citation network promo banner for desktop
citation network promo for mobile
Bipper Media rounded logo
Bipper Media logo
Restaurants iconRestaurants
American restaurantBarBreakfast restaurantCafeCatererCoffee shopFamily restaurantFast food restaurantHamburger restaurantMexican FoodMexican restaurantPizza restaurantRestaurantRestaurants with Outdoor SeatingSandwich shopTakeout Restaurant
Hotels iconHotels
2-Star hotel3-Star hotel4-Star hotelBed & breakfastCampgroundConference centerExtended stay hotelHotelHotels with SpasInnLodgeMeeting planning serviceMotelResort hotelRV parkWedding venue
Services iconServices
Auto insurance agencyBarber shopBeauty salonHair salonHome insurance agencyInsurance agencyLeak Detection PlumbersLife insurance agencyMarketing agencyMotorcycle insurance agencyNail salonPlumberRenter's insurance agencyRoofing contractorService establishmentWebsite designer
Stores iconStores
ATMBarber shopBeauty supply storeCar dealerCell phone accessory storeCell phone storeClothing storeConvenience storeDiscount storeGas stationGrocery storeHair salonHome goods storeUsed car dealerWalmartWomen's clothing store
Lawyers iconLawyers
AttorneyCar Accident LawyersCriminal Defense LawyerDivorce and Family LawDivorce lawyerDUI LawyersEstate planning attorneyFamily law attorneyLaw firmLegal servicePersonal InjuryPersonal injury attorneyPersonal Injury DoctorPersonal Injury LawPersonal Injury LawyersTrial attorney
...Others
Health iconHealthThings To Do iconThings To DoChurches iconChurchesTransportation iconTransportationWalmart iconWalmartCostco iconCostcoAlbertsons iconAlbertsonsAldi iconAldiSafeway iconSafewayMcdonalds iconMcdonaldsChick Fil A iconChick Fil AFedex iconFedexOlive Garden iconOlive GardenStarbucks iconStarbucksPublix iconPublixTarget iconTargetKroger iconKrogerBest Buy iconBest BuyWalgreens iconWalgreensCVS iconCVSDollar General iconDollar GeneralBars iconBarsBuy A Tree. Change A Life. iconBuy A Tree. Change A Life.
Reviews (920) 882-4044 Call Direction Website Photos About
Restaurants Wisconsin Appleton Carmella's an Italian Bistro
Carmella's an Italian Bistro in Appleton

Carmella's an Italian Bistro in Appleton

Is this your business?
4.7 (1039)
Mon
3:15 pm - 12:00 am
Tue
12:00 am - 9:00 pm
Wed
12:00 am - 9:00 pm
Thu
12:00 am - 9:00 pm
Fri
12:00 am - 9:00 pm
Sat
12:00 am - 9:00 pm
Sun
3:15 pm - 12:00 am
Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings
Restaurants Wisconsin Appleton Carmella's an Italian Bistro
54 Images
Call Direction Website Reviews
(920) 882-4044 Direction Website Reviews

Contact

(920) 882-4044
View on Map

Carmella's an Italian Bistro

716 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton, WI 54913

 http://carmellasbistro.com/
Schedule Tour

About

Carmella's an Italian Bistro, the premier Restaurant in Appleton, WI, invites you to experience the authentic taste of Italy in a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Located at 716 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton, WI 54913, our Italian Bistro is dedicated to serving only the freshest ingredients and traditional Italian cuisine with a modern twist. From classic pasta dishes to mouth-watering pizzas and risottos, our menu is carefully crafted to transport your taste buds to the Tuscan countryside. Our chefs take pride in preparing each dish to order, ensuring every bite is a delight for the senses. Whether you're in the mood for a romantic dinner, a night out with friends, or a family gathering, Carmella's an Italian Bistro is the perfect destination. Our friendly staff, extensive wine list, and elegant ambiance make us the ideal choice for any occasion. Come and indulge in the rich flavors of Italy at Carmella's an Italian Bistro, the ultimate Restaurant experience in Appleton, WI.

