Reviews (631) 345-5454 Call Website Photos About

Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant in Middle Island

Name: Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant in Middle Island
Address: 1259 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, New York, 11953, US
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.4

Is this your business?

4.4 (218)

Pizza Restaurants

Call Direction Website Reviews

(631) 345-5454 Direction Website Reviews

About

Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a pizza restaurant in Middle Island, NY.

Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.4

(218 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Christina Wahl -Google user

Edited 3 years ago

Tonight I got what I called the pasta trifecta it’s delicious and vegetarian friendly and I love and and my salad. It’s all yummy from my husbands chicken fettuccine Alfredo to my asd child’s chicken parmigiana hero to my special needs daughters sausage, garlic worth...Read More

Sufei Zhao -Google user

5 years ago

Ordered takeout here for 4 pies and they were all SO good! My favorite is the pesto pizza, it was filled with fresh tomatoes and drizzled with pesto. They are so generous with toppings, the buffalo chicken pizza was packed with meat. The owners also...Read More

Tony Isaman -Google user

2 months ago

Great pizza joint, friendly staff and wide assortment of choices.

Lunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Suitable for all group sizesNo wait

Michael schwartz (Mike4Christ) -Google user

a year ago

If you have an urge to get enjoyably good pizza this is the place all their food is amazing. The owner Renee and her husband Paul do an amazing job at what they do... So please if your looking for good food come here, you...Read More

Take outLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Garlic Knots, Chicken Wrap, Sicilian, Sausage, Grandma's Pizza, Garlic Bread

Lisa Jacobs -Google user

4 years ago

Paul goes above and beyond! When ordering some pizzas for delivery, I mentioned I was doing so to thank my staff for all the great things they do. It never occurred to me to ask for anything special to be "written" on a pizza...but Paul...Read More

Abby Marie -Google user

3 months ago

Great pizza!! No flop good, good under carriage, just the right amount of cheese. Also, think it's only place in area that uses a big box for to go pizza!! Pizza fits better in big box, really does affect the pizza. ...Read More

N. Wittreich -Google user

Edited a week ago

Considering it was lent I ordered from this Pizzeria a shrimp Parmesan dinner when it arrived at my house and had taken it in as I opened it, it looked like chicken cutlets to me even the delivery driver said I made...Read More

Take outAtmosphere: 5

tammy callas -Google user

a month ago

Had the Baked Pasta Trio. Food is delicious, great prices, and very friendly staff. Been there twice now. It was recommended to me by a friend.

Howard Koster -Google user

5 months ago

I ALWAYS enjoy the food here!! I get along well with everyone there! Very pleasant experience every time I go there.

Dine inOther$10–20Atmosphere: 5Garlic Knots, Sicilian, Chicken Wrap, Lasagna, Meatballs, Chicken Parmigiana

john paniccioli -Google user

9 months ago

For years I have gone between two pizza places in Ridge. CAPIO'S is the winner. The owners are always there working butt's off. Always polite and that counts to me. I never say anything except observe. AND pizza is fantastic.

Take outDinner$1–10Atmosphere: 5Plenty of parkingFree parking lot

Frank Turrigiano -Google user

10 months ago

Service and atmosphere based on a walk-in Pizza Parlor. Had both Sicilian slice and regular slice. The Sicilian slice was very proofed. Very light and airy. Very good taste. Regular slice was also very good.

Take outLunch$1–10Atmosphere: 5Sicilian

Shereen Tartaglia -Google user

a year ago

The food at Capios is always top notch. We have had 3 parties catered and going to have a 4th this weekend. I cannot recommend them enough. Some of my family members have actually used them for parties as well. The food always arrives nice...Read More

Alysa Buchanan -Google user

a year ago

True New York style pizza, with a sauce to keep you coming back for more. Always a great variety of slices and rolls to choose from and reasonably priced. Atmosphere is comfortable enough to eat in and service is quick enough to take it to...Read More

Dine inDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 5Garlic Knots

Rob Laukaitis -Google user

a year ago

Shout out to the delivery guy tonight 5/24/24. Arrived 15 mins sooner and was very polite. Unfortunately I had an old number stored when ordering my food online so he had to wait about 5 mins. I am very so sorry. He was very patient...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Jami Beahm -Google user

11 months ago

Here for a softball tournament and decided to try. Cozy little place. The pizza was great and staff was very friendly. Price was very reasonable.

