Reviews (707) 620-0551 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Pizzaleah, the premier Pizza restaurant in Windsor, CA, invites you to experience the flavors of Italy in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Located at 9240 Old Redwood Hwy #116, Pizzaleah is your go-to destination for delicious pizza, fresh ingredients, and exceptional service. As a top-rated Restaurant in the heart of Windsor, we take pride in our commitment to quality, using only the freshest ingredients to craft our signature pizzas, salads, and pasta dishes. Whether you're in the mood for a classic margherita or a meat-lovers delight, our menu has something for everyone. At Pizzaleah, we're dedicated to providing an exceptional dining experience for our customers. Join us for lunch or dinner, and enjoy our comfortable seating, friendly staff, and prompt service. We're open for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, making it easy to satisfy your cravings whenever, wherever. Come taste the difference at Pizzaleah, Windsor's favorite Pizza restaurant!

Pizzaleah Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.8
(333 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Siamack Sioshansi
Siamack Sioshansi -Local Guide
3 years ago
The restaurant's name is a blending of the chef-owner’s first name and the work that made her famous. The local press has been raving about this award-winning restaurant since it opened calling it, Mecca of Pizza and one of the 101 pizzas in America.We ordered...Read More
Bff Nnn
Bff Nnn
a year ago
Had some excellent pizza! The crust was whole wheat, thick, chewy, remained crisp in center and didn’t get soggy. Full of flavor. Then my pizza had a thick red sauce, lots of good cheese, and some really good meatball slices, tasty Italian sausage, and olives....Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 3/5
Lana Rivera
Lana Rivera -Local Guide
a year ago
First time visiting, small restaurant limited seating they do have patio seatting it was to cold to sit outside the day we visited. It was a weekday and this place was busy for dinner. Service was ok we sat at the bar. The pizza...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 4/5Atmosphere: 4/5
Chris Moore
Chris Moore -Local Guide
a year ago
The pizza is second to none. Their broccolini habanero special was fantastic and the chili crisp, though ambiguous in nomenclature, is a perfect pairing. We’ve ordered the kiddos bacon + pineapple which consists of strips of thick cut savory bacon and small chunks of pineapple...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Ryan Taylor
Ryan Taylor -Local Guide
3 years ago
Easily our favorite pizza in all of Sonoma County. If you can get one before they're gone, their square pies are bomb. Tonight I didn't get through their busy phone lines in time to do that. That being said their circle pies, bomb. Be it...Read More
Brian Hinojos
Brian Hinojos -Local Guide
a year ago
Easy going, staff friendly, outside dining too. Unique pizzas. First time there. Course the Standard Piazza. Very good. Will go back and try a more unique one.Kid-friendliness: Family Friendly
Food: 4/5Service: 4/5Atmosphere: 4/5
Amanda Parks
Amanda Parks -Local Guide
4 years ago
There is a reason that the "Mush-a-Roni" pizza is award winning and a damn good one.The crust was perfect. It was so fresh and delicious and the service was OUTSTANDING.I'm very much looking forward to eating here AGAIN AND AGAIN.
Robyn Hood
Robyn Hood -Local Guide
a year ago
Sherry Adams
Sherry Adams
7 months ago
This place is great. The pizza is exactly right, cooked exactly the right amount, the ingredient proportions exactly right, the ingredient quality top notch, the combination of flavors exactly right. It was ready 10 minutes after I ordered. Leah was circulating to make sure all...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 4/5
Cassidy Dalton
Cassidy Dalton -Local Guide
a year ago
We got the caesar salad and the old grey beard pizza. The salad was good, I'd order it again, but not my favorite caesar. The dressing had a hint of dejon flavor which seemed a bit weird in caesar salad.The pizza was good. Hot honey...Read More
Food: 4/5Service: 4/5Atmosphere: 4/5
Jaima Finn
Jaima Finn
a year ago
The best pizza period - especially the square pies, don’t skip those!! Leah is also so down to earth and often there to thank for her amazing pizzas 🍕 while you can’t go wrong with plain cheese, we LOVE all of the specialties. It’s a...Read More
Chris Hanson
Chris Hanson -Local Guide
a year ago
this is probably the best pizza in Sonoma county ive had. the dough is fermented for 72 hours so it has a great flavor and texture. it's cooked in a real pizza oven so it gets the crunchy flavorful bottom. the thin...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Brendan McGuigan
Brendan McGuigan -Local Guide
4 years ago
Hands-down the best East Coast style pizza we've had in Sonoma County. Perfect for take-out. Crust is chewy and foldable with a good crisp and a light burn on top. Sauce is just the right acid balance. Sauce/cheese ratio is spot on. This pizza absolutely...Read More
Becca Barrett
Becca Barrett -Local Guide
2 years ago
GO HERE!This was my first visit to Pizzaleah. My sister and I arrived right before the dinner rush about 6pm so it was slow but by 6pm nearly all the tables inside and outside were filled.The staff was amazing! We asked them for recommendations...Read More
Benjamin Jacobs
Benjamin Jacobs -Local Guide
2 years ago
Ordered a carryout 12" Roo with red sauce, smelled so good that I ate half of it in my car in the parking lot. It's seriously the best pizza I have found anywhere on the West Coast, and I can say I've done a pretty...Read More
jose rocha jr
jose rocha jr
2 years ago
Absolutely the best pizza pie ever! Customer service is also the best. A must indulgence 🍕 thank you Pizza LeahParking: Easy parking
Alexandra Nichols
Alexandra Nichols -Local Guide
3 months ago
This place is great. The staff are super friendly, quick, and helpful. I love sitting on the patio. It’s quiet and comfy. I’m a celiac, and I did not have a reaction to the gluten free pizza. The GF crust was delicious, very airy and...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Elena Ruszkowski
