Reviews (718) 885-0920 Call Website Photos About

Sammy's Fish Box in Bronx

Sammy's Fish Box in Bronx

Is this your business?

4.3 (10116)

Bars Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Seafood Restaurants

244 Images

Call Direction Website Reviews

(718) 885-0920 Direction Website Reviews

About

Sammy's Fish Box is a bar in Bronx, NY.

Sammy's Fish Box Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.3

(10116 Reviews)

5

4

3

2

1

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Lady Vaughan -Google user

a week ago

Everything was very good. We had a really large party and the food was served in a timely manner and perfect temperatures.

Dinner$50–100Atmosphere: 5Moderate noiseNo waitPlenty of parkingFree parking lot

Franny Bae -Google user

3 months ago

This place was pretty big. Very specious with different seating arrangements to accommodate various party sizes. We were a party of 13. The food was descent service was good. Nice vibe. Drinks was good. Lemon drop get you lil litty.

$50–100Atmosphere: 5Loud, but you can still talkNo waitIndoor dining areaPlenty of parkingKids welcome

Latin Impulse Magazine -Google user

Edited 6 months ago

Update March 9, 2025: Today’s lunch with my son was outstanding, thanks to our waiter William, who has been serving me for over 20yrs. His hospitality and professionalism as a waiter is outstanding and few can be compared to him in the restaurant business. His...Read More

Dine inLunch$100+Atmosphere: 5Sammy's Shrimp PannigianaPlenty of parkingFree parking lot

Michelle Marquez -Google user

Edited 3 months ago

if you are looking for a true seafood experience this is the restaurant for you, we ordered “Our Fabulous Feasts for 2” but it is actually so big that it could easily fit 4 people, the lobster and crab legs were super fresh and juicy,...Read More

Dine inDinner$100+Atmosphere: 5

Shani Stanley -Google user

4 months ago

Our server was amazing, the food was plentiful, the staff was pleasant, and the vibes were high. It was my second time back in the past 2 years. This time, we came to celebrate my Mom's 70th bday. She was happy. Thank you so much...Read More

$30–50Atmosphere: 5Loud, but you can still talkNo waitSeafood restaurant.Plenty of parkingValetPlentyHi-chairsGround floor.

Marino Corniel -Google user

6 months ago

Although life is getting harder with the bad economy, Sammy’s meals are a healing delight. I enjoy the interaction with all the servers there always so sweet and the place is always busy and the food is great. I love the ambiance and interactions with...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Nicole Nicole -Google user

11 months ago

Consistently good food with generous portions. Food is well seasoned. Each table gets a starter with salad, garlic bread, a crusty loaf, cornbread and pickled vegetables. Service is fast and in addition to standard sides, yellow rice and corn on the...Read More

Atmosphere: 4

happiness is a journee -Google user

8 months ago

If you're looking for a dining experience that delivers on quality, service, and great prices, look no further than Sammy’s Fish Box. Located in the heart of City Island, this gem of a restaurant consistently impresses with its standout dishes and a welcoming atmosphere. One of...Read More

Dine inDinner$30–50Atmosphere: 5Sammy's King Crab & Lobster Feast, Fish Box, Sea Food, Snapper, Kid's Hamburger Platter, Snow CrabPlenty of parkingFree parking lot, Free street parking, Valet

Frugal Cyclist -Google user

Edited 4 months ago

OUTRAGEOUS SHRIMP 🥇🥇 Cycled 45 miles here. Saw the $15.95 advertised poster and got drawn in. WOW 🤩 WOW 🤩. 10 Jumbo sized shrimp lightly fried. Succulent & seeping with flavor. Came with extra large fries, a coleslaw salad & pickle slice. Tremendous value 👍👍. Good for 2. I must...Read More

Take outLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 4Plenty of parkingFree parking lot

Aracelis Martinez -Google user

a month ago

My 2nd time here , so good the food and nice atmosphere ❤️😍

Atmosphere: 5

Danak D -Google user

a year ago

I had dinner here with a group of family members recently and were seated at our reserved time at 6:15. We were waited on by Ahmad, who was very helpful, gracious, and accommodating. I was thoroughly surprised by the food portion!! It's a good thing...Read More

Dine inDinner$50–100Atmosphere: 5Sea Food, Corn Bread, Salad with French DressingPlenty of parkingValetValet parking is available across from the restaurant and is free if you get your ticket stub validated by the restaurantThe mac and cheese you see listed is what pur 4 year old ate and enjoyed. Of course, she couldn't eat all of it.

