Reviews Website Photos About

Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Jefferson

Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Jefferson

Is this your business?

4.6 (107)

Italian Restaurants Pizza Restaurants Takeout Restaurants

9 Images

Direction Website Reviews

Direction Website Reviews

About

Johnny's New York Style Pizza is a family-friendly Italian restaurant serving authentic New York-style pizzas, pastas, and more in Jefferson, GA. As a popular Pizza restaurant, we're dedicated to providing the best dining experience for our customers. Our menu features a wide range of options, from classic cheese and pepperoni to gourmet pies and salads. At Johnny's New York Style Pizza, we're committed to using only the freshest ingredients and traditional cooking methods to ensure every bite is delicious. Whether you're in the mood for a quick Takeout or a night out with friends and family, our restaurant is the perfect spot. Visit us today and taste the difference for yourself!

Johnny's New York Style Pizza Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.6

(107 Reviews)

5

4

3

2

1

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Tracey Brosh -Google user

a year ago

What a great Italian joint for Jefferson!!! The place was packed and all the dishes we saw looked fantastic! We thoroughly enjoyed sharing cheese sticks as an appy followed by my cousin enjoying his Spaghetti & Meatballs with a Caesar Salad and my friend...Read More

Dine inDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Hawaiian Luau Pizza

Benjamin Wells -Google user

11 months ago

Hands down the best pizza around!! Drove 20 min just to try this place!

Garrett Groff -Google user

Edited 4 months ago

Probably the largest and best-lit Johnny's pizza there is. Nice looking bar too which was needed in Jefferson. Only gripe I had was the pizza which was too thick to call thin crust. Still tasty though I guess. Make it thinner please lol. The garlic...Read More

Dine inDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 5Mini Garlic Knots

Angel Madera -Google user

4 months ago

Super good. The best pizza place I have found in the area. The insalata caprese was great as was the margarita pizza. The rearuarant itself is very pleasant and the downtown area is fairly walkable as well

Dine inLunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talkFree parking lot, Free street parking

Cindy Jamison -Google user

3 months ago

My family was wanting an authentic NY style pizza and I recommended we give this place a try because I’ve driven by there a few times. Parking is tricky. Don’t park right out front because you might be stuck for a while. The service was...Read More

Take outLunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5Suitable for all group sizes

Chris Bentley -Google user

6 months ago

It was one of the worst experiences I've had at this establishment. Terrible slice of cheese pizza. Turkey sandwich, which had virtually no turkey. Looked. Like a slice from a carl buddig package. After asking, they said they would re-make or discount. So I end up paying...Read More

Atmosphere: 2

Michelle -Google user

a year ago

I had lunch here with a friend & her 2 kids. Our waitress was amazing & the pizza was so so good! Lunch special $8.00 for 2 big slices and a drink. We will definitely be back! Thank you so much. Now please open one...Read More

Aj Ervine -Google user

a month ago

These reviews astound me. From the second we walked in, it smelled and look so good! The service was very fast, Danielle was excellent, helpful and so nice. We got a great white pizza at her recommendation at it was SO good. Also a cheese/pepperoni...Read More

Dine inDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 53-4 people, 5-8 peopleDifficult to find parking

Mike Bice -Google user

3 months ago

I will be honest….not being from the area, I drove around the block 3 times. Parking is ridiculous. This is just a fact of the town not the restaurant. In the end the parking battle was worth it. The place is immaculate, the bartender was...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Jesilyn Strickland -Google user

4 months ago

walked in and it was so busy, but we were seated immediately. our server Bryson was so attentive and friendly. I used to work for a Johnny’s back in the day, and our food was NEVER as good as Jefferson’s was! so impressed and leaving...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Adam Starkey -Google user

2 months ago

Great Italian (particularly the white flatbread pizza and calzones). Environment is equally good - upscale pizza joint with great beers on tap and great cocktails all. Highly recommended - Abby, our server, was great too! If you're near downtown Jefferson, definitely check them out.

Judy Robart -Google user

5 months ago

We had a great dine in experience. Our server, Rayann, was awesome. Just an all around great server and it's really hard to find that these days. We will diffently request her every time we go. Great atmosphere, cold beer and the food came out...Read More

Dine inDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 5Indoor dining area, Bar area, Booth seating

Devada Doyal -Google user

3 months ago

We had a great experience here! We sat at the bar and had John as our bartender and he was able to make our favorite shots perfectly then the pizza was excellent as well and will be happy to come back soon next time we're...Read More

Robert Childres -Google user

6 months ago

My pizza was excellent and the restaurant was very clean with a great atmosphere. The service was exceptional. I actually became engrossed in things that I was working on and did not pay attention to the time. My waitress, Lala, actually …

Caleb Grant -Google user

2 months ago

This is the best pizza place in Jefferson!! They have clean tables and very good pizza. And they have trivia night every Wednesday. It makes for great family fun!

995 -Google user

7 months ago

I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni and sausage, but they accidentally made pepperoni only, when they served it to me they told me that they're remaking my order and the 2 slices are on them. So I got 4 slices for the price of 2!...Read More

Connie Porter -Google user

a year ago

I was wanting a really good pizza for takeout. There aren’t any good places in Winder. I haven’t had Johnny’s in years, per reviews here I was skeptical. They did not disappoint! The pizza and wings were so good and 100% satisfied my …

Kristin Rancke -Google user

a year ago

Came here to see family and evacuate from Hurricane Milton for a week (Saint Pete, FL). Great pizza place, nicely decorated and very clean. Everything was perfection, price was reasonable and very friendly service. Thanks for making us feel at home away from...Read More

D. Right -Google user

a year ago

First time experience with them. I believe they are worth my 5 stars. I tried 2 locations, and I stumbled across the one in Jefferson not far off i-85 n GA. Walked in, and yes, the atmosphere is a place I would definitely sit in...Read More

Tegan Taylor -Google user

a year ago

Everything was awesome the food we had was awesome. We had pizza and fried pickles the pizza slices were large but very delicious. The pickles were awesome. We had a waitress named April she was so awesome so kind and sweet you should …

Features

People Also Search

Italian Restaurants Pizza Restaurants Takeout Restaurants