Reviews (607) 836-6006 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Hathaway House is a banquet hall in Cincinnatus, NY.

Hathaway House Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.9
(65 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Robyn
Robyn -Google user
8 years ago
Beautiful, and great service.
William OGorman
William OGorman -Google user
3 years ago
Regardless of the event, this is the best venue by far. From the property to the food... the Tinelli family welcomes you and you always feel like family.
Matt & Tracey Spencer
Matt & Tracey Spencer -Google user
a year ago
We had a beautiful wedding ceremony and reception at the Hathaway House. The parlor rooms, the grounds, all just so rich and gorgeous, bygone elegance tucked away in a lovely rural area. The terrace room, with the garden view, patio, and bar area...Read More
Ellen Lindstrom
Ellen Lindstrom -Google user
5 months ago
Wonderful facility! Attended a party and the food was FABULOUS!
Meaghan Rowe
Meaghan Rowe -Google user
6 years ago
Tony was amazing for our wedding! We had so many special requests, dietary restrictions, and necessary seating arrangements to accommodate some less-than-ideal familial situations that we were nervous about. He took the time and effort to respect every request. On top of all of that,...Read More
linda fusaro
linda fusaro -Google user
Edited 5 months ago
Awesome in every way! Great host ,food and out of this world desserts . Great country setting
Andy Jewett
Andy Jewett -Google user
2 years ago
I always look forward to an event here knowing the wonderful food Tony, Nadine and Gina Tinelli and staff will present with gracious service. We are fortunate for the Tinelli family hosting so many of us for so many years.
Rick Dorman
Rick Dorman -Google user
12 years ago
I have been here for a number of alumni banquets and class reunions. I have never been disappointed. The food is always fantastic and the service is terrific. Tony and his staff go out of their way to make the evening very...Read More
Richard Johnson
Richard Johnson -Google user
a year ago
Very nice place to have a Christmas party. Iam sure this place can be used for other occasions. Excellent food. The desserts are fantastic.
Lee Skywalker
Lee Skywalker -Google user
6 years ago
A beautiful historical site to have a special event held. The grounds are beautiful . A lot of.wonderful green space. Very classy & formal atmospheric.Just a hidden germ in the New York countryside.Just love the history of this place!!💞 …
George
George -Google user
6 years ago
Hathaway House is a beautiful venue in the country owned and operated by the Tinelli family. They put on a perfect function down to the tiniest details. Excellent food. The Tinelli family are gracious, wonderful people. Jerri Miller-Duane
Cathy Heller
Cathy Heller -Google user
a year ago
Came here for an event and they didn't disappoint. Family owned and a beautiful place for weddings or any large events.
Patricia Ward
Patricia Ward -Google user
6 years ago
Beautifully decorated home that hosts not only weddings but parties. The food they serve in banquet style is absolutely delicious!!
John Spurrier
John Spurrier -Google user
Edited 3 years ago
Been there a couple of times when I was younger. Dinner banquets. Always professional and always had very good food
Anthony Cincotta
Anthony Cincotta -Google user
5 years ago
Great place for a banquet,great food,some of the best prime rib around this area. Hope we can work it out for 2020.
Jack Comfort
Jack Comfort -Google user
2 years ago
Was here for a Christmas party. Everything about this place is fantastic. I enjoy coming here every chance I get.
Wendy Clay
Wendy Clay -Google user
4 years ago
The owners are terrific. The food is excellent, the house and grounds beautiful.
Gary Henry
Gary Henry -Google user
4 years ago
A wonderful visit and experience, great meal and excellent service.
Sarah Moore
Sarah Moore -Google user
5 years ago
Beautiful setting! Staff was great and the food was AMAZING!!
Ciera & Jay
Ciera & Jay -Google user
6 years ago
Love the house, so pretty and good amount of room for anything

Features

Service options

check icon Dine-in
Delivery
Takeout

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot