citation network promo banner for desktop
citation network promo for mobile
Bipper Media rounded logo
Bipper Media logo
Restaurants iconRestaurants
American restaurantBarBreakfast restaurantCafeCatererCoffee shopFamily restaurantFast food restaurantHamburger restaurantMexican FoodMexican restaurantPizza restaurantRestaurantRestaurants with Outdoor SeatingSandwich shopTakeout Restaurant
Hotels iconHotels
2-Star hotel3-Star hotel4-Star hotelBed & breakfastCampgroundConference centerExtended stay hotelHotelHotels with SpasInnLodgeMeeting planning serviceMotelResort hotelRV parkWedding venue
Services iconServices
Auto insurance agencyBarber shopBeauty salonHair salonHome insurance agencyInsurance agencyLeak Detection PlumbersLife insurance agencyMarketing agencyMotorcycle insurance agencyNail salonPlumberRenter's insurance agencyRoofing contractorService establishmentWebsite designer
Stores iconStores
ATMBarber shopBeauty supply storeCar dealerCell phone accessory storeCell phone storeClothing storeConvenience storeDiscount storeGas stationGrocery storeHair salonHome goods storeUsed car dealerWalmartWomen's clothing store
Lawyers iconLawyers
AttorneyCar Accident LawyersCriminal Defense LawyerDivorce and Family LawDivorce lawyerDUI LawyersEstate planning attorneyFamily law attorneyLaw firmLegal servicePersonal InjuryPersonal injury attorneyPersonal Injury DoctorPersonal Injury LawPersonal Injury LawyersTrial attorney
...Others
Health iconHealthThings To Do iconThings To DoChurches iconChurchesTransportation iconTransportationWalmart iconWalmartCostco iconCostcoAlbertsons iconAlbertsonsAldi iconAldiSafeway iconSafewayMcdonalds iconMcdonaldsChick Fil A iconChick Fil AFedex iconFedexOlive Garden iconOlive GardenStarbucks iconStarbucksPublix iconPublixTarget iconTargetKroger iconKrogerBest Buy iconBest BuyWalgreens iconWalgreensCVS iconCVSDollar General iconDollar GeneralBars iconBarsBuy A Tree. Change A Life. iconBuy A Tree. Change A Life.
Reviews (845) 357-6556 Call Direction Photos About
Restaurants American restaurants New York Suffern Sutter's Mill
Sutter's Mill in Suffern

Sutter's Mill in Suffern

Is this your business?
4.2 (664)
Mon
11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Tue
11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Wed
11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Thu
11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Fri
11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Sat
11:30 am - 10:00 pm
Sun
11:30 am - 10:00 pm
American Restaurants Bars Bar & Grills Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Sandwich Shops
Restaurants American restaurants New York Suffern Sutter's Mill
Call Direction Reviews
(845) 357-6556 Direction Reviews

Contact

(845) 357-6556
View on Map

Sutter's Mill

214 NY-59, Suffern, NY 10901
Schedule Tour

About

Sutter's Mill is an american restaurant in Suffern, NY.

