Reviews (727) 527-7773 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Mahoney Auto Repair Inc. is an auto repair shop in St. Petersburg, FL.

Mahoney Auto Repair Inc. Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Pros

Mahoney Auto Repair Inc. is known for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, who take the time to explain repairs and provide honest estimates. Their prices are reasonable, and they offer a free shuttle service for customers. The shop is clean and well-organized, and they use high-quality parts for repairs.

Cons

Some customers have reported longer-than-expected wait times, and a few have experienced issues with communication regarding repairs. There have been some instances of higher-than-quoted prices, and a few customers have reported being charged for unnecessary repairs.

Review Rating Chart

Google: 4.4/5

Yelp: 4.2/5

Facebook: 4.5/5

Better Business Bureau: A+

Angie's List: 4.5/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.1
(91 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Robert Cunningham
Robert Cunningham -Google user
a year ago
I give 4 because they are good at finding the issues however be aware there are hidden costs and high labor costs. $37 service fee for paying with a debit card? I feel like this should be disclosed in advance. UPDATE My...Read More
Gabriela Miliano
Gabriela Miliano -Google user
a year ago
Friendly, Honest and Affordable family operated Car Repair Company. They were timely and responsive. I went on a recommendation and glad I took my car here. Consider to support local businesses like this. Thank you for a job well done in a timely fashion at...Read More
General repairs & maintenance
Erica Blosser
Erica Blosser -Google user
2 years ago
SHADY! I have photo/video evidence so don’t let him come to the comments and lie. He is a fake Christian, uses that coy to get business. We dropped off a vehicle overnight to get an estimate. Never got a written estimate. He called and gave...Read More
Gary
Gary -Google user
a month ago
Always an excellent mechanic very knowledgeable and fair
M K
M K -Google user
3 years ago
Bought a car from a "friend" and trusted him that the car is safe and sound to drive. Had issues with noises and too much oil in the engine since it was over serviced. Took it there and they dropped some oil and found the...Read More
Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism, ValueSteering & suspension repair, General repairs & maintenance, Oil change
Shir Kaduri
Shir Kaduri -Google user
4 years ago
This place is crooked and completely dishonest. My boyfriend took his car there. On the phone my boyfriend asked him how much a check up on a couple things would be - the owner didn’t say any price and just said in an hour and a...Read More
Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism, ValueService not listed
Eva Wigal
Eva Wigal -Google user
7 years ago
Took my car to get oil change done and some AC issues fixed. It was great service, the owner is very nice and helpful, fixed the AC (some kind of reset of the system issue). My car is older, with lots of miles and...Read More
Candice Johnson
Candice Johnson -Google user
a year ago
I have known the owner Elzie Mahoney for about 25 years He has always done right by me and his mechanics do a great job.Today at lunch time I went there with a battery problem...Read More
CanadianGirl 4ever
CanadianGirl 4ever -Google user
a year ago
Mr Mahoney maybe one of the few honest mechanics left!! He truly cares about serving his customers. I have found him to be honest and fair. He has served our family for many many years!
Veronica Millinghaus
Veronica Millinghaus -Google user
2 years ago
Went to Mahoneys for the first time. They had my car on a lift in no time, part in within an hour, car fixed and running great. I went in with no appt. They took great care of me and pricing was so reasonable. Would...Read More
hajirah Syed
hajirah Syed -Google user
3 years ago
They will pretty much lie to you and steal your money. Don't be fool with the owner being a Christian. They charged 800 dollars and once they were done said my car was ready and all good, the problem was still there and I took...Read More
Quality, Value
Lori Waggoner
Lori Waggoner -Google user
8 years ago
I have always had great experiences taking my vehicles to Mahoney's. I have been taking my vehicles to Mahoney Auto Repair for over 30 years and I've always got fair, honest service at reasonable costs. I highly recommend them for ALL your...Read More
Nicholas Vogelsang
Nicholas Vogelsang -Google user
2 years ago
Great spot for getting your car taken care of. Fair prices, fair people. They'll work around your priorities, keep you updated, and give you suggestions that make sense for your situation.
Randi Talsma
Randi Talsma -Google user
6 years ago
They have great service, kind people, they did an awesome job with my car and were more than fair on pricing. The work was straight forward and no hassle. They stayed true to what they said. 5 out of 5 would recommend!
Claire Hillyard
Claire Hillyard -Google user
3 years ago
If I could give negative stars I would. honest mahoney what a good cover. lol. does not stand behind what he sells you. my friend bought a vehicle from him, nothing but problems. in the shop all the time and now wants to...Read More
General repairs & maintenance, Engine repair, Air conditioning
Lionel Hargrove
Lionel Hargrove -Google user
a year ago
Surely was friendly and had a good quality of tires. I will recommend them to everyone I know.
Sky Ashley
Sky Ashley -Google user
4 years ago
My guy came here while we were traveling in Florida to get his AC looked at it. He spent 16hours over 2days outside with the guy doing the work. He went and got the parts himself and came back to the hotel with nothing to...Read More
zakkary whitelock
zakkary whitelock -Google user
8 years ago
If it was possible to give negative stars I would. First off he will only take cash for fixing any large issues. He won't take anything that leaves a receipt proving he did any work. I dropped my car off the have an oil leak...Read More
Elise Heal
Elise Heal -Google user
8 years ago
My 2500 Chevy truck almost didn’t make it to Mahoney’s. I was assured they would diagnose and repair my vehicle. In just a few hours the work was complete. Mahoney’s claimed the problem was just a faulty MAF sensor which they replaced. Only $224.00 and...Read More
Wayne F Landry
Wayne F Landry -Google user
10 months ago
Just my own personal opinion and I’ve been going here for Car Maintinence for several years. Ever since Tim left, there quality of repairs has spiraled down hill.

Features

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings

check icon Oil change

Amenities

check icon Mechanic
check icon Restroom

Planning

check icon Appointments recommended

Payments

check icon Debit cards
check icon Credit cards