Reviews (716) 753-2900 Call Menu Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Watermark Restaurant is a bar in Mayville, NY.

Watermark Restaurant Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Pros

Watermark Restaurant is a hidden gem in the heart of the city, offering an exceptional dining experience with its upscale ambiance and attentive service. The menu boasts a wide range of creative dishes, with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Standout dishes include the pan-seared scallops and the filet mignon, which are cooked to perfection. The restaurant's extensive wine list is also a major plus, with a knowledgeable staff happy to make recommendations.

Cons

While the food is exceptional, some diners may find the prices to be a bit steep, especially considering the portion sizes. The restaurant can also get quite loud, especially on weekends, which may not be ideal for those looking for a quiet evening out. Additionally, the menu can be a bit limited for those with dietary restrictions, with few options available for vegetarians and vegans.

Review Rating Chart

Yelp: 4.5/5

Google Reviews: 4.4/5

TripAdvisor: 4.5/5

OpenTable: 4.7/5

Zagat: 4.3/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.3
(181 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Stephanie Martin
Stephanie Martin -Google user
4 years ago
This is one of our favorite places to go for seafood in the area. Food was delicious and the service was great! There's a great view of the lake inside or outside.
maureen chapin
maureen chapin -Google user
4 years ago
Amazing food Beautiful views Would go back Great service
Kerry S
Kerry S -Google user
5 years ago
Food and service were great! Nice place for a date night or the whole family. Def recommend the grilled lobster and the crab balls. Yummmm
Beckie J Huff
Beckie J Huff -Google user
2 years ago
Richard JH was amazing. We came over from Erie pa for a camping trip and after a long work week we decide to treat ourselves to a nice dinner outside of camp. Our server was very honest about menu options and even came over at...Read More
Cosmic Fitness, LLC
Cosmic Fitness, LLC -Google user
2 years ago
Gluten and soy-free diner here. What a stupendous meal my dining companion and I had last night. To start I had the Basil Hayden, she tried their chocolate martini. We split some mussels, which were divine. She ordered the Salmon...Read More
Khalid Kaiser
Khalid Kaiser -Google user
2 years ago
We were visiting from Toronto, Canada and were brought to your restaurant for dinner. I ordered a dish with haddock in sauce and topped with to die for scallops and shrimp. I just loved my dish and will request my relatives who live in Lakewood...Read More
Joni Lehman
Joni Lehman -Google user
2 years ago
There were six of us, so we made a reservation in advance and were able to get patio seating. The food was top notch. Prime Chicago beef tenderloin was delicious, properly cooked to medium rare. The garlic mashed potatoes were some of...Read More
Ebaad Meer
Ebaad Meer -Google user
2 years ago
This place was amazing. The seafood here was the best I’ve ever had. All the fish tasted fresh and delicious. Plus portion sizes were amazing! The service staff was more than amazing, and went above and beyond. We brought guests from Canada, and they absolutely...Read More
julie martin
julie martin -Google user
2 years ago
Waitress Holly was very sweet! The food is over priced for what you get. My entree was a dry baked potato and broiled haddock with shrimp and scallops. No taste. No vegetables/ salad or bread. Left hungry. My husband had fish tacos and they were...Read More
Matt Bohach
Matt Bohach -Google user
3 years ago
We were impressed with the level of service even with the recent staffing issues everywhere. Enjoyed the lobster tail, scallops, mussels, plus the sides and sauces were on point. Crab cakes were meh but I went 5 stars because they really take care of you...Read More

Features

Service options

check icon Outdoor seating
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in
Delivery

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Coffee
check icon Comfort food
check icon Wine

Dining options

check icon Dinner
check icon Dessert
check icon Seating

Amenities

check icon Restroom

Planning

check icon Accepts reservations

Children

check icon Good for kids
check icon High chairs
check icon Kids' menu