Carmella's an Italian Bistro Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.7
(1039 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Tianna Ellis-Jamron
Tianna Ellis-Jamron -Google user
2 years ago
Honestly, my favorite "treat yourself" restaurant in the area!My mother and I got the seared sea scallops appetizer to share, and the scallops were melt in your mouth delicious.Her go-to meal is the chicken marsala, whereas mine is the pappardelle and both were so flavorful...Read More
John Doe
John Doe -Google user
6 years ago
Easily the best Italian restaurant in the area. Low lighting and a classy atmosphere paired extremely well with the excellent service. I didnt have to wait long to be seated and served at the bar and the food was phenomenal. Truly wonderful from salad...Read More
Melissa Christensen
Melissa Christensen -Google user
2 years ago
Good food- better than most Italian restaurants around this area. Portions are generous and our server- Bradley- was amazing!! Prices are not cheap but I believe you get what you pay for with food.They charge for the bread now which is fine with prices going...Read More
Maria Terese
Maria Terese -Google user
2 years ago
Growing up in an Italian Family, it is hard to compare Italian Restaurants and their authenticity to what I am used to; so with that being said, I would say this restaurant is OK. The food isn't anything super exceptional when it comes to...Read More
Pikka
Pikka -Google user
a week ago
I really appreciated the great service while dining at Carmella's. They have a very cozy atmosphere, but the lighting could have been a little brighter as it was hard to study the menu. They have a variety of beers and wines, no liquor....Read More
Food: 4/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 4/5Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot
Ephraim Jacobson
Ephraim Jacobson -Google user
a month ago
Overall, for phenomenal experience this time. The service was exceptional. The food was amazing and the flavors were all on point. Very happy with everything and the experience. The restaurant was not too loud this time so it was quite comfortable to have conversations. I...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 4/5Recommended dishes Tiramisu, Seared Sea Scallops, Fettuccine, Carmella's Chocolate Cake Recommendation for vegetarians Highly recommend Vegetarian offerings Vegetarian menu or section Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot
Momma J On the Move
Momma J On the Move -Google user
5 years ago
We visited on a Wednesday night. We were seated promptly and the wait staff was very friendly and helpful. The ambiance is relaxed and welcoming. The food is amazing! The fresh bread they place on your table when you are seated is delicious! Highly recommend...Read More
Amanda Lynn Baird
Amanda Lynn Baird -Google user
3 years ago
Such a charming bistro! Not only was everything fantastic, but the staff went above and beyond to make us feel special! It was our first time visiting, but we will definitely be back soon! Thanks again to Lisa, Andrew, and Simon for taking care of...Read More
Jacqueline Ellers
Jacqueline Ellers -Google user
9 months ago
Update 2-28-24 again Carmella’s for the win. Waiter Frankie was great. Non-menu Appetizer - Napoleon was fabulous!This time salmon and veal for entrees. AMAZINGLY GOOD! Chocolate Cake best ever!Previously - Great food, great staff, looking to go back and try some more....Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Yanderis Paniagua
Yanderis Paniagua -Google user
4 years ago
ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS.A friend recommended Carmella's and being such a fan of Italian food my husband and I decided to make reservations and check it out. It was well worth the two hour drive. Their staff were welcoming, friendly and well knowledge of their winery's and...Read More
nathan r
nathan r -Google user
3 years ago
This place exceeded expectations. We had the antipasta plate and the spaghetti special with Italian sausage. The spaghetti was a perfect al dente with delicious basil and tomatoes. The antipasta had all sorts of things to try. Several meats and cheeses were especially memorable (not...Read More
Kristen Coenen
Kristen Coenen -Google user
2 years ago
Always a great experience! Food is delicious! Staff is friendly and very knowledgeable about the menu, able to answer any questions you may have. Always feels very warm and welcoming.Parking: Parking lit for strip mall. Usually lots of parking available.
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot
Dani Marie
Dani Marie -Google user
2 years ago
The food is pretty great, very umami and the service matches it. I've been here so many times though, graduations, birthdays, etc. I feel like they should have features and limited time specials to spice up their menu. I stopped wanting to go because they...Read More
Recommended dishes Tiramisu, Antipasta Plate
Dipesh Patel
Dipesh Patel -Google user
5 years ago
Best Italian meal I have had outside Italy!The Scarpariello was absolutely amazing! I had a massive lunch, not the biggest fan of Italian, and I only eat Italian dishes with marinara sauce. This experience and dish has completely changed everything about how I view Italian...Read More
Eric Jones
Eric Jones -Google user
8 years ago
We were here for a small birthday dinner. The menu is really "sophisticated". You need a PhD in food to really understand what you are getting. I find it interesting to see what combinations they come up with. The presentation and...Read More
Caitlin Kestell
Caitlin Kestell -Google user
a week ago
Ask for the Napoleon. It’s not on the menu but it’s delicious. Fresh mozzarella, heirloom tomatoes, balsamic, and basil.Great ambiance. Very cozy and romantic.$3 bread service is worth it. One my favorite restaurants in Appleton.
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes Caprese Salad
Dennis Anderson
Dennis Anderson -Google user
a year ago
No Review Text
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 4/5Recommended dishes Seared Sea Scallops
Brent Richardson
Brent Richardson -Google user
a month ago
Unexpected stop and I was not dressed for this place. The food was excellent and the service top rate. I will be putting on appropriate dress and going back.Kid-friendliness: Excellent service. Over the top friendly.
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes House Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot
Patricia Roll
Patricia Roll -Google user
8 months ago
Part of a group of 9 in March 2024. Only $$$ wine or beer ---no cocktails!! Salad extra for $12-$19 with a $26-$35 dinner. Bread/rolls not served with meal. One dinner, same as one other order, not served until much later only after...Read More
Food: 4/5Service: 3/5Atmosphere: 3/5
Eric Christenson
Eric Christenson -Google user
3 weeks ago
This was our first visit; we decided to try something new, and it seemed promising based on the reviews. The atmosphere was good. The service was great! Our waiter was super friendly and helpful. The food was decent, but nothing super special. They were really...Read More
Food: 3/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 4/5Noise level Quiet, easy to talk Group size 2 people, 3-4 people Wait time Up to 10 min
Marina Lee
Marina Lee -Google user
8 months ago
Last night our family of 3 went out for dinner because we remembered this place being so good. However, we were left very disappointed. I ordered Halibut, which was so dry I had to keep washing it down with water, and the risotto that came...Read More
Food: 1/5
Jessica York
Jessica York -Google user
9 months ago
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Carmella’s is a gem for amazing Italian food! The friendly staff adds a warm touch to the dining experience. I accidentally left my sunglasses, and the owner went above and beyond by offering to mail them to me in Minnesota. Don't miss out on their...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
jeff H
jeff H -Google user
9 months ago
Waitress yes!! Atmosphere ok.Value for money, NO!No soup, no salad and they wanted $3 EXTRA if you want bread!!!$98 for 2 meals and 2 glasses of wine,,,, NOOOOO!!! I left hungry...😐What is missing is Value. Too many other options, explains why it...Read More
Food: 3/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 2/5
Tim Oconnor
Tim Oconnor -Google user
9 months ago
The food was excellent. The service was great. Our waitress was friendly, helpful, and checked back just enough to make for a great experience. Definitely will go again.Parking: Parking is not an issue.
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 4/5Recommended dishes Seared Sea Scallops, Antipasto, Meat and Cheese Plate, Antipasta Plate Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot
Heidi De La Teja
Heidi De La Teja -Google user
5 months ago
🌹I stopped in today around lunchtime and ordered papadeli -Not sure if I spelled that right, but it was absolutely nectar of the gods.🌿 I ordered it with gluten-free noodles since IM gluten sensitive. I must say the whole dish was absolutely over the top...Read More
Atmosphere: 5/5
Michael Kerby
Michael Kerby -Google user
2 years ago
I am relatively new in town, and was taking a cruise and looking for a small bite or a sandwich. I was unfamiliar with this restaurant and thought it was a deli until I walked in the door. I decided to eat anyway...Read More
Charles Shutt
Charles Shutt -Google user
2 years ago
Lovely experience! We dined on the partially enclosed patio, the servers were extremely pleasant and attentive and the manager was active in making a great dining experience.Great menu, wonderful combination of flavors and done well.Highly recommend and one of our favorite spots!
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Brad Pomplun
Brad Pomplun -Google user
2 years ago
Could not have been more impressed! Amazing atmosphere and service (one of the most helpful servers I have ever had at a restaurant), but the food was out of this world. Hands down the BEST food I have ever had... My wife and I went...Read More
Austin Mikii
Austin Mikii -Google user
a year ago
I brought my boyfriend here for his birthday. After reading reviews online, I made a reservation and mentioned it was for my boyfriend’s birthday. When we arrived, the gentleman who was seating (who I also believe took my reservation) wished my boyfriend a “Happy Birthday!”...Read More
Sheila Ipsen
Sheila Ipsen -Google user
a year ago
I was misled in believing that this was a nice family run Italian bistro. Although it is only in a mini mall, this was a pretty upscale place with MORE than upscale pricing. So, don't be misled and enter there in very casual clothing like...Read More
Food: 1/5Service: 1/5Atmosphere: 2/5Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot
Tom Schweitzer
Tom Schweitzer -Google user
a year ago
There were some good flavors in the food but overall the pasta was over cooked, the sauces were real watery but the salads were really good ! It’s way over priced, microwaved bread and old dry parmesan cost extra. Bread and parmesan should be included...Read More
Food: 2/5Service: 4/5Atmosphere: 3/5
Julie Bessette
Julie Bessette -Google user
a year ago
Not impressed. Italian cuisine, pasta is good, flavors are great.The wait staff.. ok. What I DON'T understand is why such "FINE" dining is located in a STRIP mall with the DOLLAR store?? Really offsets the ambience. Also, the bread with oil costs extra, excuse me,...Read More
Michael Flanagan
Michael Flanagan -Google user
5 years ago
Wonderful place for some of the best Italian food to be had anywhere. The staff is extremely nice, knowledgeable and responsive. The menu is definitely a treat and they change it up with some regularity.We've eaten here for years and never had an entree that...Read More
Big City
Big City -Google user
2 years ago
was a last minute decision to go here. they said we could sit without a reservation if it would be less than an hour. not a large menu, which is fine. had a large wine menu which I do not care for. some prices have...Read More
Michael Kersten
Michael Kersten -Google user
2 years ago
Recently traveled to WI from the East Coast for a Golf weekend at Whistling Straits. Heard about Carmella’s so my friend and I decided to drive an hour and 20 minutes north seeking out some good Italian food. Was definitely worth the trip! The food...Read More
Meg Potempa
Meg Potempa -Google user
11 years ago
The restaurant was packed on a Tuesday evening. We called ahead and arrived at5:30, so were seated promptly. Michael was our waiter and he is the best! He knows his job and does it very well. He is just the right...Read More
Tianna Ellis
Tianna Ellis -Google user
5 years ago
Never, ever, ever a bad meal! The servers are all attentive, I never once had to ask for a drink refill, they were on the ball. The staff is always knowledgeable about the menu and answer any question to the best of their abilities. The...Read More
Michelle Sorenson
Michelle Sorenson -Google user
3 years ago
This is hands down the best restaurant in the area and certainly tops for italian fare. The food was incredible (you can never go wrong ordering one of the specials) and I particularly enjoyed the Gingerbread Creme Brulee for dessert that tasted as delicious as...Read More
Justin Mackey
Justin Mackey -Google user
4 years ago
Did curbside carry out last night and it was excellent! Food was ready and brought out to my car within seconds of pulling up. It was still hot and delicious after my 15 min drive home. Wife did the special Maine Lobster Risotto, the kids...Read More
dahl1derrick
dahl1derrick -Google user
3 years ago
This place has the best Italian food in the fox valley. I moved to Appleton a few years ago and this is one of my favorite restaurants in the area. I celebrated my birthday there this year and the staff went above and beyond to...Read More
Thomas Keller
Thomas Keller -Google user
2 years ago
One of our favorite restaurant however not good last night sorry to say. Pasta was hard and my filet was covered with a sauce that I could not even see what it is. We all had to take our flashlights out to see the menu...Read More
Shelley Draeger
Shelley Draeger -Google user
7 years ago
Another favourite restaurant of mine. High quality local ingredients, made to order and fresh, very well trained staff who understands the food.They are always busy, so call ahead and reserve a table. Make sure to get the homemade soups or salads before dinner. They have...Read More
Myrtie Fendryk
Myrtie Fendryk -Google user
3 years ago
I always enjoy my meals here. We went for a 16th birthday surprise meal and were not disappointed. Great staff, and even better food. I tried a salad this time and it was very good. It's so nice to have a consistent, well priced for...Read More
Hannah Kasten
Hannah Kasten -Google user
2 years ago
Very friendly staff, great service, and great food! We choose to arrive at 5pm and that seems to have been a good choice. Once 6pm rolled around the restaurant became quite busy.We have the Fussili and the Paparedelle and theh were both fantastic! The Paparedelle...Read More
Elizabeth VandenBoom
Elizabeth VandenBoom -Google user
4 years ago
Why have we been sleeping on this amazing Bistro?!?! Unreal amazing dinner last night. Had a gift card from our wedding we finally used. Conner our server was so informative and helpful with everything. Super knowledgeable server! Everything we had was amazing. I couldn't say...Read More
Michael Keeler
Michael Keeler -Google user
3 years ago
Food was ok apps where very good, I had the featured special the clams with a white wine lemon sauce. Honestly it tasted like lemon water with a hint of wine. I was not impressed this go around. Very disappointed with Carmellas this time. 3...Read More
Donna Boyce
Donna Boyce -Google user
5 years ago
I used to like Carmella's. Not anymore. In the last two times I ate there, the food was not good. Doesn't come close to justifying the price.Last time, my husband's dish was supposed to contain shrimp, pasta and vegetables. There were about 5...Read More
Mike Davidson
Mike Davidson -Google user
8 years ago
This is easily going to be some of the best food in town. I went here for a business dinner and could tell by the midweek crowd that it was popular. They have a good beer and wine selection, and I'd suggest starting with appetizers...Read More