Sutter's Mill Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.2
(664 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
neyisha williams
neyisha williams -Google user
8 months ago
The chicken club was colossal!! The burger with Swiss was just delicious n juicy. The pickles r good 2. The coffee's not bad....didn't like the Buffalo wings. I asked 4 them 2 make them well done n boy did they! Lol, I did...Read More
$30–50Atmosphere: 4
Debby “Brew” Sherr
Debby “Brew” Sherr -Google user
3 years ago
'First time visiting Sutter's Mill, it's a great little find! The atmosphere is casual and fun, decorated for Halloween. The food was pretty good and the beer was frosty cold! The only thing missing is live music, that would be a nice touch! Dakota took our order,...Read More
Dine inBrunch$20–30While Sutter's Mill is popular for its burgers and wings, there are many selections that will satisfy the vegan!Bubblegum machines and Duck Diving game make it a cheerful place for kids.
John Arehart
John Arehart -Google user
3 years ago
Never noticed this place before, probably because it's on the end of a little strip mall at a busy intersection. It came up on my GPS so I tried it. Service was friendly and food was delicious. I had the French Onion Soup and a...Read More
Ann Saintilien
Ann Saintilien -Google user
3 years ago
Love this restaurant!! The people are the sweetest and the food is really good. Drinks are good too.
Dine inDinner$100+
Shawn Surma
Shawn Surma -Google user
a year ago
Really good little place. Staff was amazing. Out food was great.
Dinner$10–20Atmosphere: 5French Onion Soup, Sutters Famous Buffalo Wings
Jerry Paz
Jerry Paz -Google user
a year ago
The food was good as was the service.
Atmosphere: 5
Investigator K. Lynch
Investigator K. Lynch -Google user
2 years ago
Do not pass up this local gem. Burgers are amazing, juicy, flavorful, and are chock full of quality ingredients, the perfect mixture of beef, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, perched on-top of a bun that is buttery and toasted to perfection. The fries are...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
Kailey Cono
Kailey Cono -Google user
4 years ago
I absolutely love this place, it is my go-to. The portion sizes are great. Brian the bartender is the most extravagant human being of all time. I cannot think of a time I’ve ever been here without having a wonderful time. Highly recommend this spot!
Aurora C
Aurora C -Google user
Edited 6 months ago
Relaxing not crowded great atmosphere Their salmon is delicious as are those sweet potato fries!
Dine inDinner$30–50Atmosphere: 5Plenty of parkingFree parking lot
Edwin Betancourt
Edwin Betancourt -Google user
2 months ago
Great environment, food was delicious, service was fantastic! Had the Sutters double smash burger and that’s the definition of a burger. Sloppy, juicy, seasoned well and the sauce was the icing on it. Sweet potato fries and onion rings were great also. Karen provided excellent...Read More
Dine in$20–30Atmosphere: 510-30 minIndoor dining area, Bar areaSomewhat recommendClearly labeled vegetarian dishesPlenty of parkingFree parking lot
Francis Lopez
Francis Lopez -Google user
3 weeks ago
Always heard great things first time being there. Food and service were great it was empty and server noticed my brother and I watching the TV she came and asked if we wanted the volume on which doesn't happen often. Very kind of hee. Highly...Read More
Dine inAtmosphere: 5
Colleen Pope
Colleen Pope -Google user
a month ago
Wow amazing burgers 🍔 and wings. Went for Tuesday. 75 cent wings. Great friendly staff and fast service. Can't wait to go back and try more of the menu.
$30–50Atmosphere: 5Suitable for all group sizesNo wait
Jeff Guzman
Jeff Guzman -Google user
3 months ago
Excellent food. Love their wings and burgers,fries. Karen our waitress is awesome and Samara is incredible in the kitchen. Staff is great. In short it's a hidden gem. Go visit.
Dine in$10–20Atmosphere: 5No waitIndoor dining area
eli binshtok
eli binshtok -Google user
8 months ago
This is an surreal oasis of culinary magic! I walked in exhausted after a long day of work as a hospital nurse. I ordered a draft beer and wow the glass was ice cold, the beer was ice cold with perfect carbonation(very rare to find)....Read More
$10–20Atmosphere: 5French Onion Soup, Sutters Famous Buffalo Wings, Baja Fish TacosPlenty of parking
Jeff Cifichiello
Jeff Cifichiello -Google user
6 months ago
Had an awesome dinner with my family @ an old-time favorite place for Suffern. Shout out to Samara and the rest of the staff. Happy to see that Sutter's Mill is back and better than ever!
Dine inDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Cheese Burger Deluxe, Tacos and Nachos, Soft Taco, Waffle Fries, Cheeseburger Combo, Sutters Mill Burger
Beth Knowles
Beth Knowles -Google user
7 months ago
Had a great dining experience at Sutters Mill in Suffern last night. The new menu had a great variety of new choices . The Buffalo wings were just like I remembered them from years back. Our entrees were fish tacos, which were delicious.One w cod,...Read More
Dine inDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Sutters Famous Buffalo Wings, Baja Fish Tacos
Jim Foley
Jim Foley -Google user
9 months ago
Sutter’s Mill is back with Sam in the kitchen! Our dinner was great! Everything coming out of the kitchen looked delicious. Food is good quality and cooked the way you like it. My steak and wife’s burger were a treat to eat. We’ll be back...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
A L G
A L G -Google user
Edited 9 months ago
Same great place. The chili was even better than before! They are just getting started under new management, so no liquor license yet, and some new staff so have a bit of patience, you won't be disappointed.
Dine inDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 4French Onion Soup, Reuben Open FacePlenty of parkingFree parking lotkids menu with dessert included.
Mark “Jersey Mark” Jehan
Mark “Jersey Mark” Jehan -Google user
3 years ago
Good food with friendly service. I had a lovely cheddar cheeseburger with sauteed onions. Cook perfectly. The roll wasn't soggy from the juice of the burger. It came with steak fries which were great. The other diner in my body had it grilled chicken...Read More
Sierra Rinaldi
Sierra Rinaldi -Google user
9 months ago
Sutter’s is a great little casual joint! Amazing fries and fresh ingredients. Highly recommend!
$20–30Atmosphere: 5
David Liebergall
David Liebergall -Google user
6 months ago
Did takeout; their cheddar burger and wings are back like 5 years ago!!
Mike Dickinson
Mike Dickinson -Google user
5 years ago
I had the wings and chicken fingers both were crispy and delicious. My fiance had a burger and French onion soup. I tried those too. The burger was juicy and flavorful and the soup was very good not too salty and lots of cheese....Read More
Johnny Montauk
Johnny Montauk -Google user
Edited 3 years ago
Excellent quality above average "bar food" for sure! Filet Sliders are top notch. Burgers and Wings are staples. Many locals but feels very welcome there. Bartender is a great...I think she is the owner...Very attentive and friendly demeanour. Definitely going back!!
Jessica Murphy
Jessica Murphy -Google user
2 years ago
We took a little break from dinner at Sutters but after reading a review about the new kitchen we decided to try it again. Wow! We were NOT disappointed! The burgers were so delicious. They were big, …
Laura S
Laura S -Google user
2 years ago
Bar restaurant. Lots of bar food coices on the simple menu. At the corner of a small strip mall. Served quickly for a late lunch. Our waiter was very cordial and did a good job. Food was good and reasonably priced. I would recommend and...Read More
Scott Smith
Scott Smith -Google user
5 years ago
Been going to Sutter’s for over 15 years. I’ve stuck mainly to the wings, burgers and chili dogs during football season so I can’t speak to the entire menu. Although there is this butter cake that’s too good to turn down. Overall, decent …
Nick
Nick -Google user
7 years ago
Went here tonight for the wings and was not disappointed. 20 wings (I'm sure I was served over 30) and 3 coors light set me back $12...I paid more for that for a pint of beer in new York less than 2 hours earlier. The...Read More
TowerOfVape
TowerOfVape -Google user
Edited 3 years ago
This is a really good place to have lunch. The bar keep and wait staff are very welcoming and the choices on the menu are varied and plentiful. Affordable prices, quality dishes, and a home-like feel make this restaurant/bar a go-to place …
Andrew C
Andrew C -Google user
7 years ago
How do I love this place? Let me count the ways. I'm a big wing guy and this place has been the stalwart establishment for as long as I can remember. On top of it the staff is always cool and quick, and other food...Read More
Samuel Nazaire
Samuel Nazaire -Google user
Edited 6 years ago
I have been going here for years with friends because of the Monday Night football special. You can get wings under 50 cents and burger at $1! They have recently updated their menu and have some cool new options at a very reasonable price....Read More

