What types of bagels do you offer?

We offer a variety of traditional and specialty bagels, including whole wheat, everything, cinnamon raisin, and more.

Do you have gluten-free or vegan options?

Yes, we offer gluten-free and vegan bagel options, as well as vegan cream cheese spreads.

Where are you located?

We are located at 559 S 5th Ave.

Can I customize my bagel with different toppings or spreads?

Absolutely! We offer a wide range of toppings and spreads, and you can customize your bagel to your liking.

Do you offer catering services for events or meetings?

Yes, we offer catering services and can provide bagels, spreads, and other baked goods for your event or meeting.

Reviews (208) 235-1311 Call Website Photos About

Fifth Street Bagelry in Pocatello

Is this your business?

4.7 (939)

Bagel Shops Breakfast Restaurants

Call Direction Website Reviews

(208) 235-1311 Direction Website Reviews

About

Fifth Street Bagelry is a beloved Bagel shop and Breakfast restaurant in Pocatello, ID. Located at 559 S 5th Ave, we're dedicated to serving up freshly baked bagels and delicious breakfast options to start your day off right. Our bagel shop is a cozy spot to grab a quick bite or meet with friends and family. From classic everything bagels to creative flavor combinations, our menu has something for everyone. Pair your bagel with a hot cup of coffee or a refreshing smoothie for the perfect breakfast combo. At Fifth Street Bagelry, we're passionate about providing exceptional customer service and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a sweet or savory breakfast, we've got you covered. Stop by today and taste the difference for yourself!

Fifth Street Bagelry Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Fifth Street Bagelry is a popular spot for freshly baked bagels, sandwiches, and coffee. Reviewers rave about the friendly staff, generous portions, and creative flavor combinations. Some mention long lines, but most agree it's worth the wait.

Review Rating Chart

Yelp: 4.5/5

Google Reviews: 4.4/5

TripAdvisor: 4.5/5

Foursquare: 8.5/10

Facebook Reviews: 4.7/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.7

(939 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Ignacio Rodríguez -Google user

a year ago

Very limited parking / 5⭐ bagels / good spot for hanging out or casual dates First of all the food was really good as far as bagels go. You can choose any bread and then the style of bagel you want. You can also choose 3...Read More

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 47 Layer Bar

abigail bibler -Google user

a year ago

I cannot say enough good things about this place. I live out of town and always make a few trips to 5th Street when I’m in town. Their bagels are the best I’ve ever had and they have a plethora of options to choose from....Read More

Blue -Google user

a year ago

Fifth Street Bagels has fantastic food, drinks, and service. We enjoyed having breakfast here on the little patio area, and hope to come again soon.

Dine inBreakfast$10–20Atmosphere: 5

Ana -Google user

2 years ago

LOVED THIS PLACE!! We came to visit pocatello, and I ended coming 3 days in a row due to how much I liked fifth street bagelry! They have soup of the day which was a surprise, however what I was not expecting is how good their soups...Read More

Jennifer Rae Anderson -Google user

9 months ago

Very good food and affordable! My sister in law Dan'vi and my daughter took me and my boyfriend here while we were in town visiting, loved the food here... A little hidden gem!

Dine inLunch$1–10Atmosphere: 5California Bagel Sandwich, Adobo Club

Sarah Roberts -Google user

a year ago

We came here for breakfast on Saturday and the bagels are the best I’ve ever had. They are even better than Einstein bagels, they are so fresh and have great flavor and texture. I ordered the egg Florentine breakfast sandwich on Asiago and it was...Read More

Allie Tomlinson -Google user

a month ago

It is impossible for me to drive through Pocatello without stopping for the best bagels in the WORLD. i get the pilgrim, add avocado, spinach and sprouts 😇

Atmosphere: 5

Elisa Johnson -Google user

2 years ago

I have been eating here for years. I love this place for lunch and breakfast but this afternoon I got a lemon blueberry bagel that has fresh blueberries on it. Yum right? Well it was until there was mold on 3 blueberries. Completely unacceptable.

Sepehr Honarvarnazari -Google user

2 months ago

Everything was just amazing! The staff was super kind and willing to go above and beyond, the atmosphere was so nice, and the food was just scrumdidlyumscious.

Take outOther$1–10Atmosphere: 5Highly recommendClearly labeled vegetarian dishesPlenty of parkingFree parking lot

Red Hatchet -Google user

a week ago

Free lunch from our pharmacist 🥰 love the sandwich-BLT! Thank you!

Take outLunchAtmosphere: 5

Ryan Cantrell -Google user

2 weeks ago

Excellent breakfast sandwich. Slow, but very friendly service.

Atmosphere: 5

Nikole Missfairy -Google user

9 months ago

I normally love this place but was very disappointed today. I had to call three times to place an order. I got the California Club as usual and wanted to try it on an onion bagel.. think it toasted too long cause it was burnt...Read More

Take outLunch$10–20Service: 3

Aurelie B. -Google user

a year ago

Wonderful bagel place ! The second I come as I am visiting the town again and it is just a delicious lunch- breakfast place with homemade bagels and fresh produce.. love it and highly recommend for a healthy option . Nice outdoor seating for summer...Read More

Alexis Thompson -Google user

3 years ago

Really good customer service and bagels! However, I can never tell when their drive through is open. While some bagels might be more expensive, they're good quality and delicious. Their coffee drinks are good too. They're usually very busy, but their service is still quick....Read More

Lacy Parker -Google user

3 weeks ago

Great place to get a coffee and read the paper on a Sunday. Good service. Yummy food and drink. They have sugar free options. I wish they had a protein coffee option though. Fingers crossed for the future.

$10–20Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talk3-4 peopleUp to 10 min

bananapancake09 -Google user

a month ago

Came home one day after ordering a bunch of bagels and a couple sandwiches. I live about an hour away and when I qwnt through the bags I noticed my sandwiches were missing. I called them and they wrote down that they own me two...Read More

Take outAtmosphere: 5

Dallin Walker (Dal) -Google user

3 months ago

Not really sure how these pass as bagels. About what one would expect in Idaho I suppose. Customer service was decent and I’m glad to see a local business doing well, will give it a shot in the future; was not impressed at all with...Read More

Take outLunch$1–10

M -Google user

4 months ago

Bagels aren’t as good at this location. They look and taste different. Just not very good. Maybe old? The other locations bagels are just fine. Also it’s the middle of winter and there’s still flies around in the building.

Take outBreakfast$10–20

Jeffrey Johnson -Google user

5 months ago

A chocolate chip bagel would have been awesome. I settled for the cinnamon toast bagel but was a tad underwhelmed. All the cinnamon/sugar mix just fell off and nothing really held it to the bagel. I hate to make the comparison...Read More

Take outService: 5

Riley Vanleuven -Google user

a month ago

The bagels are always amazing! It’s too bad that the staff they currently have are unfriendly and lack customer service skills! It takes away from the experience completely.

Features

Service options

Drive-through

In-store pickup

In-store shopping

Takeout

Dine-in

Delivery

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options

Breakfast

Amenities

Wi-Fi

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

People Also Search

Bagel Shops Breakfast Restaurants

Fifth Street Bagelry in Pocatello

Contact

About