Reviews (631) 390-5912 Call Website Photos About

The Hidden Gem Cafe in Melville

Is this your business?

4.8 (90)

Breakfast Restaurants Cafes Delis Lunch Restaurants

Call Direction Website Reviews

(631) 390-5912 Direction Website Reviews

About

The Hidden Gem Cafe is a breakfast restaurant in Melville, NY.

The Hidden Gem Cafe Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.8

(90 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

andres munoz -Google user

2 years ago

Awesome food and staff. Catering always arrived on time and ready to serve with minimal set up required. They even included utensils for serving and extra dressings. The in person location is also worth the trip to go to if you have time. Always greeted with...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Alberto Acevedo -Google user

2 years ago

I recently visited The Hidden Gem Cafe, and it truly lives up to its name. This cafe is an absolute gem that offers an exceptional menu. The standout item on their menu is "The Captain" sandwich, which surpassed all expectations. Additionally, their meal preps are outstanding—convenient,...Read More

Dine inBreakfast$10–20Atmosphere: 5

cassie nandalall -Google user

3 years ago

Amanda is amazing, the food was incredible. We had French toast with Nutella and strawberries and also a bacon egg and cheese. The hidden gem is truly a gem i can’t wait to return. Also check out there massive cookies!!!

Ry -Google user

3 years ago

Started with a philly and Panini and they were super tasty. Owners are so friendly and nice. Thanks for the cookie, it was also delicious! Will be back to try more of the menu ASAP.

Marisa Dobrev -Google user

Edited a year ago

This is SO good!! Also FYI they’re in the basement of the bank building. These prices are incredible for the quality of food you’re getting. Less than $5 for a huge egg sandwich?! Amazing! Can’t recommend enough. Will be back for sure. Edit: tried to leave...Read More

Take outBreakfast$1–10

Monday nineam -Google user

a year ago

The Sandwich I had there was just delicious, crispy toasted bread with layers of fresh ingredients, makes my day happier instantly with the extra cookies, just love it!

Lunch$10–20Atmosphere: 4

Angela Scolaro -Google user

2 years ago

I’ve been meaning to write this review since Cassidy and Amanda catered my daughter’s graduation party on Saturday. We had such a pleasant experience and I can’t say enough about how fresh and delicious the food was. We received such favorable feedback from...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Judith Marando -Google user

Edited 2 years ago

I used the Hidden Gem cafe to cater my backyard wedding in 2020 and am going back to have them cater my daughter’s first birthday party. The food is delicious & the cakes they make are absolutely incredible. They really are a hidden gem and...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Kate Kaplya -Google user

2 years ago

The place is was a little hard to find but their sandwiches are amazing!! The portions are huge for the price. Very tasty. The iced coffee was good also.

Take outBreakfast$10–20

Brice -Google user

8 months ago

Due to its rating , I walked over from the Marriott to give a try. Worth the effort . Food was great and staff even nicer. Asked for a special order which was accommodated with a friendly smile. It truly is a hidden gem...Read More

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Asked for a carnivore friendly meal which was gladly accommodated

Joseph Beauchamp -Google user

2 years ago

I have had the pleasure of dining at the Hidden Gem Cafe and having various meals catered by the Hidden Gem Cafe on numerous occasions. I can say that breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert are all super delicious. Breakfast sandwiches are delicious, and the French...Read More

DeliveryDinner$100+Atmosphere: 5

Kevin Mulligan -Google user

2 years ago

This place truly is a gem! They catered lunch for a large group that I hosted earlier this week. The sandwiches and wraps were absolutely fantastic and thankfully unlike the typically bland and tasteless wraps that I have received in the past from competitors. Everyone...Read More

DeliveryLunchService: 5

Ann-Marie Connor -Google user

2 years ago

I have been fortunate enough to have eaten here and to have catered parties from here. Food is always delicious! They make having an "occasion" easy. I have used them for an under 12 person party with very specific needs and...Read More

Take outBreakfast$10–20Atmosphere: 5Smoked Turkey Sandwich

Amanda Mazzurco-Wright -Google user

2 years ago

If I could give this establishment over 5 stars, I would!! The food is fabulous. They make a crunchy pickle wrap that is a pickle lovers dream. Their catering is off the hook. Hot food, cold food, baked goods - everything is amazing. You can't...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Desiree Gonzalez-Clickner -Google user

a year ago

Hidden Gem is a MUST for food. Me and my coworkers go multiple times a week here for breakfast and lunch. They also cater amazing food. Their prices are unmatched too!

