Reviews (845) 747-9686 Call Website Photos About

Pancho's Pizza & Wings

Name: Pancho's Pizza & Wings
Address: 25 Sullivan Ave, Liberty, New York, 12754, US
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.1

Is this your business?

4.1 (157)

Pizza Restaurants Delivery Restaurants

Call Direction Website Reviews

(845) 747-9686 Direction Website Reviews

About

Pancho's Pizza & Wings is a pizza restaurant in Liberty, NY.

Pancho's Pizza & Wings Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Pancho's Pizza & Wings is a local favorite known for its delicious, generously topped pizzas and crispy wings. Customers appreciate the friendly service and fast delivery, making it a great spot for casual dining or takeout. The menu offers a good variety, with options to satisfy all tastes. While the atmosphere is simple, the food consistently earns high marks for quality and flavor, making it a reliable choice for pizza lovers in the area.

Review Rating Chart

Google: 4.4/5

Yelp: 4.0/5

Tripadvisor: 4.5/5

Facebook: 4.6/5

Zomato: 4.2/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.1

(157 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Nicole Victoria Tarone -Google user

2 months ago

Pizza at Pancho’s is really good. The flavoring on the pizza is delicious, I and my family were so happy to see that we have to pizzeria fairly close by. The staff and the atmosphere is really pleasant and there is plenty of sitting. I...Read More

$20–30Atmosphere: 5Moderate noise5-8 peoplePlenty of parkingFree parking lotDefinitely kid friendly. The atmosphere inside looks fun and playful with the furniture.

Michael Rider -Google user

7 months ago

It's a great place and surprisingly big inside. The staff is very friendly and the decor is charming. I intended to get pizza to go but ended up dining in. The tables and chairs are carved wood with brightly painted decorations and there's a lot...Read More

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Plenty of parkingFree parking lotThe lot is more than big enough for the plaza with lots of pull-through spaces. I actually rode there on my ebike by way of the sidewalk and a muddy short-cut by BOCES. Cutting through the back of a plaza past no-trespassing signs made new feel like the punk kid I used to be. It was great.Surprisingly sensory-friendly with cute furniture. The two fast food chains nearby used to be good for kids but both removed their play areas years ago. This restaurant has a lot of whimsy that you won't see in the corporate wasteland of gray box fast food.

Nate 8 -Google user

11 months ago

We went in for pizza and wings Friday night. Both items came out quickly and were delicious. The buffalo wings were crispy and tasty,not just spicy. The large cheese pizza wasn't too greasy and had a good crunch to the crust. I definitely would go...Read More

Dine inDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 4

Jamie Nicole Silverstein -Google user

a year ago

Stopped here quick on the way home from a trip upstate because Liberty Diner was packed. The pizza is great! I love their thin crispy crust. The sauce was very good as well with a little hint of sweetness. I had a plain slice and...Read More

Dine inLunch$1–10Service: 5

James Hoctor -Google user

5 years ago

This restaurant absolutely slaps. I recently moved out of Sullivan County and I’m realizing that I took this place for granted. The wings are decent as hell and reasonably priced. Pair that with a cheeseburger deluxe with fries and you have an absolutely banging meal...Read More

david gillmer -Google user

3 years ago

I've eaten pizza all around the area. Pancho's is the best. Best crust. Best flavor. Chicken wings are big and juicy. Good variety of sauces, medium wings are tangy and vinegar forward with good spice level. Get here.

Patriotic American -Google user

Edited 2 years ago

I once left a bad review of this place due to a single worker there being miserable. This place shouldn't suffer because of someone they were probably desperate to hire in the first place. So I'm updating now after finding out that they hired new staff. The...Read More

Atmosphere: 4

T T -Google user

a year ago

Great Garbage Pie, Sweet chili wings, and overall atmosphere! Nice small family owned business that's great for the community

Atmosphere: 5

Darrin D.O. -Google user

a year ago

Delicious pizza,staff was friendly,and the furniture was cool, recommend for good food and a calm atmosphere

Atmosphere: 3

Kevin Garrett -Google user

3 years ago

Their thin crust pizza is fantastic. The wings are smaller than I like but COVID seems to be responsible for that too. A definite must try in Liberty.

Jaymi Leigh -Google user

Edited 10 years ago

Decided to give them a shot after multiple bad experiences at every other pizzeria in Liberty, and was not disappointed! Fair prices, great flavor, and cooked to perfection!

Paul Muller -Google user

4 years ago

We ordered a large cheese pizza to go and just ate a slice. If you want NY style pizza, this is the place. So good!

Amanda Raven -Google user

4 years ago

If you want great food, I definitely recommend Panchos pizza. The food is amazing and pancho and his family are amazing as well. If you've never tried their food, you're definitely missing out.

Take outDinner$10–20

J N -Google user

10 years ago

Pancho's is very neat and sparkling clean. Their hot sandwiches are very good and I just tried their Lasagna=OUTSTANDING!!! Five Stars!!!!!!!

Mike Aziz -Google user

4 years ago

Hardworking people that make and serve great food. There's always a good variety. The place is clean and I eat there once a week.

Fábio Campanati -Google user

6 years ago

Food is so tasty and fresh. If you like salads as well, don’t hesitates and try the Taco Salad 🥗. 😋 …

Dylan Vitale -Google user

7 years ago

Pizza is best in town but in addition all the dinners are excellent too. Nice small family owned business

Kenneth Keller -Google user

6 months ago

Good pizza good food, nice people

Take outDinner$1–10Not surePlenty of parkingFree parking lot

Cassandra Engelmann -Google user

4 years ago

Food is always good. The wings are great. Everytime I order here I get the mild wings.

Y. R. -Google user

4 years ago

Amazing food. Lemon wings, carbanera, and pizza is so tasty. And the owners are super friendly.

Features

Service options

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Comfort food

Quick bite

Dining options

Lunch

Dinner

Dessert

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Tourists

Payments

Credit cards

Children

Good for kids

Kids' menu

Parking

Free parking lot

Parking

People Also Search

Pizza Restaurants Delivery Restaurants

Pancho's Pizza & Wings

Contact

About