Reviews (914) 600-8848 Call Website Photos About

Benny’s Brown Bag in Peekskill

Benny’s Brown Bag in Peekskill

Is this your business?

4.9 (203)

Sandwich Shops

295 Images

Menus

Call Direction Website Reviews

(914) 600-8848 Direction Website Reviews

About

Benny’s Brown Bag is a sandwich shop in Peekskill, NY.

Benny’s Brown Bag Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Benny’s Brown Bag is a favorite spot for delicious, freshly made sandwiches with generous portions and friendly service. Customers love the variety of options, from classic favorites to creative specials, all served quickly in a cozy, casual setting. The ingredients are always fresh, making each bite flavorful. Prices are reasonable, and the staff goes out of their way to ensure a pleasant experience. It’s an ideal place for a quick lunch or a relaxed bite with friends.

Review Rating Chart

Google: 4.7/5

Yelp: 4.5/5

TripAdvisor: 4.6/5

Facebook: 4.8/5

Zomato: 4.4/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.9

(203 Reviews)

5

4

3

2

1

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Jodes Greco -Google user

9 months ago

Took the ride from the other side up to see what this spot was all about. I wish I lived closer…. The vibe is super chill. The entire operation appears to be run with a real love for what they do. They had some unique...Read More

Take outLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Bettuna Sando, The Bear Mountain Hot Roast Beef

Sharmaine -Google user

5 months ago

Never thought I’d ever be into turkey sandwiches—until I tried Benny’s Brown Bag. We first had them on a tour boat nearby and had to find out who was making them. We’ve been hooked ever since. 10/10, especially for the friendly staff and cozy, cute...Read More

$10–20Atmosphere: 5Turkey Chili CrispWalk-ins onlyFree street parking

Andrés Saldías -Google user

4 months ago

Unassuming place. Some hipster vibes to it. Was there 5 minutes after opening time and it had a few folks waiting already. Impressive variety of drinks. The mac salad is probably the best mac salad i have had, good salt, tangy, with some umami flavor to...Read More

$20–30Atmosphere: 5Moderate noiseNot sure

Carolina Morata Pérez -Google user

a year ago

The best sandwiches we’ve tasted in NY so far! Definitely a must-try if you’re in the area. We had a Thai sandwich and a veggie one—both were delicious! The only downside is the lack of dining space, but we found a nice picnic spot nearby!

Take outLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Highly recommendLarge vegetarian selection, Clearly labeled vegetarian dishesPlenty of parkingFree parking lot, Free street parking

Jacq Horning -Google user

Edited a year ago

Seriously baller vibes and top notch eats! The beer and snack selections are fun and unique and the sandwiches are hands-down the best - completely drool-worthy! Can't recommend the tuna enough and my husband had the roast beef sandwich and said it was one of...Read More

Take outLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Chimi Chimi Roast Beef Sandwich, Bettuna Sando

Edwin O'Brien -Google user

2 years ago

A+ Sandwich perfection—unfussy recipes, super fresh ingredients, and just right proportions. Good space, nice people, good snacks and coffee. I stopped by on my way upstate. Quick, nice detour from the highway. It was pretty busy for such a new spot, but they work hard to keep the...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Amanda Zhang -Google user

10 months ago

Amazing sandwiches, amazing vibes. If I lived closer, this would definitely be my go to spot for a grab-and-go lunch. Banana pudding was hands down the best I've had. I can't wait to come back soon!

Atmosphere: 5

Vivian Nicastro -Google user

a year ago

The sandwiches are BANGIN’. You can’t go wrong…they are so good. I loved the chili crisp turkey, but I was fortunate enough to try a bite of the buffalo chicken…10/10. They’ve got a fun selection of offerings to browse while you wait on your sandwiches, plus...Read More

Lunch

Carlee -Google user

a year ago

The Prosciutto Paisan is THE perfect sandwich - salty and sweet, dressed yet satisfyingly crunchy, and just the right amount of creaminess from the mozzarella. It’s all I’ve ever ordered from Benny’s and it never disappoints. If it doesn’t sound right for you...Read More

Take outLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Grilled Cheese w Bacon

Rachel W -Google user

a year ago

From their (very clearly) high-quality ingredients to their generous portion sizes, it’s definitely a new local favorite. A satisfying sandwich that will never leave you feeling bogged down! The choice of unique snacks and drinks are another fun perk. It was fantastic walking into a...Read More

Take outLunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5

Mark LaFaro -Google user

2 months ago

I’d say that this is the #1 sandwich shop in Westchester, but it would be unfair to rank professionals with amateurs. Benny’s is in a league of its own like Geena Davis or BASEketball.

