Reviews (727) 232-2474 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen and Subs is a family-owned Italian restaurant and sandwich shop serving up delicious eats in New Port Richey, FL. Our chefs whip up authentic Italian dishes using only the freshest ingredients, from classic pasta favorites to mouthwatering subs and sandwiches. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty plate of spaghetti or a satisfying sub, our menu has something for everyone. With a cozy atmosphere and exceptional service, Goodfellas Italian Kitchen and Subs is the perfect spot to grab lunch or dinner with friends and family. Visit us today at 5446 Grand Blvd, New Port Richey, FL 34652 and taste the difference for yourself!

Goodfellas Italian Kitchen and Subs Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.7
(229 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Julie Lechner
Julie Lechner -Google user
2 years ago
Can't believe it's taken me this long to stop in a try a sub but man oh man was this one phenomenal. I'm not the biggest fan of Italian subs so I went with something the guy at the counter recommended which was The Bronx...Read More
Tiffany F
Tiffany F -Google user
a year ago
So was looking to find some good eggplant Parmesan have tried all the other local spots and have not been impressed so when I say I hit the jackpot this time I did- I ordered caprese salad, eggplant parmigiana entree- which came with soup (I...Read More
Take outDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 5
DonnaY
DonnaY -Google user
a year ago
Delicious food, super nice staff
Dine inDinner$1–10Atmosphere: 5Sandwiches
Michael Simila
Michael Simila -Google user
2 years ago
AWESOME SHOP! The girls working today did a great job. It was super busy but they were still fast snd efficient. Did pick up, ordered 2 Tony Montanas and a Philly (forgot the rest of the name) .. everyone was pleased, sandwiches were delicious ,...Read More
Charles R Marks
Charles R Marks -Google user
a year ago
Went today for the first time and I'm impressed!! Excellent Chicken Parm!!! I can't wait to try other things here! Its only 6 to 7 minute drive from Gulf Harbors wich is a huge win for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Allen Robinson
Allen Robinson -Google user
a year ago
It's a Friday so either it's Pasta are Subs. First time ordering and experiencing Goodfellas menu. I order the DonVito. Best sub since I moved to the area.Soft bread also the right amount of vinaigrette. I will definitely be visiting on a normal basis. 💯
Take outDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 5The Don Vito
Adam Wright
Adam Wright -Google user
a year ago
Great sandwich at a reasonable price. My order was the philly. Excellent meat, cheese and peppers. Well seasoned. Staff was friendly and efficient even during the lunch rush.
Atmosphere: 5
Amy Robertson
Amy Robertson -Google user
3 years ago
This place is AMAZING! Everything I have gotten from here has been delicious. Super fresh, huge portions, and great variety. Was just introduced the their Meal Prep options, and once again, couldn't be happier with the meals. Having fresh, healthy meals I can preorder or...Read More
Jennifer Geckas
Jennifer Geckas -Google user
a year ago
Great experience!!! Very fresh ingredients. Sandwiches and cannolis are awesome. Love the bread. Very nice local owner, Brooklyn Bomber is my favorite! Add Jalapeño for extra kick. Don’t take it off menu. :) lol ❤️🥳👍we will be back. Thanks!
Take outLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5
Brielle Baez
Brielle Baez -Google user
2 years ago
Goodfellas always treats their customers like family the minute you walk in! During spring break they made lunches for all of the kids for free! It’s amazing! We are so thankful for them💖 …
Shelby Smith
Shelby Smith -Google user
3 years ago
Soft bread, fresh tomatoes, house made mozz, and pesto!! If I see a caprese sandwich I always order it and this may be the best I’ve had 😌 their don vito is their bestseller and it’s just as excellent too 🤌🏼🤌🏼 …
Michael Watts
Michael Watts -Google user
2 years ago
First time coming to this restaurant & all the hype I’ve been hearing definitely didn’t disappoint. The food is fresh and so good & the customer service in their is on point.
GrindLeague Productions
GrindLeague Productions -Google user
3 years ago
Amazing! From the food to the service i mean look at this thing! Hands down the best meats and roasted pepper with the very best balsimac venegarette ive ever had. Ill b back daily probably!
Andrea Vieara
Andrea Vieara -Google user
3 years ago
It was my first time at goodfellas. The Don Vito sandwich was delicious, and so reasonably priced. Will definitely go back soon
Scott Thomas
Scott Thomas -Google user
a year ago
We were here for a soccer tournament and looking for something different. This place was AMAZING! The service, staff, and food were impeccable. Everything is fresh! The bread was so soft. The Furio was exceptional. I wish I could take the...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
William Cronin
William Cronin -Google user
2 years ago