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5

It's just me -Google user

a year ago

Capio's pizzeria is the best indeed!! It is always the go-.to place whenever I don't have time or efforts to cook. Quick, delicious pizza, and very welcoming faces all the time.

Atmosphere: 5

Christine Guzzardo -Google user

a year ago

I have been out in ridge for about 5 years now and this is by far the BEST pizza shop here! The pizza is sooo good and the food is even better. Especially the penne alla vodka with shrimp! My family and I come here...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

JJ -Google user

7 months ago

Best place on long island. Awesome owners and amazing food and service. I have been here a decade best around. JOHN!

DeliveryDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Sicilian, Broccoli Rabe, Spicy Chicken Wings, Chicken Piccata, Fettuccine Alfredo, Lasagna, Fried Ravioli, Meatballs, Chicken Parmigiana, Fried Calamari

Adam Maxwell -Google user

5 months ago

One of the best pepperoni pizzas I’ve ever had

Atmosphere: 5

Maria Cassano -Google user

5 years ago

Just moved to town today and ordered from this place because A). They had gluten free pizza and B). They were close enough to deliver, so I could get a no-hassle meal for the friends/family who helped me move. They were so sweet and helpful on...Read More

Melissa Olsen -Google user

7 years ago

LOVE THIS PLACE! Delicious, fresh, made to order food. The owner is so nice and always present. They offer gluten free options and are extremely willing and able to accommodate people with dietary restrictions, without compromising the …

Zach Foreman -Google user

3 years ago

Before I even talk about the food, the staff is amazing. Extremely friendly. Love a family owned business. The penne alla vodka is to die for. Paul and Sal make the best pizza in town. I highly recommend their take on a Sicilian pie, it...Read More

Patrice B. -Google user

6 years ago

The pizza here is amazing! My husband and I moved to NY in May and Capio's fast became our favorite local place to get food from.Be careful - it's a bit addictive :) The staff is always very friendly and helpful. If your looking for...Read More

Marilyn Brown -Google user

3 years ago

I've never ordered or had food from Capios, but it was the restaurant that was suggested to me when I wanted to have food catered to my family members home in Middle Island for 25-30 people. I made the call from my home...Read More

connie jackson -Google user

5 years ago

I have placed orders on a weekly basis and have never been disappointed in the food. This week I had a family dinner and was not up to cooking, thought of you and placed an order from your catering menu, everyone loved the food. Thought...Read More

Becca Godwin -Google user

3 years ago

I had ordered 10 pies & 4 dozen garlic knots they knocked it out of the park!! All 10 of my pizzas were hot & freash! They went above an beyond! Everyone at the birthday party loved the pizzas!

Jennifer McCarthy -Google user

3 years ago

Absolutely LOVE this place!! I’m from NJ and moved to LI about 4 years ago. And honestly I hated the pizza here on LI. Until we moved to Middle Island and discovered Capios. We order from here at least 3x a week. They never disappoint.

Logan Skipas -Google user

3 years ago

I ate capios 3 times last week, not just for the delicious pizza, but the impeccable service that I get every time. Always with a smile. It feels like family. Paul always asks about my daughter annalia and even has a pizza in his glass...Read More

Eileen S -Google user

6 years ago

Capio's catered our family party. Everyone raved about the rigatoni a La vodka and lasagna. This is our favorite place to order good, delicious traditional Italian dishes. They are just the best! A really nice family owned place,

Salvatore Dirato -Google user

9 years ago

I'm new to Middle Island, and have not been able to find a decent pizza since moving here. Well I need to look no further, by far the best pizza in town. The crust has a great taste to it, the sauce, mmmm so good,...Read More

Features

Service options

No-contact delivery

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Comfort food

Healthy options

Quick bite

Vegetarian options

Dining options

Lunch

Dinner

Catering

Dessert

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Planning

Accepts reservations

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

Parking

Free parking lot

Parking

People Also Search

Pizza Restaurants

Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant in Middle Island

Contact

About

Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant Review Summary