Reviews (973) 895-3434 Call Website Photos About

Rosie's Trattoria in Randolph

Name: Rosie's Trattoria in Randolph
Address: 1181 Sussex Turnpike, Randolph, New Jersey, 7869, US
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.5

Is this your business?

4.5 (767)

Banquet Halls Bars Catering Food and Drink Suppliers Event Venues Family Restaurants Fine Dining Restaurants Italian Restaurants Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Seafood Restaurants

36 Images

Call Direction Website Reviews

(973) 895-3434 Direction Website Reviews

About

Rosie's Trattoria is a banquet hall in Randolph, NJ.

Rosie's Trattoria Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.5

(767 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Timothy Potter -Local Guide

a year ago

Best Italian place around Randolph. Great atmosphere, attentive staff, and wonderful food. Rosie greeted our table herself, discussed the specials, and made suggestions. My wife had the seasonal butternut squash soup. It was amazing. She also had pumpkin ravioli. Each ravioli was stuffed...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Christina Aiazzone

a year ago

Casual restaurant with an upscale feel. From the moment we walked in the service by all was outstanding. A friend recommended this place and my only regret is not trying it sooner!The food was amazing as well! We had the garlic loaf to start and...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Carla Little

6 years ago

We’ve been enjoying dinner and drinks at Rosie’s for years, and always get a warm welcome. Since the remodel, the bar are has been expanded, and is a great experience with signature cocktails and great service. The outdoor seating is a great addition. Last night...Read More

EH -Local Guide

11 months ago

Pretty good chicken parmigiana & shrimp fra diavolo, good flavor & served temperature hot. Fried calamari appetizer was not fresh seafood, tasted like frozen rubbery rings then fried. Draft beer was flat & served in room temperature glass. Interior decor was decent, couple side rooms,...Read More

Food: 4/5Service: 4/5Atmosphere: 4/5

Tara Porter

a year ago

Excellent dining experience last night. All these years living local and we finally got to try Rosie’s. We stopped here for an impromptu Birthday dinner and we are so glad we did. The service was impeccable, so attentive. The drinks were delicious and the menu...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

KD -Local Guide

2 years ago

This Italian restaurant was a total vibe. Beautifully decorated and maintained. The appetizers and dinner we ordered were very delicious. They have seasonal cocktails which is awesome. I tried the Pumpkin Pie Martini. It was really good but also very sweet but still well made....Read More

Nodir Ibragimov -Local Guide

4 years ago

Nice outdoor setup for the summer currently, but what really gets you here is how delicious all the food is. Tried a couple different stuff from appetizers to main dishes and nothing let you down!!! Make sure to call ahead for reservations cause they're always...Read More

daja7100 -Local Guide

4 months ago

Rosie’s is always consistently a great experience. The food, energy, ambience and service is always best in class. We love to go to the bar before dinner for a perfectly made cocktail by Jen who is always cheerful and pleasant. The Veal Chop Parm is...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Emily Cunningham

10 months ago

Absolutely insane experience at Rosie’s!!! Wow!!! Food was SO delicious, and the ambiance was great too! I ordered the grilled octopus which was to die for, surf and turf and the most delicious chicken parm I have ever had. It was so good I had...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Keischa Marrow

2 years ago

The service here is top notch! We were seated immediately without a reservation. We were promptly greeted by our waiter who made us feel at home. The lamb chops were out of this world! I bought dessert home and it was amazing. Plan on going...Read More

Food: 4/5Service: 4/5Atmosphere: 4/5

Mariana Zamora -Local Guide

3 years ago

My family and I went for dinner for the first time to this restaurant. And let me tell you. We will be going back soon. The food was out of this world! Their grilled octopus was the best we've ever had! Their seafood fra diavolo...Read More

James Brennan -Local Guide

5 years ago

I have been here a few times since the renovations and I am very impressed with the quality of the service, decor, and of course the food. I went recently for the Carton Brewery Tap Takeover and it seems like they will be having more...Read More

