Reviews (716) 297-8442 Call Website Photos About

Sammy's Pizzeria in Niagara Falls

Sammy's Pizzeria in Niagara Falls

Is this your business?

3.9 (883)

Banquet Halls Bars Caterers Italian Restaurants Pizza Deliveries Pizza Restaurants

Call Direction Website Reviews

(716) 297-8442 Direction Website Reviews

About

Sammy's Pizzeria is a banquet hall in Niagara Falls, NY.

Sammy's Pizzeria Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

3.9

(883 Reviews)

5

4

3

2

1

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Robert -Google user

2 years ago

Deep dish pizza sesame crust. Would get regular next time. Good pizza though. Nice portion of toppings. The Greek salad was great. There is a bar inside and dining but didn’t eat in. So had to give 3 stars for atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 3

Chia-Yi Cheng -Google user

5 years ago

I heard about this place from a local who grew up in the neighborhood. As a visitor I can't wait to follow locals' recommendation and that was a smart move. This pizzeria is full of character. The dough for specialty pizza is soft, medium thick,...Read More

Larry Paletta RE/MAX Escarpment Homes For Sale -Google user

2 years ago

If you want to go back in time then Sammy’s Pizzeria in Niagara Falls, New York is the place. Pizza after the bar scene in the 90’s Baby!! The Photos, The Chairs, The Carpet, The Garbage Can in the Dining Area…. The Pizza is Classic...Read More

Dine inDinner$20–30Buffalo Wings, Cheese and Pepperomi Pizza Slice, 1 2 Tray Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza

Rhonda Steines -Google user

a year ago

Although in an old area of town, the pizza itself was delicious with great flavors, baked perfectly. Service was just okay, atmosphere was okay, but very warm inside on a hot day, not real comfortable. Would have the pizza again. Beware the mediums are more...Read More

Atmosphere: 4

Amarjit Dhamrait -Google user

6 years ago

A local dive bar that serves amazing pizza. The Alfredo chicken pizza was outstanding. Huge chunks of moist chicken, the dough is made fresh and the crust was easy to eat. The traditional Buffalo wings were big. The price is really good for such good...Read More

K Bennett -Google user

Edited 2 years ago

We had a great time at Sammy's! Excellent pizza and friendly staff. Family owned & operated! Highly recommend if you find yourself in Niagara Falls!

Atmosphere: 5

Johnny Lebda -Google user

3 years ago

The food is great and our waitress, Robin was the best. We had fried zucchini which was out of this world, we also had a medium cheese and capicola pizza was the best I've had since I move from The Bronx to California. They...Read More

Shin O -Google user

a year ago

You can find pure American vibes here. Our waitress Crystal was extremely friendly and helpful. We had an amazing dining experience at Sammy's 💖

$10–20Atmosphere: 5

Jim Beaver -Google user

Edited 2 years ago

Been since the start of covid since we've been to Sammy's. Living in Kitchener Ontario the pizza selection is quite poor we've been making our own. Yesterday we took our first trip to the States for an overnight stay. We had Sammy's the night we...Read More

Dine inDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Buffalo Wings, 1 2 Tray Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza, Medium Wings Meat Pizza

Aaron Spinney -Google user

10 months ago

Best wings, amazing pizza. Great bar. Love it. It's a must stop for me every time I'm close.

Take outAtmosphere: 5

OneLowTime Delivers -Google user

a month ago

I love my food from Sammy's. Tonight I was given this Cajun Chicken Alfredo to try, and my taste buds are still excited and I finished eating 30 minutes ago. It was so good. My parents said they make the best Gluten Free Pizzas that...Read More

Take outDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 4Suitable for all group sizesSomewhat recommendNot sureDelicious Gluten Free pizzas 🍕Plenty of parkingFree street parkingDefinitely park in the street, on Pierce or Hyde Park. Please don't block the parking lot driveway, that's for us delivery people.

Sean Carter -Google user

Edited 8 months ago

Went to Sammy's for a pregame meal on our way over to Sabres game based on a recommendation. We live in nearby Niagara, ON and are always looking to try different pizza & wing spots in NY. Sammy's lived up to the amazing reputation &...Read More

Dine inDinnerAtmosphere: 5Chicken Wings, 1 2 Tray Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza

Haley Whelan -Google user

a year ago

Had a wonderful experience after visiting Niagara Falls. Food was almost as amazing as my server Crystal who was so kind and attentive. Also the endearing small town American vibes made it a wonderful escape from the tourist traps at Niagara Falls.

