Reviews (305) 664-3225 Call Website Photos About

Pierre's Restaurant in Islamorada

Name: Pierre's Restaurant in Islamorada
Address: 81600 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, Florida, 33036, US
Price range: $$$$
Rating: 4.4

Is this your business?

4.4 (563)

Bars Eclectic Restaurants French Restaurants Lounges Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Wedding Venues

Call Direction Website Reviews

(305) 664-3225 Direction Website Reviews

About

Pierre's Restaurant, a premier French restaurant in Islamorada, FL, offers an eclectic dining experience in a sophisticated setting. Our lounge is perfect for unwinding with craft cocktails, while our restaurant serves up exquisite French-inspired cuisine. As a popular wedding venue, we cater to intimate gatherings and grand celebrations alike. Join us for a romantic dinner, a night out with friends, or a special occasion. Our expert chefs and attentive staff ensure a memorable experience. Visit us at 81600 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036.

Pierre's Restaurant Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Pros

Pierre's Restaurant is a hidden gem with exceptional service, attentive staff, and a cozy atmosphere. The menu offers a diverse range of French-inspired dishes, and the presentation is visually stunning. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable considering the high-quality ingredients used. Many reviewers rave about the restaurant's consistency in delivering outstanding meals.

Cons

Some reviewers found the menu to be limited, and the options for vegetarians and vegans are scarce. A few guests experienced long wait times for their food, and the restaurant can get quite noisy during peak hours. Additionally, the dessert menu is not as impressive as the rest of the menu, and some dishes can be overly rich.

Review Rating Chart

Yelp: 4.5/5

TripAdvisor: 4.5/5

Google Reviews: 4.4/5

OpenTable: 4.5/5

Zagat: 4.3/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.4

(563 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Simonne Piriz -Google user

4 months ago

We were visiting the area for our baby moon, and was recommended we try this restaurant. Everything had such decadent flavors, we were really impressed. We were told by the server that the menu changes quite often, however here’s what we ordered: - The escargot - The...Read More

Maria Delgado -Google user

2 months ago

We love this place so much! The lady manager was impeccable and absolutely amazing in her service. Needless to say, our server from Poland and this beautiful Manager made our experience unforgettable! We will be back for sure! Thank you for the great hospitality and...Read More

Jamie Engel, Florida Keys Real Estate -Google user

3 months ago

We had our annual Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co Holiday Paety last weekend. This was one of our best events for several years. The food was absolutely beautifully presented and delicious! The service was impeccable. Beautiful night for an outdoor party with seating...Read More

Le Ann -Google user

8 months ago

I was hesitant to book a reservation after reading some of the reviews, but if you are considering Pierre's - do it! The reviews did not live up to our experience and I'm so glad I decided to see for myself. The service was impeccable, attentive, and welcoming from start to finish and the food was beyond any expectation I had. I am leaving a long, detailed review, as a local, because this place truly deserves it. We did the 6 course dinner tasting and were full after the 4th course, but powered through because it was THAT amazing. The portions are half that of the regular size and it was incredibly filling, exceptionally beautiful, and full of flavor. We booked a balcony reservation for 7:00 and the hostess tried to warn us that it was going to be very hot, but being locals, we thought it would be okay - it wasn't. This was the ONLY downside of the experience. I wish they had a fan at every other light on the balcony, I think that would have cooled us off enough. However, while it was hot, the view was breathtaking! The 6 course tasting menu took us about 3 hours, the timing was well spaced and the time allowed us to watch the sunset and see the stars come out - such a beautiful location! I read a lot of reviews and unfortunately did not see any regarding the tasting menu, so here is my takeaway. It cost about $148/person and I believe was WELL worth it. They did not skimp on portions, changed out our silverware after each course, and paced the meal accordingly. Living here is expensive as is, so for those reviews complaining about portion sizes compared to cost must not know the Keys are flat out expensive. As a local, a typical meal out costs around $150-200 without drinks, so getting to taste a variety of menu items we normally wouldn't have tried AND filling full hours after getting home was a win. Pierre's is one of the nicest restaurants in the Keys and that comes at a price, but I would gladly pay it again. For the course we had: 1. Butter Lettuce 2. Sautéed Hudson Vally Foie Gras 3. Florida Lobster Ravioli 4. Pan Roasted Black Grouper 5. La Belle Farms Duck Breast 6. Molten Lava Cake. My favorite item was either the Butter Lettuce or the Lobster Ravioli - it was STUFFED with meat! All of the sauces and ingredients were amazing, there was not one meal I would say was bad. My least favorite dish was the duck breast and it was not anything they did, it was amazing, it was just my least favorite. I also removed the sour cream from the molten lava cake - it is a French thing, and I understand staying true to French cuisine, but as an American I didn't prefer it and that was an easy fix. The drinks were strong and very good, the wine menu was exceptional, after dinner cappuccino was amazing, and they even have a cigar market. After dinner we grabbed a cigar and sat down by the beach for a nice end cap - perfect all around! Thank you Sandra for the exceptional service - she is such a sweetheart and knows how to give attentive service. We will be back for our next date night. Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $100+ Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Alexandra Lilley -Google user

a year ago

My boyfriend and I came here on February 10 for dinner, and had an unforgettable experience. First off, my boyfriend decided to propose before dinner. We can’t thank the server enough that he talked to who took a video and photos for us before the restaurant...Read More

Susan Tabas -Google user

a week ago

Not only was the chef impressive - the food was delicious, creative and beautifully presented in the nicest atmosphere, but the staff was first rate and made our anniversary extra special. Shout outs to Rose, the manager, Selly our hostess and Violet our server. Rose...Read More

Paula Dow -Google user

a week ago

College sorority sister reunion 40 years later in Islamorada and we chose Pierre’s for our special dinner out. It was well worth every penny. Started with a Prosecco for cheers and then enjoyed a scallop appetizer and delightful fish entrées. We did have a birthday...Read More

Isabelle Kyte -Google user

a month ago

We had the pleasure of sitting at a table on the terrace, overlooking the sunset, and it was truly magical! The service was outstanding, and the staff was incredibly accommodating, ensuring we had a couple of vegan options to choose from. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Alivia -Google user

a week ago

Came here to eat tonight to celebrate our wedding and everything went above and beyond our expectations. The view from the balcony, complimentary touches from the house, the amazing service experience, and the top notch meal made this an unforgettable experience. We are already planning...Read More

Julie Caron -Google user

a week ago

We had a delicious dinner, tuna tartare was very fresh and the grilled fish delicious. Key lime bar was good too. Service was impeccable. If you want to sit outside come around sunset. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Features

Service options

Outdoor seating

Takeout

Dine-in

Delivery

Highlights

Fireplace

Great beer selection

Great cocktails

Great coffee

Great dessert

Great wine list

Live music

Popular for

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Happy hour drinks

Happy hour food

Hard liquor

Healthy options

Organic dishes

Small plates

Vegan options

Vegetarian options

Wine

Dining options

Dinner

Catering

Dessert

Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite

Restroom

Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

Cozy

Historic

Romantic

Trendy

Upscale

Crowd

Groups

LGBTQ+ friendly

Tourists

Transgender safespace

Planning

Reservations required

Dinner reservations recommended

Accepts reservations

Payments

Credit cards

Children

High chairs

Kids' menu

Parking

Free parking lot

Parking

Other

LGBTQ+ friendly

People Also Search

Bars Eclectic Restaurants French Restaurants Lounges Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Wedding Venues

Pierre's Restaurant in Islamorada

Contact

About

Pierre's Restaurant Review Summary

Pros