Reviews (305) 440-3650 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

What The Fish? Rolls & More, the premier Seafood restaurant in Tavernier, FL, offers a fresh catch of deliciousness in every bite. Located at 90775 Old Hwy Unit #6, our restaurant is a must-visit destination for seafood lovers. Indulge in our mouth-watering rolls and more, crafted with love and care to provide an unforgettable dining experience. At What The Fish? Rolls & More, we're passionate about serving only the freshest and highest-quality seafood, sourced locally whenever possible. Our menu boasts a variety of options to cater to diverse tastes and dietary preferences. From seafood enthusiasts to foodies, our restaurant is the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings. Join us for a culinary adventure that will leave you hooked! Visit us today and discover why we're the go-to Seafood restaurant in Tavernier.

What The Fish? Rolls & More Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.7
(705 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
G.
G. -Google user
7 months ago
Top notch lobster rolls in a wonderful hidden and quiet corner of the upper keys. We got caught in traffic exiting the keys , so found this place , stop and enjoyed the water views while dining on well prepared yummy rolls. The owner...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
emma peña
emma peña -Google user
3 months ago
A hidden gem in Islamorada that you simply can’t miss. The food is absolutely spectacular — incredibly fresh fish prepared with a Caribbean touch that makes every bite unforgettable. We tried the ceviche, the catch of the day grilled to perfection, the lobster roll, and the...Read More
Lunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talkNo wait
Leonardo Freytes
Leonardo Freytes -Google user
3 months ago
We were on our way to Key West and have chosen this place by reviews for a lunch stop. We are glad to found it! Alex is a great host and the food absolutely delicious. All the ingredients are fresh and tasty. Now is going to be...Read More
$20–30Atmosphere: 5Casa Mar Roll, Fresh Catch of the Day, Ceviche Del Mar3-4 peopleOutdoor patio / terrace
Laura 3355
Laura 3355 -Google user
8 months ago
What an amazing meal! Should be the name of the place. The owner gave a warm welcome, very passionate about his food and restaurant; you can feel it in the dishes. Fresh catch of the day fish, beautiful ceviche. Amazing lobster roll; pro tip: eat...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
Eva Cagwin
Eva Cagwin -Google user
a year ago
Outstanding lunch stop! Delicious fresh seafood rolls (sandwiches) - we had a Casa Mar (local catch) and a calamari roll. Flavorful and tender! The rolls were grilled to perfection. The owner was welcoming and so helpful. The small venue with outside seating only overlooking the canal was...Read More
Lunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Calamari Roll
Isabella Torres
Isabella Torres -Google user
8 months ago
The shrimp and crab rolls were great, we ordered a small side of calamari that was also good! The atmosphere and view were a great, plus some pelicans that came to visit while we ate!
Dine inLunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5Cast Away Shrimp Roll
Cedric Poupy
Cedric Poupy -Google user
2 months ago
As a French person with high expectations when it comes to quality and originality, I was absolutely not disappointed. Both the welcome and the food were excellent—this was truly a wonderful experience that will satisfy even the most demanding guests. To top it off, the...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
Roz Cavallaro
Roz Cavallaro -Google user
4 weeks ago
So happy we stumbled upon this place! The employees were so nice and helpful, they explained the whole menu. The food was incredible! So fresh and wonderfully prepared. Sitting outside by the water was so nice. Can’t wait to go back!
Lunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5
Claire Dunivan
Claire Dunivan -Google user
5 months ago
God this place was so good!! I got the daily catch platter and it was delicious. My husband got the fried fish sandwich and it was also delicious. The coleslaw had a slight curry flavor that was so tasty, and the fries were crispy on...Read More
Dine inLunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5Fish, Fresh Catch of the Day
Lara W
Lara W -Google user
4 months ago
The lobster roll and ceviche were amazing. Probably one of the best I’ve ever had! The service was also amazing, he was very welcoming and explained the menu to us. Definitely coming back here and would recommend.
