Reviews (315) 574-2236 Call Menu Direction Photos About
Call Direction Reviews

About

Caffe’ Maya is an italian restaurant in Herkimer, NY.

Caffe’ Maya Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Pros

Caffe' Maya is a hidden gem in the heart of the city, offering a cozy and intimate atmosphere that's perfect for catching up with friends or getting some work done. Their expertly crafted coffee drinks are made with high-quality beans, and their menu features a variety of unique flavors and specials. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure customers feel welcome and valued. Additionally, the cafe is clean and well-maintained, with plenty of seating and outlets available.

Cons

Some customers have reported that the cafe can get quite busy during peak hours, making it difficult to find a seat. The menu can be a bit limited, especially for those with dietary restrictions, and the prices may be slightly higher than what's found at other coffee shops in the area. Furthermore, the cafe's location on Main Street can make it difficult to find parking, especially during rush hour.

Review Rating Chart

Yelp: 4.5/5

Google Reviews: 4.4/5

TripAdvisor: 4.5/5

Facebook Reviews: 4.7/5

Zomato: 4.3/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.8
(46 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Rebekah Martino
Rebekah Martino -Local Guide
4 months ago
Absolutely delicious food... and dessert! Grabbed some olives from the cold case 😋 Would DEFINITELY come here again, the sauce was fresh and craveworthyVegetarian options: Pasta, eggplant parm, pizza, sandwiches, etc
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Ann Bond
Ann Bond -Local Guide
a week ago
My son and I had a really good Silicillian Eggplant dish, layer in roasted peppers, etc. If you can't have a lot of salt don't eat this dish. My husband had a creamy dish, looked like a lobster tail, rich, but tasty. ...Read More
Food: 4/5Service: 3/5Atmosphere: 4/5
Robert Ball
Robert Ball
a year ago
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
elise
elise
4 months ago
Everything was phenomenal. We started with the antipasto which is perfect (the salad dressing is amazing and all of the toppings were high quality). We also tried the stuffed long hots and stuffed portobello. Both were delicious and the homemade red sauce was SO good....Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 4/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Donald “JAY” Huggins
Donald “JAY” Huggins -Local Guide
a month ago
As authentic and as delicious as possible....Real Utica Italian food! Veal Scamardo was perfect, Haddock Francaise was light & flavorful, the Marinara was fresh & on point! Christian & staff were attentive as well as entertaining... Too full for dessert, they all looked beautiful, i...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Madison Migneault
Madison Migneault
5 months ago
Incredible!!! Tried the lobster ravioli and the vodka riggies with chicken, and was completely blown away! All ingredients are fresh, and these are some of the best riggies I’ve ever had. Not to mention, the prices are more than reasonable! Should you stick around long...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Lorrie Deapo
Lorrie Deapo -Local Guide
10 months ago
If I could give this place a 10 I would. Second time I've been here & the food was extraordinary. The service exceptional & the desserts so decadent!! Food came out hot & delicious. Today we traveled from Syracuse to Herkimer just to enjoy...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Anthony Paparella
Anthony Paparella
11 months ago
Excellent home made Italian fare by a very talented young chef.Veal Scamada (made with prociutto, eggplant, and fontina cheese,etc.) is a great dish.Antipasto for one or for two,has various meats, egg, tuna, peppers, tomato, etc.are wonderful. Also had Angel hair pasta and homemade bread.Just like...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Marlene Hobaica
Marlene Hobaica
10 months ago
What a nice place owner great and great service good food reasonable try it it’s great !!!!Vegetarian options: No meatParking: We were able to park in front perfect
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Features

Service options

check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in

Popular for

check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Coffee
check icon Comfort food

Dining options

check icon Dinner
check icon Dessert

Amenities

check icon Restroom

Atmosphere

check icon Casual
check icon Cozy

Crowd

check icon Groups
check icon Tourists

Payments

check icon Credit cards

Children

check icon Good for kids

People Also Search