Lauren Ann -Local Guide

5 years ago

My family took me here to celebrate my birthday this past Saturday, and our overall experience was fantastic. Upon entering, you're met with a vibe that is distinctly Old World Europe- the style is Tuscan-inspired. The dining area beyond the lively bar possesses a certain elegance which is uniquely balanced with the coziness you'd experience in your Grandma's kitchen. We decided to share a bottle Chianti, which was velvety smooth and highly complementary to our pasta dish entrees. I was offered a taste of the wine beforehand to ensure I liked it, which was a very nice touch.Two of us ordered the Penne Vodka, which was delivered al dente to the table- the firmness of the pasta was just right and the pink cream sauce was out of this world. The amount of prosciutto in the dish was excellent- it was not overpowering. My brother-in-law ordered the Fusilli, which he loved, too. Although I do not recall what everyone else ordered, I remember everyone was very happy with their meals! The entrees were served hot and in a timely fashion. The bread was fresh and the glass-bottled water on the table was topped off without me having to ask- the bussers are very hard working people and very on the ball! I was a bit disappointed that our server could not take a picture of our table (we asked him and he said he'd "send someone over because he was busy") but thankfully, the always gracious Rosie eventually made her way over and took the picture for us. Although our server was on point in the accuracy of our orders, I do wish he could have been a bit more helpful when my cousin asked if he had any recommendations. It wasn't a very big deal, but we thought certainly, there must be some dishes he could have spotlighted as "all-time favorites" in particular categories in order to provide some guidance for our hungry party. I am very impressed when a server is able to entice you with the specials or a particular list of dishes that are their personal favorites or popular dishes among patrons.I wish we had left room for dessert, but that just gives us all another reason to visit Rosie's again very soon! The mix of northern and southern Italian fare can't be beat here. If you're on a quest to find a restaurant where you can experience top-notch authentic Italian cuisine, in a non-pretentious and warm, yet chic atmosphere, head on over to Rosie's!

M Z

2 years ago

Should change the menu for the Margherita pizza. Was told they don’t have “sliced”tomatoes??! The diced tomatoes make their delicious crust too spongy/soggy. Might as well remove the Margherita and only keep the bruschetta pizza on the menu. Had the original Margherita a year ago...Read More

robert fuchs -Local Guide

5 months ago

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Frank Tirone -Local Guide

a month ago

My wife has severe gluten and dairy allergies. We went out for dinner at the bar on Friday night and unfortunately had a disappointing service experience, which was unusual given our many positive visits where her allergies were always handled carefully.The female bartender took our...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 1/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Emily and Casey O'Connor

a month ago

My husband and I had our rehearsal dinner here 10/11/2024 and we cannot recommend this spot enough. You have your own private "party" area, private bar and private restrooms for your guests in an upstairs room. From start to finish, Mia was INCREDIBLE answering every...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Michael McManus

6 months ago

We made an order to go. While placing the order, we had to correct the hostess three times on what we wanted. Needless to say when we got home the order was what she kept saying and not what we wanted. We didn't eat the...Read More

Food: 1/5Service: 1/5

Rose Pico -Local Guide

9 months ago

My family had our Aunt Repass at Rosie's. The food was amazing. Everything was fresh and delicious. The staff was so nice. Best service I've seen in a long time. It's nice when people seem to enjoy their jobs. They tend to be a...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

C Tedesco -Local Guide

8 months ago

This local Italian has evolved a lot in the past 10 years. It used to be a reliable local Italian with good food and at a decent value. Several years ago they renovated the bar and added a covered patio, which I am sure...Read More

Food: 4/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 4/5

Spencer Beaton -Local Guide

a year ago

This is a great place to enjoy a memorable meal. The staff is attentive without being too pushy. The food is outstanding, and the owner makes the rounds to ensure everything is going good, we were there for a birthday and they made a nice...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Yohko Ballan

a year ago

We had a retirement party in one of their private rooms and everyone raved about the food. Everything was delicious. But what I was especially impressed about was the service we received. It was top notch, and I really appreciated everything they...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Michael Rieger -Local Guide

8 months ago

Finally got to try Rosie's last weekend. The first thing is the menu was way too large which was an immediate concern. The more options, the harder to do them extremely well. Given the pricing, you expect well above average.I ordered veal...Read More

Food: 4/5Service: 3/5Atmosphere: 4/5

Chris Tracy

a year ago

Wanted to take a second to highly recommend Rosie’s Trattoria and specifically Mia for any events you are looking to have. This past weekend me and my fiancé had our engagement/ engagement party upstairs and was absolutely perfect. They went out of their way to...Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Carl Whitehand

10 months ago

Here's the problem with this place...it's hit-or-miss. When it's good it's great, but it's a coin flip on whether it'll be good or bad.For this place being on the more expensive side of things, it should be a guarantee that you're getting a GREAT meal....Read More

Food: 3/5Service: 4/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Chelsea Janek

2 years ago

I came to Rosie's to celebrate my birthday, everything was great from start to finish! The service was top notch, and all of the servers and front of the house staff were cheerful and attentive. The food was very flavorful, and drinks well made. I...Read More