Take outLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5

Nancy Wascura -Google user

2 years ago

This is truly a hidden gem for their food. This cafe is in the basement of an office building at 275 Melville Rd. It primarily services the office building workers, but we went there one day looking for a new place to eat based on...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Tiffany Phillips -Google user

2 years ago

Cass and Amanda are great! My company orders from them all of the time and I frequent them often for lunch. The cookies are amazing, the truffle shuffle is so unique and delicious, bang bang chicken is a hit, and I love the oriental salad....Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Scott Smith -Google user

a year ago

Almost shockingly good, we ordered a mix of lunch, breakfast, and sides, and everything was really good and tasted much fresher than your average deli. I wouldn't hesitate to order from here again. If you're wondering how to get there, take the elevator to the...Read More

Take outLunch$10–20Service: 5Plenty of parkingFree parking lot

gtl525 -Google user

2 years ago

Tom L. The Hidden Gem is amazing! I work in the building where they are located and I have had many lunches from The Gem, average of about 3x a week. In over a year, I have never gotten one bad lunch!! The Gem is always...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

David Bohorquez -Google user

a year ago

True hidden gem, hidden in office building, a gem due to the fact food was so well prepared and delicious. Staying at nearby hotel, found closest place on search, turned out to have great breakfast sandwiches. Wish they had a place in Florida where...Read More

Dine inAtmosphere: 5

Travis James -Google user

2 years ago

The Hidden Gem Cafe is exactly what this place is. The food and the service are second to none, for someone who likes to eat they know what they're doing. Amanda and her staff were so friendly and polite, and the food is reasonably priced....Read More

Loida -Google user

2 years ago

The Hidden Gem Cafe has never failed to surprise us with their great food and dessert! These ladies do an amazing job with their food and their desserts are amazing. Their off premise catering and pie/dessert stand in Long Beach during the …

Susan Dorsey -Google user

3 years ago

Wow. Prices here are super reasonable for off-premise catering even in this crazy economy. And the food will get you compliments at your party. I've also sent baked goods as corporate gifts and one client said they were literally the best …

Wade Pond -Google user

2 years ago

Hidden Gem is appropriately named! Ordered the classic wrap which was grilled. The wrap itself was light and the food content was very flavorful (ordered the classic wrap with crispy chicken, bacon and Russian dressing). Also, as a first …

Michelle Jensen -Google user

2 years ago

The Hidden Gem is our official caterer and we wouldn’t have it any other way! A true girl power establishment! The owners are amazing! Food is always on time, ALWAYS DELICIOUS! Never had anything I didn’t like! From cold foods to hot foods, breakfast, lunch...Read More

C D -Google user

2 years ago

The food is ALWAYS amazing. I have been doing business with them for years and these ladies are consumate professionals down to the smallest detail. I can assure anyone who reads "Sal Lominos review" that he is some jackass with a personal …

Angelina Aguilera -Google user

2 years ago

I cant say enough good stuff about this place. The friendly workers, the AMAZING quality food, the perfect prices for breakfast & lunch. My office orders from here almost once a week. .50 cookies are to die for! And french fries are always cripsy &...Read More

Steven -Google user

2 years ago

This place always exceeds my expectations, Amanda and Cassidy always go above and beyond to make sure the food and service is flawless. They’ve also catered for a few parties I’ve been to and it’s nothing short of perfect every time. The …

Thomas Galligan -Google user

2 years ago

The Hidden Gem is an absolute MUST HAVE for anyone looking for great food in the Melville area or anywhere. The quality of food they have far exceeds most of the local competition. I'm using them to cater all my gatherings as well!

Tamara Molina -Google user

3 years ago

Great little restaurant inside First Nation Bank building on the lower level. Has a few gluten free choices on the menu. I explained that my husband has Celiac Disease, so they washed down the prep equipment before making his food. The owners are also super...Read More

Features

From the business

Identifies as women-owned

Service options

Curbside pickup

No-contact delivery

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

Highlights

Great coffee

Popular for

Breakfast

Lunch

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Coffee

Comfort food

Healthy options

Quick bite

Dining options

Breakfast

Brunch

Lunch

Catering

Dessert

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Cozy

Crowd

Family-friendly

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

Other

Identifies as women-owned

People Also Search

Breakfast Restaurants Cafes Delis Lunch Restaurants

The Hidden Gem Cafe in Melville

Contact

About

The Hidden Gem Cafe Review Summary