Reviews (718) 388-8338 Call Website Photos About

Shelter in Brooklyn

Shelter in Brooklyn

Is this your business?

4.3 (1026)

Argentinian Restaurants Cocktail Bars Pizza Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings

Call Direction Website Reviews

(718) 388-8338 Direction Website Reviews

About

Shelter, a vibrant Pizza restaurant, Argentinian restaurant, and Cocktail bar, is nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, NY. Located at 168-170 Wythe Ave, Shelter offers a unique dining experience that combines the flavors of Argentina with the classic charm of a New York pizzeria. Indulge in our signature Pizza dishes, crafted with love and care, using only the freshest ingredients. Our Argentinian-inspired menu features a range of mouth-watering options, from tender grilled meats to savory empanadas. Unwind with a craft Cocktail at our trendy bar, where our expert mixologists will guide you through a menu of innovative drinks. Whether you're in the mood for a classic margarita or something more adventurous, we've got you covered. At Shelter, we're passionate about providing exceptional service, delicious food, and a warm atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Join us for a memorable dining experience in Brooklyn's vibrant Wythe Ave neighborhood.

Shelter Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.3

(1026 Reviews)

5

4

3

2

1

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Liz Przy -Google user

2 years ago

I love this place. The log cabin interior transports you, the fire place is cozy in winter, the empanadas and anything else from their coal fire oven are memorable, and I really enjoyed the Italian wine they had available by glass last time I went....Read More

Juan Gutierrez -Google user

4 years ago

What a lovely place and great atmosphere. The outdoor seating for Covid is stupendous! Large, socially distant, plants, umbrellas or a giant plastic roof. Bottles of hand sanitizer on every table. The food was delicious! Empanadas were so good. I had to try the skirt steak...Read More

Nancy Cavazos -Google user

Edited 2 years ago

Such a cozy place!!! We had a charcuterie board to start and then we had the parrillada, both were delicious! Their bread was very yummy, I assume is same dough they use for the pizzas. The staff is so great and super friendly!!! We came back and we loved...Read More

Dine inDinner$50–100

m h -Google user

a year ago

Turned up about 20mins before they're supposed to open and they let me and a lesbain couple in. Really friendly service, fire place and wood fired pizza oven. Interesting decor, nice place to chill out in.

$30–50Atmosphere: 5Burrata & Prosciutto

Mildred Bodden (Milly B) -Google user

6 years ago

I had a lovely time here! The atmosphere is very warming and romantic. The light was very dim but in a way that it creates a lovely aura to the room. Though there isn't any central air, it was well ventilated and I never felt...Read More

Jingo Mante -Google user

4 years ago

The mushroom, goat cheese, and kale arepa is insanely delicious! The warm gin punch was a great way to start my Saturday afternoon...highly recommend it...it’s tart, warm, and very gin forward LOL 🤪 Pizza was pretty good, too. Crispy crust. Fresh cheese. My dog also...Read More

G. López -Google user

a year ago

When you go through the door you feel like you are entering a cabin in the middle of La Patagonia, Argentina. You should try the beef empanadas! Delicious, it worth every cent!! As an argentinian living abroad for many years, this place was a...Read More

Dine in$20–30Atmosphere: 5

Steve Blake -Google user

6 years ago

Fun bar and restaurant. Seems to be one of the most buzzing places in Williamsburg these days, as it’s frequently full and hard to get a sit at night and weekends. Never ate there unfortunately, but the cocktails that I tried were pretty good and...Read More

Thomas Ho -Google user

8 years ago

Truffle Mac and cheese was great, the quatro formaggi pizza was amazing, and the skirt steak was cool to a perfect medium rare (it needed a bit is salt). The empanadas were excellent, but maybe a bit over priced. The service was excellent and the...Read More

isaac sanchez -Google user

5 years ago

What a really nice place!!!! gf and I came here for a quick bite but we ended up ordering drinks and food. Their pizza is amazing and staff is super friendly and helpful. I wish I knew the name of our server but he...Read More

Alon hergenhan -Google user

3 years ago

As visitors to Brooklyn we met and old freind here, and it was perfect! The wate staff were very knowledgeable and pleasant, the environment was charming, and pizza was fantastic.. great place to talk with freinds, over good food and drinks.

Dine inDinner$20–30

Andres Blanco -Google user

4 years ago

Vintage decorations and tasty food! The pizza truffle is amazing, empanadas… OMG.. delicious highly recommend this restaurant.

Dinner$30–50

Stacey Sterling -Google user

2 years ago

This place was a delight. Went here for the first time on a date night and it was amazing. The ambiance was very nice and the music selection 👌 Food was good and drinks was just right.

Dine inDinnerAtmosphere: 5

Elisabeth Hediger -Google user

6 years ago

This place is so cute!! I didn’t get to try their pizza but the hummus & cauliflower and kale salad were great! The interior is rustic and open and little outside seating area was great for people watching. Need to go back and try their...Read More

Andres Hernandez -Google user

2 years ago

Lovely ambiance! The food was fantastic. I recommend the skirt steak. The sailor gin and tonic is lovley.

Milly P. -Google user

a year ago

This is my favorite pizza place in Williamsburg. It’s pet friendly, the atmosphere is amazing, servers are super nice and pizzas are unbelievably delicious. My favorite is Quattro Stagioni. Very close to European style pizza. And yea, they have great wine selection as well!

Dine inDinner$30–50Atmosphere: 5Burrata, Burrata Salad, Truffle Mac & Cheese, Burrata & Prosciutto, Cod Croquettes

Dylan James -Google user

4 years ago

This place was fantastic! We had some small bites and drinks and everything was wonderful. Friendly and attentive staff, beautiful location, and ample indoor and outdoor seating available. The menu has something for everyone, but I really loved their burrata! The pizzas were delicious as...Read More

Pablo Gonzalez -Google user

Edited a year ago

Been here more times that I can remember. Love this place, food and service are always perfect! Their empanadas and pizzas are to die for. Also the desserts. Great selection of beer and we'll stocked bar, everything in a very trendy country atmosphere. Will definitely...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Matthew Neubek -Google user

2 years ago

Dinner was good and drinks were great at this unique bar / restaurant. It's 80% bar and 20% restaurant, in my opinion. But their food options are way above average for a bar. We had a pizza, two empanadas, and the day's special Truffle Burger...Read More

Dine inDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Empanadas Argentinas, Ham & Cheese Empanada

Gaston Eguigorry -Google user

2 years ago

It’s not fair that I write a review to Shelter since I been here more than 100 times! I love the food, the ambience, the service and the price! Everything about this place it’s perfect! The empanadas are to die for! The fire place during winter invite you...Read More

Features

Service options

Outdoor seating

Curbside pickup

Delivery

Dine-in

Takeout

Highlights

Fast service

Fireplace

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible seating

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Comfort food

Happy hour drinks

Hard liquor

Late-night food

Quick bite

Small plates

Wine

Dining options

Brunch

Lunch

Dinner

Dessert

Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Cozy

Trendy

Crowd

College students

Groups

Tourists

Planning

Dinner reservations recommended

Accepts reservations

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

High chairs

People Also Search

Argentinian Restaurants Cocktail Bars Pizza Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings