Reviews (315) 781-0201 Call Menu Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Edgar’s Restaurant in the Castle is an american restaurant in Geneva, NY.

Edgar’s Restaurant in the Castle Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
3.9
(361 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Rachelle Morales
Rachelle Morales -Google user
3 months ago
We came here for our first Wedding Anniversary on 10-21-24. Great atmosphere, food & service! Thank you 😊 Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Terrie
Terrie -Google user
3 years ago
We stayed at Belhurst Castle on a Wednesday night. I really wanted to eat at Edgar's. I called earlier in the week, but reservations were booked. When we arrived we checked at the restaurant and they were still full. We stopped by a little later...Read More
Loveta Geesey
Loveta Geesey -Google user
3 years ago
The castle is beautiful, the grounds are gorgeous, and the food was delicious. They are very short staffed (and would love to have you come in for an interview), but they took good care of us. The steaks were amazing, and gumbo was tasty with...Read More
Daniel Vasile
Daniel Vasile -Google user
6 months ago
Our Calamari came with no banana peppers or garlic aoli, it was so dry we couldn’t eat it . My filet mignon medium rare had no juices and was so dry I need a drink to swallow it . The creamy garlic mashed potatoes were...Read More
Elizabeth Coffin
Elizabeth Coffin -Google user
8 months ago
It was such a lovely experience. We had dinner in what was once the original castle's parlor. The food was delicious, and our server was attentive! Steak and lobster were cooked perfectly! Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Lobster Tail, Steak Dinner
Justin Tyler
Justin Tyler -Google user
8 months ago
Yes you're going to spend a lot, totally worth it. I came here for my 40th birthday and the food was great. Beautiful atmosphere, great cocktails, and good service. We did have to wait a bit for our food but we were having such a...Read More
Lauren K
Lauren K -Google user
2 months ago
Not every restaurant has to have amazing food! We were in the “we’re going for the atmosphere” camp after seeing other reviews. Just don’t do it. If you are staying in the hotel and are drunk then fine, but then you’re not reading this, are...Read More
Katie Golden
Katie Golden -Google user
6 days ago
Beautiful restaurant but food was not all the great. My lamb did not have a lot of flavor and my husband's prime rib was very cold. For the price we were really disappointed. Also the service was just so-so, again for the price...Read More
Jake Johnson
Jake Johnson -Google user
2 months ago
Can’t say enough good things about this place. 1) the seafood chowder is easily top 5 chowder I’ve ever had. 2) their service was impeccable. We had Brandon as a server, and the guy made the entire experience amazing. Gave the best recommendations. And made the whole...Read More
Tom Renninger
Tom Renninger -Google user
3 months ago
Came here with my wife and father-in-law. They raved about it from past visits. We were seated right outside the castle part in what looked like an addition. It overlooked the lake but it was already dark, so we didn't see anything. It would have...Read More

Features

Service options

check icon Outdoor seating
check icon No-contact delivery
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in

Highlights

check icon Fireplace
check icon Great coffee
check icon Great dessert

Popular for

check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible restroom
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Beer
check icon Cocktails
check icon Coffee
check icon Comfort food
check icon Happy hour drinks
check icon Happy hour food
check icon Hard liquor
check icon Vegetarian options
check icon Wine

Dining options

check icon Brunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Dessert
check icon Seating

Amenities

check icon Bar onsite
check icon Restroom
check icon Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

check icon Cozy
check icon Historic
check icon Romantic
check icon Trendy
check icon Upscale

Crowd

check icon Family-friendly
check icon Groups
check icon LGBTQ+ friendly
check icon Tourists

Planning

check icon Dinner reservations recommended
check icon Accepts reservations

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards

Children

check icon Good for kids
check icon High chairs
check icon Kids' menu

Parking

check icon Free parking lot
check icon Parking

Other

check icon LGBTQ+ friendly