$10–20Atmosphere: 5Lobster Roll, Ceviche Del MarNo waitOutdoor patio / terrace
Alejandra Acuña
Alejandra Acuña -Google user
3 months ago
The place is very nice, everything looks very clean. We ordered two lobster rolls and French fries to go, and everything was packed and served very well. The place is very pleasant and quiet, I would definitely come back to try something else.
$10–20Atmosphere: 5Walk-ins only
Giovanni Fnu
Giovanni Fnu -Google user
7 months ago
Stopped by this place for its quick, no frills service. The owner is so friendly, he greeted us and gave us a tour of his menu. They had an outdoor seating, overlooking the water. Everything we tried was delicious! Conch fritters, Mahi mahi tacos, and...Read More
Dine inLunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5Plenty of parkingFree parking lot
Yana P
Yana P -Google user
a month ago
Delicious, fresh, seafood and friendly, impeccable service. Lovely outdoor shaded seating area on the water. The kids enjoyed the best fish fingers we’ve ever tasted. My Maine lobster roll rivals the ones I’ve had in the northeast, and the corvina ceviche was so tasty. Can’t...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
Eddy Rodriguez
Eddy Rodriguez -Google user
a month ago
What a wonderful experience! From the moment you walk in, the staff makes you feel right at home with their warm and welcoming attitude. I truly can't wait to return and will be sharing this gem with everyone I know who visits the keys.
$20–30Atmosphere: 5Lobster Roll, Casa Mar RollQuiet, easy to talkIndoor dining area, Outdoor patio / terrace, Booth seatingPlenty of parking
Toni Nguyen
Toni Nguyen -Google user
2 months ago
We arrived about half an hour before closing and were warmly welcomed by the owner, who kindly explained the menu to us. We went with the lobster roll and the fried calamari — both were absolutely delicious. Highly recommended!
$30–50Atmosphere: 5
Rossana Torchia
Rossana Torchia -Google user
7 months ago
The best lobster roll I’ve ever had. Fresh, clean and the cilantro sauce on top was perfect! The owner has the greatest customer service! If you go to the Keys you must try it!
Atmosphere: 4
Jeremy Viveros
Jeremy Viveros -Google user
6 days ago
The lobster roll here was absolutely delicious — fresh, perfectly seasoned, and packed with tender lobster meat. You can tell they really care about quality and flavor. On top of that, the customer service was outstanding. The owner, Alex personally greeted us and went out...Read More
$30–50Atmosphere: 5
Caren Torrealba
Caren Torrealba -Google user
6 days ago
Tried the lobster roll and fish tacos here, and both were absolutely fantastic—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. The quality of the seafood really stood out, and it’s clear the owner takes pride in both the food and the customer experience. His warm hospitality...Read More
Lunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5Outdoor patio / terrace
Suzanne Reagan
Suzanne Reagan -Google user
a month ago
Stopped here on our way home from Key West. Daughter wanted Subway but was mildly ok when we told her no. 2 bites in to her AMAZING crab cake roll, she said this was one of the best things she’d ever eaten. My husband and...Read More
$10–20Atmosphere: 5Crab Cake RollQuiet, easy to talk
Marius Stoll
Marius Stoll -Google user
3 months ago
I had a fantastic experience at What the Fish? Rolls and More during my visit to the Florida Keys! The owner was incredibly friendly and took the time to walk me through the menu, explaining everything in detail — even how the dishes are prepared....Read More
$20–30Atmosphere: 5Suitable for all group sizesNo waitFree parking lot, Free street parking

Features

Service options

check icon Outdoor seating
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

check icon Fast service

Popular for

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible restroom
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Beer
check icon Cocktails
check icon Coffee
check icon Comfort food
check icon Healthy options
check icon Quick bite
check icon Small plates
check icon Wine

Dining options

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Dessert
check icon Seating

Amenities

check icon Restroom

Atmosphere

check icon Casual
check icon Cozy
check icon Trendy

Crowd

check icon Groups
check icon Tourists

Planning

Accepts reservations

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards
check icon NFC mobile payments

Children

check icon Good for kids

Parking

check icon Free parking lot
check icon Parking