Features

From the business

check icon Identifies as women-owned

Service options

check icon Outdoor seating
check icon Curbside pickup
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

check icon Great cocktails
check icon Great coffee
check icon Great dessert
check icon Great wine list

Popular for

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible restroom
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Beer
check icon Cocktails
check icon Coffee
check icon Comfort food
check icon Happy hour drinks
check icon Hard liquor
check icon Healthy options
check icon Small plates
check icon Vegetarian options
check icon Wine

Dining options

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Catering
check icon Dessert
check icon Seating

Amenities

check icon Bar onsite
check icon Restroom

Atmosphere

check icon Casual
check icon Cozy
check icon Romantic
check icon Trendy
check icon Upscale

Crowd

check icon Groups
check icon LGBTQ+ friendly
check icon Tourists
check icon Transgender safespace

Planning

check icon Dinner reservations recommended
check icon Accepts reservations
check icon Usually a wait

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards
check icon NFC mobile payments

Children

check icon High chairs
check icon Kids' menu

Parking

check icon Free parking lot
check icon Parking

Other

check icon LGBTQ+ friendly
check icon Identifies as women-owned

People Also Search

Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings

Contact

(920) 882-4044
View on Map

Carmella's an Italian Bistro

716 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton, WI 54913

 http://carmellasbistro.com/
Schedule Tour

Related Search Appleton

Appleton American Restaurants Appleton Asian Restaurants Appleton Bakeries Appleton Bars Appleton Bar & Grills Appleton Barbecue Restaurants Appleton Breakfast Restaurants Appleton Brunch Restaurants Appleton Burrito Restaurants Appleton Cafes Appleton Caterers Appleton Chicken Restaurants Appleton Chicken Wings Restaurants Appleton Chinese Restaurants Appleton Cocktail Bars Appleton Coffee Shops Appleton Coffee Stores Appleton Delis Appleton Delivery Restaurants Appleton Delivery Services Appleton Diners Appleton Domino's Pizzas Appleton Espresso Bars Appleton Family Restaurants Appleton Fast Food Restaurants Appleton Hamburger Restaurants Appleton Health Food Restaurants Appleton Internet Cafes Appleton Italian Restaurants Appleton Japanese Restaurants Appleton Latin American Restaurants Appleton Lunch Restaurants Appleton Mediterranean Restaurants Appleton Mexican Foods Appleton Mexican Restaurants Appleton Pizza Takeouts Appleton Pizza Deliveries Appleton Pizza Restaurants Appleton Restaurants Appleton Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Appleton Sandwich Shops Appleton Seafood Restaurants Appleton Sports Bars Appleton Steak Houses Appleton Sushi Restaurants Appleton Taco Restaurants Appleton Takeout Restaurants Appleton Tex-Mex Restaurants Appleton Thai Restaurants Appleton Vegetarian Restaurants Appleton Wine Bars

People found Restaurants by searching for…

Appleton Breakfast Restaurants Appleton Fast Food Restaurants Appleton Mexican Foods Appleton Mexican Restaurants Appleton Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Appleton Takeout Restaurants

Find best businesses

Texas Car Accident Lawyers