Vinny's Pizza is a pizza restaurant in Waverly, NY.
Vinny's Pizza Review Summary
The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.
Reviews & Ratings
Leave a Review
4.8
(19 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]
Leave a Review
James Harder
-Google user
Edited 9 months ago
Reminds me of pizza back home!! Highly suggest! It is by far the best pizza in the valley!
Food:…
Jordan Weiskopff
-Google user
10 months ago
Not only did they deliver but delivered in a storm. When i called they were polite and courteous. The food was fantastic and genuinely authentic, great prices too. Will now recommend to anyone in the area.
DeliveryLunch$50–100Atmosphere: 5Pepperoni Pizza
Sabrina Evans
-Google user
a week ago
That smell you smell when you walk into a great pizzeria hits your nose the moment you walk through the door and you practically begin drooling..... that's what it was like when I walked into Vinny's!! I love that smell!! We ordered a large pie,...Read More
That smell you smell when you walk into a great pizzeria hits your nose the moment you walk through the door and you practically begin drooling..... that's what it was like when I walked into Vinny's!! I love that smell!! We ordered a large pie, half garlic ricotta (for me) and half pepperoni (for mom). The pie was made expeditiously and the wait time was so minimal. Everything was brought to our table. This pie is DELICIOUS!! The crust is perfect, the mozzarella tastes so fresh, the ricotta is creamy and delicious!! 5 stars all the way!! Definitely will eat here again! Dining area is neat and clean. Staff is friendly 😊 dang this pizza is good!!!
Matt Eberlin
-Google user
a year ago
Absolutely best pizza in town, it was inexpensive too. I feel like I walked onto a movie set for an authentic Italian pizza shop. The pizzas I ordered were pepperoni/cheese and buffalo wing pizza. Both were crispy and delicious I couldn’t have asked for a...Read More
Absolutely best pizza in town, it was inexpensive too. I feel like I walked onto a movie set for an authentic Italian pizza shop. The pizzas I ordered were pepperoni/cheese and buffalo wing pizza. Both were crispy and delicious I couldn’t have asked for a better new pizza shop. 🙏
Take outLunch$30–50Atmosphere: 5One of the older gentleman working said my 3 year old and 5 year old looked like little princess’s. Very kind and genuine.
The Dadalorian
-Google user
6 months ago
Our go to Sunday pie now. You get more than three pieces of pepperoni per slice like the competition. They deliver when they say and not 45 minutes to an hour late.
Atmosphere: 5
Jessica Perkins
-Google user
a year ago
Best pizza in the valley, hands down. Friendly, clean, delicious. 10/10.
Food: 5…
David Alliger
-Google user
a week ago
Nice to have a place in town that has a real NY style pizza. 🍕 the subs are also very good and garlic knots just hit the spot. Don’t change a thing.
Dine in$1–10Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talkIndoor dining area
Vinnie Carlineo
-Google user
a month ago
Best pizza around. They use quality ingredients and it shows. Great service. Nice to see a business like this that cares about what they are making. Ill be back and I would even go out of my way for pizza here.
Take outLunch$1–10Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talk
Isriah L.
-Google user
2 months ago
My new favorite pizza in the area!
Great big slices. A fair price. Fast service.
I think Vinny’s is going to be ruining my diet a lot now. LOL.
Keep up the awesome work!
Atmosphere: 4
Debbie Rumpff
-Google user
5 months ago
Fabulous food. Very fair prices. Excellent service. They treat you like family. Best pizza in valley. Subs amazing. Best rolls in town. Awesome total experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Preston Bradley
-Google user
6 months ago
The food is always on point and delicious! And the service is phenomenal with friendly conversations. Vinny's is my favorite place to grab a few slices of pizza or order a large pizza for the family
Take outLunch$1–10Atmosphere: 5Slice of Pizza
Dianne Holton
-Google user
3 months ago
Vinny and the employees were very friendly! Food was excellent! Will definitely go back! Vinny's is now my favorite pizza place in the valley!
Take out$20–30Atmosphere: 5
Travis Foster
-Google user
4 months ago
Lunch special is unbelievable. Nice undercarriage, plenty of toppings. My favorite pizza place outside of NYC
cullen nauta
-Google user
8 months ago
This is the trifecta!!!! It is without a doubt the most delicious pizza you'll get in the valley, It is by far cheaper than any other pizza establishment around and I cannot express how fast it is to get your order. This has become my...Read More
This is the trifecta!!!! It is without a doubt the most delicious pizza you'll get in the valley, It is by far cheaper than any other pizza establishment around and I cannot express how fast it is to get your order. This has become my …
GAREN ASATRYAN
-Google user
6 months ago
Vinny has the excellent Italian restaurant running making the NY style delicious pizzas and appetizers! Definitely recomended. GOD bless!
Jonah Geib
-Google user
6 months ago
Plebs who don't know NY Style pizza giving this place bad reviews made me want to try this place. Now I am a loyal customer and I don't have to go to LES for a good pie.
Isla Lowell
-Google user
7 months ago
I keep forgetting this place is here and really need to remember more often! this is a NYC slice, straight up. Nowhere else in this town comes close. Menu is small and to the point. Prices are great. As someone that attracts unwanted attention in...Read More
I keep forgetting this place is here and really need to remember more often! this is a NYC slice, straight up. Nowhere else in this town comes close. Menu is small and to the point. Prices are great. As someone that attracts unwanted attention in public around here, I felt really welcomed!
Jessie Rose
-Google user
3 months ago
Best tasting pizza in the valley! So incredibly happy it's not another pudges.
Nicki Bratz
-Google user
Edited 4 weeks ago
Great pizzeria! Jersey style thin crust. The real deal! Fuhgeddaboudit 😎🍕 …
razeon197
-Google user
Edited 10 months ago
Trust me I know good pizza and this spot actually uses a real pizza oven so u get that good crisp bite and perfectly cooked dough. It's a hard thing to get right the only better pizza is from nyc and that like 300 miles...Read More
Trust me I know good pizza and this spot actually uses a real pizza oven so u get that good crisp bite and perfectly cooked dough. It's a hard thing to get right the only better pizza is from nyc and that like 300 miles away. Compared to …
Restaurants
Hotels
Services
Stores
Lawyers
Health
Things To Do
Churches
Transportation
Walmart