What types of vehicles do you insure?

We insure all types of vehicles, including cars, trucks, motorcycles, and RVs.

Do you offer any discounts?

Yes, we offer various discounts, including multi-car, good student, and military discounts.

How do I file a claim?

You can file a claim by calling us or submitting a claim form on our website.

Can I get a quote online?

Yes, you can get a free quote online by filling out our quote form on our website.

Do you have a 24/7 claims hotline?

Yes, our claims hotline is available 24/7 for your convenience.

Reviews (219) 884-3547 Call Website Photos About

CLASSIC AUTO INSURANCE in Gary

Is this your business?

4.4 (214)

Auto Insurance Agencies

Call Direction Website Reviews

(219) 884-3547 Direction Website Reviews

About

CLASSIC AUTO INSURANCE is an auto insurance agency in Gary, IN.

CLASSIC AUTO INSURANCE Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Classic Auto Insurance at 4231 Cleveland St provides excellent customer service and competitive rates, with customers praising their friendly and knowledgeable staff. They offer a range of insurance options to fit individual needs.

Review Rating Chart

Google: 4.8/5

Yelp: 4.5/5

Facebook: 4.9/5

BBB: A+

Trustpilot: 4.7/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.4

(214 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Courtney Worley-White -Google user

2 months ago

The ladies were very nice & knowledgeable. We were in & out very quickly.

Lynn D -Google user

3 months ago

The service I received was pretty bad, I was charged a down payment on top of the monthly payment; not only that when calling to cancel my policy three months later, another agent had to help me (which is fine) but when asking for my...Read More

BlackStar Amv's -Google user

5 months ago

🤬 I just came from classic auto insurance today in Gary, Indiana. There is a woman named Marcia who quoted me $91 with insurance and tow. Over the phone which, I thought was a good deal until the person I spoke to just tried to...Read More

Denise Smith -Google user

11 months ago

Paid 600 for. A year and don't get a receipt.. pretty big payment not to get one emailed. . LOW AND BEHOLD I have a 2nd 600$ charge from American Freedom on a separate credit card now. HAD TO CANCEL MY CARD BECAUSE OF FRAUDYLEMT...Read More

joseph “That one scooter kid” johnson -Google user

a year ago

BIG SHOUTOUT TO-Bernadette,Haley,Dillion, and Amber took time to help me. I caused a mess up and they were super helpful, made sure they got it token care of. They answered all my questions. Classic has the cheapest insurance in town.

Jacqueline White -Google user

2 years ago

It is very reasonable as far as pricing. Very nice and friendly staff. Very cool and helpful. Knowledgeable and you understand exactly what you're getting, which is great how they tell you. Very detailed.

Mandy Timmerman -Google user

6 years ago

The lady who helped me while getting insurance made me and my son feel very welcomed. She had us in and out in a hurry so we were able to get on with our day. I will definitely recommend this place for insurance needs to...Read More

Monica Phillips -Google user

3 years ago

I purchased my insurance online right before I left for work and unfortunately got into an accident shortly after. I had called and asked them if I was covered and was told yes. I even placed in another payment but they did not process that...Read More

Hen Di -Google user

a year ago

DO NOT PARTNER WITH THIS INSURANCE, I GOT INTO AN ACCIDENT, I HAD LIABILITY INSURANCE AND IT WAS PAID MONTHLY THROUGH CLASSIC AUTO INSURANCE. THEY GAVE ME THE NUMBER TO THEIR CLAIMS DEPARTMENT WHICH IS A SCAM!! NOW I AM BEING SUED BECAUSE THEY...Read More

Jack Carter -Google user

9 years ago

Two years ago I made the decision to go with stated value insurance on my Ford GT. I called Classic and it was quick and painless. Then when my current insurance company found out I had a car not with them, they told...Read More

Desiree Washington -Google user

3 years ago

Sunny is the goat ,she was so patient with me and she understood the assignment when I told her I wasn't tryna to pay 600 for a 1,000 deductible I would definitely try here first

ynnavoig Guy -Google user

2 years ago

Pre-paid insurance is what you need to know. They have great pricing but your coverage is what you pay for so make sure to ask questions.

Sarah Jackson -Google user

4 years ago

Need more people to help service customers but the service was great. Good choice if you need to start over without a big name price tag.

Matt -Google user

3 years ago

Bernadette is the best I have been dealing with her for years all I gotta do make a call and she makes it happen number one

Timothy Brown -Google user

a year ago

Professional and friendly staff they do a great job for all your insurance needs this is the place to business with.

Tiffany McCullough -Google user

5 years ago

The people in my local classic insurance office are very nice and professional. However, the parent company “American Freedom” is unprofessionally, lazy, and when an accident actually happens, they give you a hard time paying out. Someone hit my car, we later found out we...Read More

Krystal Magliocca -Google user

4 years ago

I only call the one in Merrillville but i absolutely love them and the fact i went from paying 300 for insurance to 170 for both our cars highly recommend

Sharon Brown -Google user

2 years ago

Awesome customer service. Was paying more for liability in Texas than l am for full coverage in Indiana. Nice people.

Tiny C. -Google user

4 years ago

Always courteous. Always Polite. Callin to make a payment is like talkin to one of my Girlfriends. I Love the Customer service..

Chris -Google user

a year ago

One of the lowest prices in the state of Indiana only 55$a month for liability on a 94 civic

Features

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

People Also Search

Auto Insurance Agencies

CLASSIC AUTO INSURANCE in Gary

Contact

About