Great little place, have only had their burgers, but they are GREAT. All are double patty (has to be well over 1/2lb meat, maybe 2/3!,) cooked to order, cheese and topping are generous, served on a huge lightly toasted bun. Any other burger would get...Read More
efrain rodriguez
efrain rodriguez -Google user
a year ago
2nd time going with my uncle! First time I had the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich and it was by far the bestest Philly I had anywhere in FL by far so far. Today I had the Don Vito which is a salami, I’m pretty sure...Read More
Dine inLunch$1–10The Don VitoHighly recommendNot sureThey have it allWhatever you likePlenty of parkingFree parking lotGreat place of Energy, Owner is amazing!Great place, Great Service
Matthew Ware
Matthew Ware -Google user
2 years ago
This place is worth your time and money. Awesome little local shop. I've come probably a dozen times and every single time without fail the guys and girls working are extremely friendly, super quick and make amazing sandwiches. I live a couple blocks away and...Read More
Janelle
Janelle -Google user
a year ago
We have been to Goodfellas twice now. Both times the staff has been friendly and quick. The food is good too. Had a patriot burger today and it was a huge, delicious burger. Reasonable prices and good food...keep up the good work guys!
Take outDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 4Sandwiches
Dawn Kutz
Dawn Kutz -Google user
Edited a year ago
I was a fan of the Goodfellas sandwich shop and the new knife and fork restaurant does not disappoint. My friend is Italian and he said the Carbonara was on point. I tried a bite and I am definitely going back soon to order that...Read More
Dine inDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 5
Scott Voth
Scott Voth -Google user
3 years ago
Excellent sandwiches, great ambiance, and lots of extras (prepped foods and desserts) to choose from. I don't have an issue with the chain sub places, but this place is a cut above and more forgiving on the wallet. Employees seem genuinely interested in their product...Read More
Jon Thurman
Jon Thurman -Google user
a year ago
Great lil sub shop, finally got around to try it. Got a philly cheese steak that was one of the best I've had in Tampa or NPR. The atmostphere is heavy on the mafia NY soprano's scene but I find it charming looking at all...Read More
Sarah Brooklyn
Sarah Brooklyn -Google user
2 years ago
I went to another local deli and they were closed today, the Memorial Weekend Saturday which was amazingly depressing so I decided to walk into Goodfellas Deli. I was greeted by the sweet young girl running the counter, right followed by …
Mason Flynn
Mason Flynn -Google user
2 years ago
Goodfellas is awesome! I stopped in today with my wife, and as we walked in the smell of delicious food hit our faces. Just that alone told me the sandwiches here are prime. I ordered the breakfast Cuban, and my wife got the regular Cuban....Read More
jeremy gruerio
jeremy gruerio -Google user
a year ago
Recently had a little problem with the food I got. Not even 12 hours after posting the review, I got a response to my problem. They reached out to me and offered to make the situation right. I spoke to Eric directly and made sure...Read More
wessahrawi
wessahrawi -Google user
3 years ago
Had a wonderful experience. They have the best meats and cheeses at prices cheaper than the chain stores. These guys are local and you're going to deal with the owners who take pride in what they do, that is easy to see. Great selection of...Read More
Chris Mikelinich
Chris Mikelinich -Google user
2 years ago
Lucky enough to work next door, great place for lunch, friendly atmosphere and staff. You can tell the owner/cook puts his heart into his cooking. Would highly recommend the “bruiser” burger!
Tierra Villagran
Tierra Villagran -Google user
a year ago
Thank you to Goodfellas, knife and fork for cooking dinner tonight… i’ve been to a lot of places, including some very close to where you’re located. The flavors that you have are amazing. Everything tasted as good as grandma makes…… thank you so much we...Read More
Hannah Phelps
Hannah Phelps -Google user
3 years ago
This was a cool new little place! They’ve got some work to do on curb appeal, but don’t let that deter you! The sandwiches are huge and so so good! Loved the selection of fun craft sodas (I opted for orange cream). Yum!!
Tessa HD Campbell
Tessa HD Campbell -Google user
a year ago
I challenge anyone to find a better sub than the Don Vito, or the Antipasto salad. Not only quality ingredients, but the signature homemade Italian dressing is the secret ingredient. It's very unique and SO delicious. (I'm usually a "ranch" dressing person).

Features

Service options

check icon Delivery
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in

Popular for

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible restroom
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Beer
check icon Comfort food
check icon Quick bite

Dining options

check icon Breakfast
check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Catering
check icon Dessert

Amenities

check icon Restroom

Atmosphere

check icon Casual

Payments

check icon Credit cards

Children

check icon Good for kids

Parking

check icon Free parking lot
check icon Parking