Reviews Direction Photos About
Direction Reviews

About

Pitchfork Barbecue is a restaurant in Pine Island, NY.

Pitchfork Barbecue Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Pitchfork Barbecue is a favorite for its flavorful smoked meats and generous portions. Guests appreciate the friendly, attentive staff and the cozy, welcoming atmosphere. The menu offers a great variety of classic barbecue dishes, all prepared with care. Sides are well-seasoned and complement the main courses perfectly. Many visitors mention the brisket and ribs as standout choices. Overall, Pitchfork Barbecue delivers a satisfying dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.

Review Rating Chart

Google: 4.6/5

Yelp: 4.5/5

Tripadvisor: 4.5/5

Facebook: 4.7/5

Zomato: 4.4/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.9
(40 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Israel Rolon (Izzy Eat's)
Israel Rolon (Izzy Eat's) -Google user
4 years ago
Best biscuits I have ever had! Everything is absolutely delicious
J. C.
J. C. -Google user
2 years ago
Quite delectable.... Not a spice missing
Elaine Burghoffer
Elaine Burghoffer -Google user
4 years ago
So dang good!! Hot honey chicken biscuit 🐔 blueberry jam biscuit, chicken sandwich, potato salad, and banana pudding were all amazing. Great lunch 🤤❤ …
Kim Olfano
Kim Olfano -Google user
4 years ago
Pitchfork Barbecue and Biscuits has mouth-watering pulled pork, delicious ribs, unbelievable brisket, freshly made biscuits, and phenomenal banana pudding that will keep you coming back for more. The portions are big and everything is made to perfection. Lauren and John do a wonderful job...Read More
J H
J H -Google user
5 years ago
There are not enough stars to give this place. 100 stars. I pulled up for the first time, never been there before. The gentleman was just closing up, he poked his head out and asked me if I want it pulled pork cuz that's all...Read More
jhaag02
jhaag02 -Google user
2 years ago
This place makes REAL BBQ. Not the shortcut BBQ that's very common outside of the more known places like Texas or the Carolinas. Well worth it. They do a great job.
hugh brown
hugh brown -Google user
5 years ago
I tried the smoked chicken, pulled pork sandwich, mac and cheese, and banana pudding. Somehow they all managed to exceed my expectations. I definitely will be back to work my way through the menu.
Amanda G
Amanda G -Google user
2 years ago
This is bbq is some of the best smoked bbq around! The meat is also top quality! So happy I found this place!
Russell Doherty
Russell Doherty -Google user
4 years ago
Everything we tried was 5 stars - ribs, brisket burger, fried chicken sandwich, pulled pork sandwich, turkey and mac and cheese. Very nice people and seriously delicious food!
Kimberly M
Kimberly M -Google user
5 years ago
We ordered the chicken on a biscuit, the brisket and the pulled pork sandwiches. All were soooo delicious and there's a cute playground, benches, picnic tables and bathrooms close by.
Jose Ortiz
Jose Ortiz -Google user
2 years ago
If you want to have the most delicious brisket sandwich ever come to this place next time I'm going for the ribs!
Sarah Sigman
Sarah Sigman -Google user
4 years ago
Yummy food…. Ate there once had to bring the whole family back for a second time. Great prices and beautiful scenery. Definitely will continue going throughout the summer.
Alec Ofshinsky
Alec Ofshinsky -Google user
2 years ago
Seriously the best barbecue around. The brisket was amazingly juice and tender
DB Young
DB Young -Google user
4 years ago
Excellent as always, it's hands down the best BBQ around. Highly recommended!
Amanda S
Amanda S -Google user
2 years ago
Amazing!! Brisket and cheese grits were phenomenal! Can’t wait to go back!!!
Lyssa C. Naron
Lyssa C. Naron -Google user
4 years ago
The atmosphere, chicken and biscuits, and biscuits and gravy were excellent. We will be back for barbeque!
Timothy Delprete
Timothy Delprete -Google user
Edited 2 years ago
Best bbq around ! Just happy there back :-))
Chris von Essen
Chris von Essen -Google user
5 years ago
Had the biscuits n gravy w/eggs this morning, all I can say is wow! Fantastic....
Natalie Daleney
Natalie Daleney -Google user
5 years ago
Simply the best! Great quality and fresh ingredients! A must try!
Patrick E
Patrick E -Google user
2 years ago
Seriously the best BBQ and service

Features

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot

People Also Search