As my daughter said, she would rate this place 10 stars if she could, and so would I. Let me start out by saying we’re from Buffalo, New York, we’ve got Italian restaurants all over and more than we can count. There isn’t a single...
Read MoreAs my daughter said, she would rate this place 10 stars if she could, and so would I. Let me start out by saying we’re from Buffalo, New York, we’ve got Italian restaurants all over and more than we can count. There isn’t a single place back home that could hold a flame to Tuscany! We found this little hole in the wall establishment two years ago by accident and it was the best mistake ever! Arrived into town a little unprepared, wanted Italian, everywhere near our Airbnb was full, but Tuscany was able to accommodate. Let me tell you, Marty (I think is his name), is the most genuinely sincere sever, host, and owner I’ve ever had the pleasure of being in the presence of! He has an unfathomable passion for his service level, his food, and his guests. I felt more at home here than the most expensive restaurants I’ve ever been to. The food is to dieeeeee for! The Cesar salad is undeniably the best I’ve ever had. The pasta and meat dishes are cooked to perfection! I came back for the second time yesterday, nearly two years later, and everything was exactly the same as before. Exceptional food, reasonable prices, unimaginable service, never been happier! My fiancé and I have pledged to come back every time we’re in town for a cruise and we promise that’ll happen!
Regarding negative reviews: they seat until 9pm or until the kitchen sells out, whichever is first. They have SEVEN tables! That means the dining area is small and the kitchen does not over prepare food. They take reservations and I suggest making one. If you don’t have reservations or plan to arrive later in the day, they will be out of some items on the menu. I’ve worked in restaurants before and an uncle of mine owns a small establishment so I know how hard it is to prepare food and when margins are thin because it’s small, there’s not much you can do. All I can tell you is that the negative reviews here are unreasonable.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Toasted Bread with Oil, Bruschetta, Tiramisu
Outdoor seating 
Restaurants
Hotels
Services
Stores
Lawyers
Health
Things To Do
Churches
Transportation
Walmart