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5

Mike O -Google user

Edited a year ago

Update: went again last night before a hockey game and the food was great, only issue was the pizza took an hour and we almost had to pick it up after the hockey game. The waitress was amazing and offered to bring us...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Ronak -Google user

a year ago

If anyone is saying don’t try their food, just don’t listen to them. It is truly a hidden place in Niagara Falls. I loved their garlic bread and veggies pizza. Never disappointed

Mike Mazzolino -Google user

6 years ago

Nice people, predictable place, you always know what you're getting. Great pizza and wings, always consistently good. And if they say it's ready in 30 minutes, it will be ready in 30 minutes. Oh, and they have Rolling Rock. Last thing.... Canadian money @ par

Bald -Google user

a month ago

Visiting Niagara Falls, ordered pizza and wings for delivery to our hotel. Deep dish was fantastic, crust to die for, wings were very good too, meaty and crispy! Delivery guy was great, right to our hotel room. Highly recommend!

DeliveryDinner$20–30Service: 5Suitable for all group sizes

Joshua Edwards -Google user

2 months ago

Im not sure if they got all new staff at night or what but they are far much better here than they used to be now. The food is always done right now, the staff is super friendly. Even last night when my order was...Read More

Take outDinnerAtmosphere: 52 people

Bonzo -Google user

2 months ago

Haven't been to the USA/Sammy's in 12 years. They still make the best steak sub I've ever tried. Ate that there and took a 1/2 tray to go. Both excellent.

Dine inLunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5

Josh Staniszewski -Google user

a month ago

This place just made me one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Cheese pie, sweet sauce, well done, garlic butter crust. Get one now.

Food: 5

Terri Bergan -Google user

4 months ago

I’ve been coming to Sammy’s from Ontario for coming on 40 years. It’s Iconic. Things have changed, that’s for sure, but the pizza and wings are still excellent. I just wish my Canadian dollar went farther.

Atmosphere: 5

Jeanette Tascarella -Google user

a month ago

I go for the fish fries most Fridays.Or Saturdays, the fish fries are phenomenal not to mention.They are next door neighbors.Very good people.Everybody loves sammy and his wife

Take outAtmosphere: 5

TIFFANY HALE -Google user

a month ago

Visited from Pittsburgh. Food was delicious. Tried the sausage hoagie, pizza and wings. Definitely didn’t disappoint!!!

Take outDinner$1–10Atmosphere: 53-4 people

austin diana -Google user

9 months ago

My boyfriend and I came to visit late night because we were starving and this place was perfect! Cozy friendly atmosphere inside. We ordered some slices, wings and a gyro. All were delicious! We played darts and enjoyed our time. Just a nice place to...Read More

Gary Alexis -Google user

Edited 8 months ago

The food usually always good. If you order more than one thing to go, there usually is a issue. There timing for finishing more than one order, poor. Example a pizza and wings. They may have your pizza done. So they stick it on top...Read More

John Maikranz -Google user

4 months ago

Excellent food and service, we had a party of approximately 50 people and were able to arrange a room with only a few hours notice.

Telemakus Macgruber -Google user

4 months ago

Best wings I’ve had, always on point, pizza is in matched in the area. Always stop in when I’m in town!

Jeffrey Nowak -Google user

6 months ago

Sammy's is one of the best places in Niagara Falls to get pizza. They never disappoint. The price is reasonable.

dave nimke -Google user

3 months ago

The food was excellent and our server was great. I highly recommend Sammy's!

Sodomandkimura -Google user

a year ago

Fantastic pizza. I tried the red sauce and the sweet sauce. Both were excellent. My sons and I have made it a hobby to try as many pizza places as we can since moving to wny. Which there are no shortage of fantastic places around...Read More

Features

Service options

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Sports

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Comfort food

Happy hour drinks

Hard liquor

Late-night food

Quick bite

Small plates

Wine

Dining options

Lunch

Dinner

Catering

Dessert

Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Cozy

Crowd

College students

Groups

Tourists

Planning

Accepts reservations

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

High chairs

Kids' menu

Parking

Free street parking

Parking

People Also Search

Banquet Halls Bars Caterers Italian Restaurants Pizza Deliveries Pizza Restaurants