Reviews (516) 746-2881 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Bagelman is a restaurant in Garden City, NY.

Bagelman Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4
(220 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Ben Skidmore
Ben Skidmore -Google user
a year ago
I like being able to support local businesses while traveling. Bagelman is great! Fantastic bagel sandwich! Perfectly toasted, fluffy eggs, and make sure to order extra crispy bacon! The woman at the counter was super helpful and friendly. Customers are obviously regulars and also have...Read More
Dine inBrunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5
mariana H
mariana H -Google user
3 years ago
So I was looking for bagels, and I ended up here! Did not disappoint!! I got an egg everything bagel with cream cheese and bacon. So so good, fresh and crispy! To drink I got a Bagelman Mixer which is their creation of pink...Read More
In Wonder
In Wonder -Google user
3 years ago
Amazing experience ordering mini bagels for a party the day before. They were ready earlier than the original pickup time we were told. So professional and super nice.
Bill M
Bill M -Google user
4 years ago
My favorite breakfast spot. Sometimes the line gets backed up, but it’s worth the wait.
Kris Krane
Kris Krane -Google user
a year ago
Great bagels and super nice people! I’m a native New Yorker who lives in Chicago and was in the area for work. Went to Bagelman for lunch and had a delicious bagel with cream cheese and lox. I left as they were closing for the...Read More
Rahul Verma
Rahul Verma -Google user
a year ago
One of the best breakfast sandwiches I ever had. The French vanilla iced coffee is definitely a treat. The cashier lady was extremely nice and helpful aswell.
Take outBreakfast$10–20Atmosphere: 5
Brian Lemen
Brian Lemen -Google user
a year ago
Just a fantastic experience while in garden city for an event. Ryan is a simply amazing person. Remembered our names, and order! And the Bagels were super as well!
Dine inBreakfast$10–20Atmosphere: 5
Yolo M
Yolo M -Google user
2 years ago
AMAZING BAGELS AND KIND STAFF! This was my very first experience trying New York Bagels and BOY IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT! I was very confused at first with the amount of options offered but the cashier was very kind and helpful and explained how i...Read More
jason trompeter
jason trompeter -Google user
a year ago
Wow! Nicest staff ever. Lots of good bagel options and they will put anything on a bagel! Very pleasant place to go for breakfast or lunch.
Atmosphere: 4
Robert Guardino
Robert Guardino -Google user
5 years ago
Came to NYC with a definite desire to find a great bagel shop and we found it at Bagelman, Garden City. A bit tight on seating space but for the reason that there is typically a line waiting to get the great bagels and other...Read More
Marilia Nunez
Marilia Nunez -Google user
7 years ago
I've taken way too long to write this review... Ive worked in the area for about 4 years now and this is my first choice to visit at least twice every week... It is consistently delicious and I can always expect the staff and Owner...Read More
Nathan Jones
Nathan Jones -Google user
5 years ago
Was in town for a wedding and ate breakfast there 2 days in a row. The mexiwrap and bagel breakfast sandwiches were on point. The seasoned potatoes are a must. Great food, great price, great service. Go early because it got...Read More
N. S.
N. S. -Google user
4 years ago
always great service, and tasty breakfast sandwiches. been going to bagelman for over 25 years (when they used to be around the …
Wayne Christo
Wayne Christo -Google user
3 years ago
Me and my family had a vacation trip in New York City and we were staying not too far from BagelMan . We stopped in and got some rainbow bagels and the lady and the gentleman was very friendly and they said will make...Read More
Christopher Casa
Christopher Casa -Google user
3 years ago
Great lunch/breakfast spot. Bagels are really good and fresh, with lots of seasoning, and are soft on the inside. Sandwiches are great. I love the chicken salad with the cranberries and walnuts in it.
John J. Byrne
John J. Byrne -Google user
3 years ago
Every-time I go in I leave happy. Bagels are always good quality bagels and the service is always good. Quick turn around for food orders and sandwich orders. They have really good coffee and iced tea.
Maria Hincapie
Maria Hincapie -Google user
4 years ago
Great service! They are taking good precautions and have plenty of outdoor seating available. Service was quick and friendly. They have a nice selection of teas, coffee, and bagels to choose from as well as sandwiches and other lunch foods.
Drew Winslow
Drew Winslow -Google user
11 years ago
Nice NY style bagels, house-made fresh salads and a really rich, classically simple, and oh so tasty tuna, just like Mama used to make! Clean, comfortable and fast competent service. Owner Kenny and his family are everything an old school "mom and pop"...Read More
Viviene Hogarth
Viviene Hogarth -Google user
8 years ago
I ordered the steak, eggs and home fries for breakfast and I was a bit disappointed! However, I must say that after calling and voicing my disappointment to a rep from bagelman he asked how he could make it better and did accommodate...Read More
Puppy Person
Puppy Person -Google user
9 years ago
I have had ALOT of bacon egg and cheese on a roll from dozens of places. This is the BEST place I have ever gotten a bacon egg and cheese on a roll. I don't know what they put in it but it's literally heaven...Read More

Features

Service options

check icon No-contact delivery
check icon Delivery
check icon In-store pickup
check icon In-store shopping
check icon Takeout
check icon Same-day delivery

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options

check icon Breakfast

Crowd

check icon LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning

check icon Quick visit

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards
check icon NFC mobile payments

Other

check icon LGBTQ+ friendly