What types of bagels do you offer?

We offer a variety of traditional and specialty bagels, including sesame, poppy, everything, cinnamon raisin, and more.

Can I customize my bagel with different toppings or spreads?

Yes, we offer a wide range of toppings and spreads, including cream cheese, butter, lox, capers, and more.

Do you offer any gluten-free or vegan options?

Yes, we have a selection of gluten-free and vegan bagels and spreads available.

Can I order bagels online or over the phone for pickup or delivery?

Yes, you can order online or call us to place an order for pickup or delivery.

Do you cater to large events or parties?

Yes, we offer catering services for large events and parties. Please contact us for more information and pricing.

Reviews (516) 921-9773 Call Website Photos About

Bagel Master in Syosset

Is this your business?

4.3 (290)

Bagel Shops Breakfast Restaurants

2 Images

Call Direction Website Reviews

(516) 921-9773 Direction Website Reviews

About

Bagel Master is a bagel shop in Syosset, NY.

Bagel Master Review Summary

The summary was generated by AI, based on reviews.

Bagel Master is a hidden gem, serving up freshly baked bagels with a perfect balance of crunch and chew. Their creative flavors and generous toppings make for a delicious breakfast or snack.

Review Rating Chart

Yelp: 4.5/5

Google Reviews: 4.4/5

TripAdvisor: 4.5/5

Foursquare: 4.3/5

Zomato: 4.2/5

Initializing review summary...

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.3

(290 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Christopher Ulrich -Google user

Edited 7 years ago

We've been going to Bagel Master since, well, before the kids were born... Over the last 15 years the food has been consistently delicious, with great service. It's wonderful to see small businesses that are part of the local community survive and thrive...Read More

Alan Klayman -Google user

2 years ago

best bagels and coffee on earth? maybe!!

Oren Schneider -Google user

3 years ago

You can never go wrong going to the Bagel Master amazing food and great people. Must try NY bagel spot

Nick Uliano -Google user

2 months ago

Great hot bagels and delicious sandwiches! Everything and Sesame are our go to with cream cheese. I highly recommend this spot and the staff are always super friendly. There aren't too many family run businesses anymore on Long Island and the quality here shows. Highly...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Stephen Fischer -Google user

2 months ago

Still a great deal for breakfast sandwiches. Good bagels and a variety of other options for breakfast and deli food. Always loved their hot chocolate!

Take outBreakfast$1–10Atmosphere: 5Indoor dining areaSomewhat difficult to find parkingFree parking lot

Kat Jenus -Google user

7 months ago

One of the best bagel stores on Long Island. Super friendly staff, amazing bagels and fast service. Pricing is reasonable and they offer a cash discount which is nice. One thing I miss however is they had a fun little Sue Bird item on their...Read More

Take outBreakfast$1–10Atmosphere: 4BagelPlenty of parkingFree parking lotThere are about 8 parking spaces right in front of the store and there is street parking available. Seeing as the place does mostly take out, it's usually easy to get a spot.

Linda Lowenthal -Google user

a year ago

Have been a customer since 70s Travel to shop.here BECAUSE no one else equals the quality of the product. Continues to be exceptional ! Recently, it was confirmed by family enjoying and remembering how special this was . And, recognizing that not only was it as delicious,...Read More

Take outBrunch$100+BagelOUTSTANDING NOVA

Alfred Gangemi -Google user

2 years ago

I could have given this place 4 stars, but my breakfast wrap (He-Man) was so good, it just seemed unfair. This seems like a good place for bagels too and reasonably priced. The reasons why I would have given 4 stars have nothing to do...Read More

Dawn K -Google user

a year ago

I would give six stars if I could. Anyone who gives this place any less than 4 stars (I won’t say anywhere is perfect 100% of the time 😁) either has lost their sense of taste or are simply unpleaseable lol . I have eaten...Read More

Jasmin Thrace -Google user

a year ago

The BEST bagel cafe experience you will ever have. I truly can not say enough good things about Bagel Master between the food, the service, and the general atmosphere. Armen and his team move in sync and treat everyone who walks in like long lost...Read More

Sophia -Google user

5 years ago

Breakfast sandwich with fried eggs, avocado, green peppers extra provolone was made to perfection, WOW! Even the salt and pepper was perfect serving. Fresh ingredients, made with care AND extremely delicious! The food display case could be kept up a little better, its...Read More

Sean L -Google user

7 years ago

Been coming here for years. Bagel Master is the best of the best! Bagels are always hot. All the salads are always fresh. We used them a couple times for family occasions for catering and they come as planned and hook it up everytime. You...Read More

Michael Penton -Google user

7 years ago

The name is very accurate. I wept stepping into this bagel bakery. Such a high level of quality and handmade care is not often seen anymore. The taste and texture of each bagel was spot on, and they had everything you would ever want to...Read More

nicole pourgol -Google user

4 years ago

Hands down without a question best tasting bagels and flagels I have ever had in my life and I even got my whole family addicted to them too. Nothing compares. Not only is their food great, but it feels like a family and they are...Read More

Alan Sack -Google user

5 years ago

I have been going to Bagel Master since I first moved to Syosset, when my kids were just babies. It has been our family tradition since 1997. Bagel Master has the best tasting and freshest bagels, sandwiches and omelets that we have ever had. My...Read More

Mrs. D -Google user

7 years ago

I've been coming here for more than 10 years and I will continue to come here. The bagels are amazing. Great oatmeal with a side of brown sugar. Really good veggie tuna. Can't go wrong with anything here! Ice coffee...Read More

Melissa Sumroy- Greene -Google user

6 years ago

Bagel Master has the best bagels in town. They are more expensive then they were previously, but worth it. They make blintzes one day a week. You need to get them quickly because they run out after 2 or 3 days. They...Read More

B L -Google user

4 years ago

Had a friend in S.C. order me a box of goodies from these guys. If I could give them 10 stars I would. Arrived in a little over 24 hours and enjoying everything in box. Great job, if you haven't tried, you need to. The...Read More

Bryan Webb -Google user

5 years ago

Fresh, perfect bagels. What a NY bagel should be! Make sure to try their sunflower flagel (flat bagel) and their tuna salad is simply the best. Don't be intimidated by the line in the morning as it moves quickly but be...Read More

Naz -Google user

8 years ago

Everything is good. Family oriented staff is pleasant and service is warm and efficient. Favorite item- egg, tomato and cheese on a whole wheat sunflower seed Flagel (flat bagel). So good! Smoked salmon, deli salads and wraps/sandwiches also excellent here.

Features

Service options

Delivery

In-store pickup

In-store shopping

Takeout

Dine-in

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options

Breakfast

Amenities

Wi-Fi

Planning

Quick visit

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

People Also Search

Bagel Shops Breakfast Restaurants

Bagel Master in Syosset

Contact

About