$10–20Atmosphere: 5Prosciutto Paisan

John Flynn -Google user

2 weeks ago

I recently discovered Benny's and a bit depressed I was late to the game. A great sandwich shop. To date I have had the Chilii Turkey, Thai Fried Chicken, and the Chimi Chimi Roast Beef. All are excellent. The Thai Fried Chicken would be...Read More

Take outAtmosphere: 5

Selena Rook McMahan -Google user

2 weeks ago

This sandwich place is so awesome. Really carefully crafted sandwiches. Such tasty combinations and a very fun atmosphere. We regularly drive 45min out of our way just to get a Benny's sandwich.

$10–20Atmosphere: 5Turkey Chili Crisp, Thai Fried Chicken Sandwich, The Bear Mountain Hot Roast BeefQuiet, easy to talkNo wait

Pablo Momene -Google user

a month ago

Great service and sandwiches. I had the Prosciutto Paisan. Delicious. Bread was top quality. Girlfriend had the veggie sandwich. I had a bite and it was also really good. Guy at the counter was very nice. Cool stuff to look at while you wait.

Take out$10–20Atmosphere: 5

Griffin Dennis -Google user

a week ago

Best sandwiches in the game. Perfect harmony of textures and flavor; everything in balance to create a symphony greater than the sum of its parts. Incredible and friendly staff and excellent vibes all around.

$10–20Atmosphere: 5Prosciutto Paisan, Thai Fried Chicken Sandwich, Chimi Chimi Ya Roast BeefNo wait

Alexandra Holesinska -Google user

2 months ago

The sandwiches at Benny’s are amazing! Today we tried the Thai Chicken and the Southern Fried Chicken, and both were packed with flavor and absolutely delicious. Great quality and taste – we’ll definitely be coming back!

$10–20Atmosphere: 5Up to 10 min

Daniella Gostev -Google user

a month ago

Vegan Sky high veggie stack. I’ve tried lots of vegan sandwiches and this is the best if not second best vegan sandwich I’ve ever had from a shop. The staff were also really friendly to me and my brother. Thank you!

$10–20Food: 5Sky High Veggie StackHighly recommendClearly labeled vegetarian dishes

Brandon Winters -Google user

4 months ago

Just finished my first sandwich from Benny's. My wife and I both got the Chili Crisp Turkey and we both agreed it's probably the best sandwich we've ever eaten. Benny's Brown Bag is the gold standard by which all other sandwiches should be measured. If...Read More

Take out$10–20Atmosphere: 5Turkey Chili Crisp, Chili Crisp TurkeyNo wait

Julian Flowers -Google user

2 months ago

HONESTLY, the best sandwich I’ve ever had. I couldn’t believe how much meat was included & it tasted AMAZING. Bettina is the best, always welcoming and friendly. A must stop whenever I’m passing by.

Atmosphere: 5

Fat Kid-Diarys -Google user

3 months ago

Stopping in at Benny’s for some sandwiches. Got the chili crisp turkey for myself and was VERY good. The chili added a nice flavor profile to the sandwich. All the sandwiches were generous sized making the value perfect.

Atmosphere: 5

Features

Service options

Takeout

Delivery

Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Assistive hearing loop

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Coffee

Comfort food

Quick bite

Vegan options

Vegetarian options

Dining options

Lunch

Dinner

Catering

Dessert

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Cozy

Trendy

Crowd

Tourists

Planning

Accepts reservations

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

Parking

Free street parking

Parking

Pets

Dogs allowed outside

People Also Search

Sandwich Shops