Reviews (516) 804-8004 Call Website Photos About

Brooklyn Square Pizza in Seaford

Brooklyn Square Pizza in Seaford

Is this your business?

4.4 (192)

Pizza Restaurants Italian Restaurants Delivery Restaurants

Call Direction Website Reviews

(516) 804-8004 Direction Website Reviews

About

Brooklyn Square Pizza is a pizza restaurant in Seaford, NY.

Brooklyn Square Pizza Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.4

(192 Reviews)

5

4

3

2

1

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

June Stoyer -Google user

7 years ago

Excellent authentic N.Y. style pizza with sesame crust! The garlic knots are delicious and not too doughy!

Joseph Lanzarotta -Google user

6 years ago

Finally got to try these guys out after seeing them on social media and it was absolutely delicious the sicilian slice was amazing the sauce was excellent and there regular slice was good as well and some of there slices have the sesame seed crust...Read More

Dennis M. -Google user

5 years ago

All thumbs up...treated the guys to lunch on the tail gate and these guys made it well....and 14 bucks.... they didn't hit me over the head with the cost....love the sesame seed crust...nice touch!

Nancy Jovel -Google user

5 months ago

I love their square pizza !!! It’s exactly like spumoni Gardens. I recommend this place to all my family and friends !

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Slice, Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza Slice, Specialty Slice, Square Slice, Chicken Cutlet, Fresh MozzarellaHighly recommendPlenty of parkingFree parking lotVery kid friendly !!

Courtney Urrutia -Google user

a year ago

Awesome spot for the BEST Pizza!! I’m a born & raised NY’er but I’ve been in Florida the past twenty years, where you just don’t get awesome pizza, bagels or anything bread related, down here!! So being back in town for a visit, we were looking for...Read More

Dine inLunchAtmosphere: 5

Tony Naclerio -Google user

4 months ago

Very solid slices. Sesame seed on the crust is always good

Atmosphere: 5

Kerlin Bonilla -Google user

6 months ago

Extremely delicious pizza my favorite was the Brooklyn square pizza and the customer service was amazing 10/10 recommend it.

Dine inDinner$10–20Atmosphere: 5

Alura Alvarez -Google user

11 months ago

My family frequently visits this pizzaria even though we have good pizza locally in Lynbrook. Brooklyn Square Pizza has some of the best flavor for classic and gourmet slices and cozy feels of a traditional pizzaria. Will be back again soon!

Dine inLunch$1–10Atmosphere: 5Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza SliceNot sureVegetarian menu or section

Joe -Google user

3 years ago

This is the best pizza! Sweet tomato sauce on top of thin layer of fresh mozzarella cheese. No garlic, onions or dried spices. Very light and refreshing. Not your typical Sicilian slice. May not be for everyone but I love it.

Michael Rudolph -Google user

a year ago

I always liked this pizzeria. The owner and his son are very nice and make good food. I would definitely recommend getting pizza here.

Atmosphere: 5

Dean Livingston -Google user

3 years ago

Hands down the best pizza you will find in all of Long Island. The Grandma slice is my favorite but they may have the best meatballs ever. I just moved to Seaford and come here regularly. Don’t take my word, try them once for yourself...Read More

K -Google user

7 years ago

This is some amazing pizza. We ordered 2 slices each and that was a mistake. They are huge!! The buffalo chicken pizza was amazing! So much friggin chicken cutlet on It! The square pies where crispy and fresh the eggplant, zucchini, roasted …

Frank Pronounced Like Jenna (Jenna) -Google user

3 years ago

I don't usually do reviews, but this place was so good, I had to. This was our first time eating from there. We ordered later in the evening and usually late night orders aren't given the same love, but this place produced some awesome food...Read More

Maria Sierra -Google user

4 years ago

This place is amazing. It never disappoints. I am Italian and their sauce is very good. They never burn their chicken cutlets. The pizza is very good too. We order in right now and our food is delivered earlier than promised and it’s always HOT.

Tom Durkin -Google user

Edited 6 years ago

Friendly staff and owner their spinnage/ artichoke slice was to die for, best in years. They usually only make it on Fridays. Their plain slice had a strong tomato taste which I liked but was a little to strong for my wife.

Paul Abriola -Google user

6 years ago

Brooklyn square pizza is a rare find. They make a type of pizza we know as "bakery pizza" which we have rarely found outside of Brooklyn. It is awesome. Of course they make other styles which are also great. …

s1r_magnus -Google user

6 years ago

I wish I lived closer like I did 10 yrs ago. Even though Carmela's is fantastic and only a few blocks up the road, they got NOTHING on this place. When it comes to quality, exquisite, delicious pizza, Brooklyn Square is the best in Nassau...Read More

Mary K -Google user

2 years ago

I love this place! My favorite pizza from here is their grandma's pie. It's incredible and will change your tastebuds for life with the awesomeness!

Temponomic -Google user

a year ago

I get a slice or two here and there. I love the pizza, and I’ve never had issues with the staff or the food.

Dan Ramirez -Google user

3 years ago

The square pie is very delicious. The sauce on top has just the right amount of sweetness to it and there is not and overwhelming amount of cheese.

Features

Service options

No-contact delivery

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Comfort food

Late-night food

Quick bite

Dining options

Lunch

Dinner

Dessert

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Cozy

Crowd

College students

Groups

Planning

Accepts reservations

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

People Also Search

Pizza Restaurants Italian Restaurants Delivery Restaurants