Jainam Shah -Local Guide

a year ago

Best Italian food I have had! Definitely worth the price. I recommend the pasta options. They are made differently from most Italian restaurants and taste so good.The restaurant staff are pretty awesome especially the host outside.Only downside is several wait staff attend to you so...Read More

william hays

11 months ago

Rushed us through dinner. Started clearing plates and silverware immediately after some finished while others were not even half way done. Asked for extra Ricotta because of swallowing problem due to cancer. They said ok but we’ll have to charge you. Brought 1 pat of...Read More

Vlad Fedorchak -Local Guide

a year ago

Always a hit with the family. They accommodate us on short notice all the time, even when it's very busy. The wine list is excellent and has some good budget choices.Kid-friendliness: Willing to accommodate families with strollers

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Steven Reinke

a year ago

One of my favorite Italian spots in New Jersey if not my favorite. Food is always delicious with super quality and you can always count on tons of specials and fresh seafood.The waiters are super kind and after a few visits I feel like family....Read More

Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

N A -Local Guide

a year ago

The entrance was a little confusing to find we passed the entrance at first thinking it was for the bank next door when they in fact share a driveway but it’s not clearly marked as such. Plenty of parking when we arrived although it filled up as we were leaving. My party was sat in a stone themed room with low light ambiance and linen dressed tables it was nice however loud with the amount of people seated together. They immediately come over to see if you’d prefer tap water or bottled still/sparkling water for the table. They bring over delicious warm bread and spreading butter after you’ve placed your entree order we really enjoyed that. My party for appetizers ordered the Nona’s meatballs, the Roberto’s salad, and the burrata special. The appetizers were not as impressive as the entrees the meatballs were slightly tough , the burrata came out with ingredients on it that weren’t listed on the menu for the one we ordered off the specials menu (it was confusing) and the Roberto’s salad came with romaine lettuce instead of mixed greens like stated on the menu. For entrees we ordered the chicken parmesan, Chicken Piccata & Penne Vodka (without the mushrooms). The entrees were all good portions and good tasting for the most part. I would just note the chicken Parmesan breading was a little mushy with the bread crumbs on the outside where I would typically look for a crispy breading layer and the chicken was more on the drier side on the inside than I would like. The penne vodka was some of the best I’ve had in awhile, I will be back specifically to order that again for sure (next time I will take it just as it comes with the mushroom peas prosciutto etc.). We also ordered dessert to share amongst us all we shared the cookie dough and marshmallow chocolate cake and the cookie lava cake both were very indulgent and decadent desserts however the center of the cookie lava cake didn’t have the oozing chocolate as described (which was no issue it still tasted good.) Servers were pleasant and attentive. Pricing was fair and true to the two $$ advertised on google, not overly priced for portions. We paid $56 each person before gratuity. All in all a solid Italian place for dine in or pick up: I would definitely recommend this establishment to my friends/family and anyone interested in Italian food for dinner in the Randolph area. We also liked that they were open until 10 pm on a weekday so we didn’t feel rushed out at all.

Food: 3/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 4/5

Joseph Dancs

2 years ago

Sorry folks, this didn’t live up to its rating. We went there on a Friday night in November 2021. Parking was an issue. The indoor decor is very nice. It was definitely crowded. We did get seated fairly quickly. However, the somewhat satisfaction ended there....Read More

Kathy Millien Harris

7 months ago

I received a gift card from Rosie's a while back. I went to the restaurant to find out how much was on the card with intentions of making reservations for our family. I was told that the gift card was voided because...Read More

Features

Service options

Outdoor seating

Takeout

Dine-in

Delivery

Highlights

Great coffee

Great dessert

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Comfort food

Hard liquor

Healthy options

Small plates

Vegetarian options

Wine

Dining options

Brunch

Lunch

Dinner

Catering

Dessert

Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Cozy

Romantic

Trendy

Upscale

Crowd

Groups

Planning

Dinner reservations recommended

Accepts reservations

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

High chairs

Parking

Free parking lot

Parking

People Also Search

Banquet Halls Bars Catering Food and Drink Suppliers Event Venues Family Restaurants Fine Dining Restaurants Italian Restaurants Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Seafood Restaurants

Rosie's Trattoria in Randolph

Contact

About

Rosie's Trattoria Review Summary

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

Features

Service options

Highlights

Popular for

Accessibility

Offerings

Dining options

Amenities

Atmosphere

Crowd

Planning

Payments

Children

Parking

People Also Search

Contact

Rosie's Trattoria in Randolph

Contact

About

Rosie's Trattoria Review Summary

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

Features

Service options

Highlights

Popular for

Accessibility

Offerings

Dining options

Amenities

Atmosphere

Crowd

Planning

Payments

Children

Parking

People Also Search

Contact

Related Search Randolph

People found Banquet Halls by searching for…

Find best businesses