Jishan Chowdhury -Google user

2 years ago

The staff is really what has me coming back to this location few time, and has a great set of people, they are wonderful and so sweet and always working hard!!! It wasn’t super busy at this location on Thursday and the employees are...Read More

Dine inDinner$20–30Fish Box, Corn Bread, Yellow Rice and Corn on the Cob

Vito -Google user

3 months ago

Upon entering, we were greeted warmly and given our choice of seating. (It was not that busy.) Waiter patiently brought water and waited. He saw we were enjoying the atmosphere and looking at the menu. Bread and some items of carrots, sweet peppers cheeze were...Read More

Atmosphere: 4

Pamela Smith-Watson -Google user

2 weeks ago

Loved the seafood options and everything was served hot, tasty and plentiful. Ordered calamari, crab legs and lobster tail combo with salad and loaded baked potato. The drinks were great too. Our waiter was very nice and professional.

Dinner$100+Atmosphere: 5Reservations not requiredQuiet, easy to talk

Jacklyn Nappiere -Google user

a month ago

Food was great! Prices were reasonable. At first service was slow but in their defense the place was packed so can't be too hard on them about it. Once server came out the quality of service was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Brian Granoff -Google user

3 weeks ago

Love the broiled seafood platter and linguine with red clam sauce - fun decor & cool experience. Definitely a cultural landmark on City Island!

Atmosphere: 5

valerie lester -Google user

a month ago

Love Sammy's, I've been going for years. Took my son for the first time, he loved it. Food was great, served in abundance, I always have leftovers. Service was excellent, my waiter was very attentive. And the atmosphere was lively but not loud. Absolutely...Read More

Dinner$50–100Atmosphere: 5Moderate noise2 people

Eboni Dabbs -Google user

2 months ago

Hubby and I been here a few times..but Sammy's Fish Box is a treasure on City Island. The service and atmosphere is great. You cannot ask for a better, dining experience. The seafood portions are large, definitely great value for your meal.

Dinner$100+Atmosphere: 3Moderate noiseIndoor dining area, Outdoor patio / terrace

Lance Vascones -Google user

6 months ago

My wife and I had the king crab legs and lobster tail combo. It was seasoned to perfection. The butter was a bit salty, but an employee went back and melted some small packs of butter for us. Honestly, the way the food was seasoned,...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Jennifer Kellenbenz -Google user

2 weeks ago

First time ever going here & I enjoyed it. Food was delicious and fresh. The portion sizes are huge. Liked that they gave us a nice cold salad, garlic bread, half a loaf of some good Italian bread, a wedge of cheese, & some...Read More

Lunch$30–50Atmosphere: 5No special eventNo wait

Features

Service options

Outdoor seating

Curbside pickup

No-contact delivery

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Great dessert

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Comfort food

Happy hour drinks

Happy hour food

Hard liquor

Healthy options

Late-night food

Quick bite

Small plates

Wine

Dining options

Brunch

Lunch

Dinner

Catering

Dessert

Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite

Restroom

Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

Casual

Cozy

Historic

Romantic

Trendy

Crowd

College students

Family-friendly

Groups

LGBTQ+ friendly

Tourists

Transgender safespace

Planning

Accepts reservations

Usually a wait

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

Good for kids birthday

High chairs

Kids' menu

Parking

Free parking lot

Parking

Valet parking

Pets

Dogs allowed outside

Other

LGBTQ+ friendly

People Also Search

Bars Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Seafood Restaurants