Features

Service options

check icon Outdoor seating
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

check icon Fast service
check icon Great bar food
check icon Great cocktails
check icon Sports

Popular for

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible restroom
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Beer
check icon Cocktails
check icon Coffee
check icon Comfort food
check icon Food
check icon Food at bar
check icon Happy hour drinks
check icon Happy hour food
check icon Hard liquor
check icon Late-night food
check icon Quick bite
check icon Small plates
check icon Wine

Dining options

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Catering
check icon Dessert
check icon Seating

Amenities

check icon Bar onsite
check icon Restroom
check icon Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

check icon Casual
check icon Cozy

Crowd

check icon College students
check icon Family-friendly
check icon Groups
check icon Tourists

Planning

Accepts reservations

Payments

check icon Checks
check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards
check icon NFC mobile payments

Children

check icon Good for kids
check icon High chairs
check icon Kids' menu

Parking

check icon Free parking lot
check icon Parking

People Also Search

American Restaurants Bars Bar & Grills Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Sandwich Shops

Contact

(845) 357-6556
View on Map

Sutter's Mill

214 NY-59, Suffern, NY 10901
Schedule Tour

Related Search Suffern

Suffern American Restaurants Suffern Asian Restaurants Suffern Bakeries Suffern Bars Suffern Bar & Grills Suffern Barbecue Restaurants Suffern Breakfast Restaurants Suffern Brunch Restaurants Suffern Burrito Restaurants Suffern Cafes Suffern Caterers Suffern Chicken Restaurants Suffern Chicken Wings Restaurants Suffern Chinese Restaurants Suffern Cocktail Bars Suffern Coffee Shops Suffern Coffee Stores Suffern Delis Suffern Delivery Restaurants Suffern Delivery Services Suffern Diners Suffern Domino's Pizzas Suffern Espresso Bars Suffern Family Restaurants Suffern Fast Food Restaurants Suffern Hamburger Restaurants Suffern Health Food Restaurants Suffern Internet Cafes Suffern Italian Restaurants Suffern Japanese Restaurants Suffern Latin American Restaurants Suffern Lunch Restaurants Suffern Mediterranean Restaurants Suffern Mexican Foods Suffern Mexican Restaurants Suffern Pizza Takeouts Suffern Pizza Deliveries Suffern Pizza Restaurants Suffern Restaurants Suffern Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Suffern Sandwich Shops Suffern Seafood Restaurants Suffern Sports Bars Suffern Steak Houses Suffern Sushi Restaurants Suffern Taco Restaurants Suffern Takeout Restaurants Suffern Tex-Mex Restaurants Suffern Thai Restaurants Suffern Vegetarian Restaurants Suffern Wine Bars

People found American Restaurants by searching for…

Suffern Breakfast Restaurants Suffern Fast Food Restaurants Suffern Mexican Foods Suffern Mexican Restaurants Suffern Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Suffern Takeout Restaurants

Find best businesses

Texas Car Accident Lawyers