read More
Cassie Hull
Cassie Hull -Google user
10 months ago
Such a cute shop. Very well organized. I'm guessing they're pretty selective about what they accept for consigning, but it makes for a good shopping experience. Some things are priced a little higher than I'd prefer for used items, but still...Read More
Dor R
Dor R -Google user
9 months ago
I have visited this shop for the first time for holiday shopping and must say that I am impressed by their inventory and quality. I was helped by a lovely woman named Lee, who was patient and very helpful in picking a perfect item for me. Will...Read More
Danielle Nahshon
Danielle Nahshon -Google user
9 months ago
Amanda exchange is the spot for all second hand pre loved Items. beautiful selection . Excellent customer service. Thank you Lee for your help and your patience. we will definitely be back when visiting Carmel Indiana.
Liraz Nahshon
Liraz Nahshon -Google user
10 months ago
This is the spot for all the people that love to shop . Amanda exchange has it all. Amazing products . Excellent customer service , clean organized space . Thank you Hannah S for providing excellent customer service at checkout. You made it fun and you put...Read More
Hannah Savage
Hannah Savage -Google user
9 months ago
Amanda’s Exchange has everything a girl could dream of! Shoes, purses, designer items, and home decor. The customer service was great, Lee was very friendly and put a smile on my face!
Marsha Coats
Marsha Coats -Google user
10 months ago
My daughter and I had fun finding incredible bargains of designer items, and Barb went out of her way to be helpful to us! Better customer treatment than anywhere else I've been lately! Thank you, Barb!
Ally Bright
Ally Bright -Google user
Edited 6 months ago
I love shopping here! It is such a nice consignment shop!! The staff is extremely helpful and kind. We came in looking for a wedding dress for a friend and even though we did not find one, it was a great time and the staff...Read More
Ruthie Hostetler
Ruthie Hostetler -Google user
8 months ago
Amanda’s exchange was an awesome place to thrift at, great finds. Thank you so much to Lee for helping me in the fitting room, she helped me find the perfect concert outfit. Thanks again!
Kerissa 8
Kerissa 8 -Google user
a year ago
My favorite consignment in the city! Women's clothes, formal wear, home decor, furniture, jewelry, bags, and now even kids clothes! Parking is easy and the store is clean, smells good, and the selection is quality! I love the AE!
Yifat Nahshon
Yifat Nahshon -Google user
9 months ago
Thank you Lee for helping us shop for last Xmas holidays gift at Amanda’s exchange . We had such a blast shopping here and definitely will be back on our next visit to Indiana .
Justin Deem-Loureiro
Justin Deem-Loureiro -Google user
10 months ago
Gillian F. was very helpful! She was able to help my mom around the store and answer all her questions. She was very, very kind and vivacious.
Cindy Seiler
Cindy Seiler -Google user
2 years ago
Absolutely love this store! Every time I go in there, it seems like they have added new categories of items to carry. It’s great to be able to shop, knowing you are getting high end, quality, merchandise at a fraction of retail prices.
Sonia Barillas
Sonia Barillas -Google user
11 months ago
I was being a tourist looking at other shopping centers and low and behold!!! I stumbled upon this GEM!!!!! A must see they have anything from lululemon to LV bags! Their Christmas merchandise is coming out daily!!!!

Features

From the business

check icon Identifies as women-owned
check icon Small business

Service options

check icon In-store pickup
check icon In-store shopping
Delivery

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings

check icon Buys used goods

Amenities

check icon Gender-neutral restroom

Crowd

check icon LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning

check icon Quick visit

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards
check icon NFC mobile payments

Other

check icon LGBTQ+ friendly
check icon Identifies as women-owned