Elena Ruszkowski -Local Guide
2 months ago
Love, love, love this place and their gluten free pizza crust! I make special trips just for their pizza. So terrific and delicious and positively awesome!My fiance loves the wheat flour crust too.
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5
Erik Engstrom
Erik Engstrom
6 months ago
Despite some serious issues with service that have been corrected after the first year, I was long overdue for correcting this frustration review and had forgotten I'd even left one.Pizzaleah just keeps getting better and better and consistently putting out delicious pizza every time we...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Margaret Razon
Margaret Razon -Local Guide
3 months ago
Amazingly delicious pizza. Perfect crust and topping choices. The Cesar salad was pretty average. For what it is I’d suggest I be made more abundant for your money’s worth. Decent prices on beer too! But just fabulous pizza.Parking: It’s right near large grocery store so...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Brian Nachreiner
Brian Nachreiner
a year ago
We had such a nice time at Pizzaleah. A friend of mine suggested it while she was visiting over the Thanksgiving holiday. My partner and I drove up from SF to get out of the city and try some delicious pizza. We were not disappointed....Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Johnson ARod
Johnson ARod
7 months ago
Pizza is good, but not sure why they ask for tips. Everything is self serve. Order food at the counter. Get cups at the counter. Fill up drinks at the counter. Pay at the counter. Refills at the counter. Order...Read More
Food: 4/5Service: 3/5Atmosphere: 1/5
Michelle Gregorio
Michelle Gregorio
a year ago
I’m a regular here since moving to Windsor and have been back at least 10 times now. The pizzas never disappoint and they produce the same quality every time no matter how busy it is. The dough is great. Ingredients are fresh. My family and...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
A G
A G -Local Guide
8 months ago
Is it a bit overpriced? Yeah. It’s also really good? Also yeah. As a Jersey Native the west coast has mainly disappointed me when looking for pizza but I’m glad to have stumbled upon this place while in town. If you want bready run of...Read More
Burt Codispoti
Burt Codispoti
2 years ago
Phenomenal pizza! Outstanding dough, cooked right, and topped with high-quality sauce and cheese that taste great. You will crave this pizza after having it the first time. Don't hesitate! The staff is friendly and they can let you know with great accuracy when the food...Read More
Chip Smith
Chip Smith -Local Guide
a year ago
PizzaLeah has one of the best gluten free crusts I have had. The menu is decent but they are happy to modify or add to anything you want. The beer selection is small but thoughtfully curated. Definitely adding this gem to my...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 4/5
Patrick Mounce
Patrick Mounce
a year ago
36 dollars for 1 pizza, and it was probably by far one of the worst pizzas I have ever had. It was soggy, and the flavor was bland. They were really busy, which looked like a good thing. I have been skeptical about trying this...Read More
Food: 1/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 3/5
Marcos Flores
Marcos Flores -Local Guide
2 years ago
Very clean, organized, and welcoming environment. Staff was all knowledgeable on the menu and very professional. The award winning lives up to its name, PizzaLeah. Mouth watering, warm, perfect slices of pizza you will ever try. Any pizza on the menu is flavorful and delicious....Read More
David Toaster
David Toaster -Local Guide
2 years ago
Fantastic pizza! I had most of the pizzas on the menu and a few of the specials and haven't had a bad one yet! The scurto and the grey beard and both excellent! They also have a good selection of local beers and Cider on...Read More
Leslie Bingham
Leslie Bingham
2 years ago
In town from AL. Hotel driver nor desk clerk had heard of Pizzaleah but we went for it anyway! We were not disappointed!! Excellent thin crust pizza - very flavorful!! Excellent service and lovely outdoor dining space. If it’s pizza you are craving you can’t...Read More
Blaine Dawson
Blaine Dawson
2 years ago
Extremely delicious, my dad and I are on our way to San Francisco and decided to stop here for lunch. I have to say it’s one the best pizzas I’ve ever had! It is fresh, the crust tastes amazing, only takes about 15-20 minutes to...Read More
Joel Rojas
Joel Rojas -Local Guide
2 years ago
Pizza was awesome!!!If you like thin crust pizza then this is the place for you. We enjoyed a 12” Standard pizza with pepperoni, sausage, onions, black olives and it tasted fresh and was quite filling. Also, they use a craft cola company and...Read More
Dominic Jones
Dominic Jones -Local Guide
2 years ago
If you are serious about pizza and self care through the act of eating pizza this is the place for you. Everyone here deeply cares about quality and it shows through the works of art that come from the oven. A fresh beer selection to...Read More
Kyle Weber
Kyle Weber -Local Guide
a year ago
The wait times are absolutely insane but the pizza is so good that it’s still worth it. The l-o-l-a is pretty good, but both the Chingona and Nico Pie are fantastic. The former may be one of my favorite pies in the United...Read More

Features

Service options

check icon Outdoor seating
check icon Delivery
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in

Highlights

check icon Fast service

Popular for

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible restroom
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Beer
check icon Comfort food
check icon Wine

Dining options

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Seating

Amenities

check icon Restroom
check icon Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

check icon Casual

Crowd

check icon Tourists

Planning

Accepts reservations

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards
check icon NFC mobile payments

Children

check icon Good for kids
check icon High chairs

Parking

check icon Free parking lot
check icon Parking