Reviews (631) 267-6700 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Stuart's Seafood Market Ltd is a seafood market in Amagansett, NY.

Stuart's Seafood Market Ltd Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.1
(55 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Jack Liu
Jack Liu -Google user
6 years ago
Nice cute place. Doesn't have crabs, but has a weight-based variety of lobsters. Has more than just the ordinary fish, mussels, and lobsters, like salads or steaks. Pricing is a bit expensive. Got a one and a half pound lobster and two pounds of mussels...Read More
Annabelle Haas
Annabelle Haas -Google user
6 years ago
Stuart Seafood Market has all the fixin’s for any foodie. Make this place your next stop when preparing your lobster dinner.. Well worth the visit! #shoplocal
El Pt
El Pt -Google user
8 years ago
Great place for fresh seafood. Clam chowder was delicious.
Sheila Kelley
Sheila Kelley -Google user
6 months ago
Small, quaint, off the much beaten and overly hyped hamptons scene. Stuarts has fresh quality seafood daily. Ask for their fresh catch so you aren't buying farmed fish. We had the sea bass last night and it was melt in your mouth fresh....Read More
Ira Nicanor Barnes
Ira Nicanor Barnes -Google user
3 months ago
Used to ship our catch into Fulton's Fish Market in NYC. After loading our catch while my dad filled out the paperwork, I would go into the shop getting lunch or dinner and it was always top notch! Everything is fresh!
William Sherman
William Sherman -Google user
a month ago
I shop at Stuart's several times a week. Every item is excellent.
Mark Smith
Mark Smith -Google user
5 years ago
If you're thinking anything seafood Stuarts is place . First and foremost they're good people. The seafood is always fresh, local, and if you want lobsters cooked and cracked you will not find better. they are open year round which is also great. I can...Read More
tracy sauers
tracy sauers -Google user
5 years ago
We LOVE Stuarts! Always super fresh seafood presented with a smile! I see al ot of peeps stating the prices are super expensive???? I do not feel that way, I feel that Charlotte's prices are right on for Market value. Keep up The great work....Read More
Rick Canter
Rick Canter -Google user
5 years ago
In these difficult times, Stuart’s is a lifeline to the world. Every week, we do curbside delivery of seafood and fresh produce. Last two nights, we had fresh bay scallops for dinner one night, and the previous night we had a 3 pound steamed lobster. All...Read More
Marcos Baladron
Marcos Baladron -Google user
8 years ago
Simply the best seafood shop in the Hamptons. My family's been coming here for years, and I won't shop anywhere else. Charlotte and Bruce run a great place. Great people. Best quality around. Try the Haddock, it's superb!
stephen sisco
stephen sisco -Google user
4 years ago
Great fresh seafood. We regularly buy clams preshucked on the half shell and have never been disappointed. Everything we’ve tried has been top notch. Is it pricey? Yeah I guess, but it’s the freaking Hamptons whattya expect?
Tyler Burcher-DuPont
Tyler Burcher-DuPont -Google user
4 years ago
Best seafood in town! Our go-to for years for fresh fish and cooked/cracked lobsters. I always recommend Stuart's to all our friends!
Peter Pfeffer
Peter Pfeffer -Google user
2 years ago
I am happy with the consistently fine quality and freshness of the fish I buy here. The prepared foods are also great.
David & Sherry Huiner
David & Sherry Huiner -Google user
3 years ago
Fantastic selection! Clam pies (a hyper-local). Possibly the best lobster bisque I've ever had!
John Weidman
John Weidman -Google user
8 years ago
Terrific fish, terrific people. Have been going here for years and will not buy fish anyplace else. If they have the Crab Bisque, buy it!
nate smith
nate smith -Google user
a year ago
Great service. Amazing seafood. …
Dror Etzion
Dror Etzion -Google user
a year ago
Delicious fresh seafood. Also salads and a bit of groceries. Friendly staff!
Jeffrey Bary
Jeffrey Bary -Google user
2 years ago
Freshest fish around and a great selection of local fish as well as from other locations.
Ygael Tresser
Ygael Tresser -Google user
8 years ago
Best seafood market in the Hamptons great quality service. From a chef for 20+ years
Katie Miller
Katie Miller -Google user
8 years ago
Love this place! Freshest seafood you can find in Long Island

Features

Service options

check icon Curbside pickup
check icon No-contact delivery
check icon Delivery
check icon In-store shopping

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Payments

check icon Debit cards
check icon NFC mobile payments
check icon Credit cards