Reviews (984) 237-0002 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Amalia's Authentic Italian Restaurant is a premier Fine Dining Restaurant in Wake Forest, NC, offering an unparalleled culinary experience. Our Italian Restaurant is dedicated to serving traditional Italian cuisine with a modern twist, using only the freshest ingredients and time-honored techniques. Indulge in our extensive menu featuring homemade pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and delectable risottos, all crafted to transport your taste buds to the Tuscan countryside. Our expert chefs take pride in preparing each dish to order, ensuring a truly personalized dining experience. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a night out, our elegant atmosphere and exceptional service make us the perfect destination. Join us for lunch or dinner and discover why Amalia's Authentic Italian Restaurant is the go-to Restaurant in Wake Forest for authentic Italian cuisine. Visit us today at 1248 S Main St, Wake Forest, NC 27587, and experience the rich flavors and warm hospitality of Italy in the heart of North Carolina.

Amalia's Authentic Italian Restaurant Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.7
(388 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Chad Parker
Chad Parker -Local Guide
2 years ago
Celebrated our Anniversary at Amalia's. First time, and was excited based on all of the good reviews. Well I'm very happy to say that Amalia's lives up to the hype! Service being the highlight for me, was some of the best I've had in the...Read More
Juanita Brown
Juanita Brown
a year ago
“LIFE NEVER DENIES YOU CHOICES; IT SIMPLY COMES WITH OPTIONS AND RULES OF CONDUCT AND RELATIVE RESULTS.”ShadowExtraordinary Italian Experience~ We had my Echo's 80th birthday party celebration at Amalia's ~ absolutely great food/ambience/ and service. Michael who is apprentice to GAETANO, an extraordinary server, provided...Read More
Hawa Abdallah El Hadj
Hawa Abdallah El Hadj -Local Guide
a year ago
Amalia's Italian restaurant was a wonderful fine dining experience from the moment I walked in the door until after we left. The table was set divinely, the service was spectacular, and the food.... Was outta this world. I felt as if...Read More
Brooke Lewis
Brooke Lewis -Local Guide
a year ago
Excellent service and excellent food. They called to let us know they didn’t have a high chair available which we really appreciated even though we are fine without one.The focaccia was very fresh- warm and moist and very flavorful. The bruschetta crostini is served as...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Maranda White
Maranda White
5 months ago
We have dined at Amalias for almost four years now and the staff have never disappointed. The menu has changed, and it was amazing. Really authentic dishes drummed up by the owner and the talented Chef!!!I decided to start out with the Stevia salad which...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Danny Rivera
Danny Rivera -Local Guide
a year ago
Amazing food. Amazing staff. Everyone made you feel so welcome. The whole experience was very personable, we went there to celebrate our anniversary and it felt like the entire restaurant knew it was our anniversary. The food was 10 out of 10, amazing. Hands down...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Talía M
Talía M -Local Guide
9 months ago
We tried Amalia’s last night and it was fantastic. From the moment we walked in, everyone was extremely nice and the service was really fast. Our waiter, Brain, was really helpful when we were deciding what to order.All of the food was incredible—I haven’t had...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Ted Gautsch
Ted Gautsch -Local Guide
3 years ago
Since moving from Minnesota to North Carolina, I have been looking for that one, intimate Italian restaurant that stands out from the rest and that I could rely on for an intimate evening out.This establishment literally hit home, its is intimate, it is welcoming, accommodating...Read More
Lesley Hayward
Lesley Hayward
a year ago
Our first time at Amalia’s did not disappoint! First off, the service is AMAZING. Gaetano is so knowledgeable about all of the food and where it has come from, and helped us navigate the menu and recommended options based on our tastes. The ambiance of...Read More
A Cotten
A Cotten -Local Guide
9 months ago
I would have to say, the reviews does not match what this place is about. The food was not even good or aligned to what the pictures others showing here. Besides the waiter. The 3 course were two shareable meals with not even a sharable...Read More
Food: 1/5Service: 1/5Atmosphere: 1/5
Kador Ibrahim
Kador Ibrahim
6 months ago
We had the most amazing experience here. We were staying at the AirBnB and decided to try them out. and were treated by Gatino to a delicious experience. He made recommendations we would have not tried on our own and was spot on. Would definitely...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Sabrina Lathram
Sabrina Lathram
a month ago
This Restaurant is a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ and offers delightful dishes that we have not heard of. Their menu is a creative one and explores the true flavors of Tuscany. The owner from Tuscany is very talented and brings Tuscany to Wake Forest. Their menu features a...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Joel Suarez
Joel Suarez
3 months ago
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A Culinary Gem in a Tranquil Setting - August 27, 2024Amalia's Authentic Italian Restaurant is a hidden gem that offers an unforgettable dining experience. Nestled in a beautifully remodeled home, the ambiance is nothing short of serene—perfect for a relaxing evening out. The tranquil...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Tara Ann Lauro
Tara Ann Lauro -Local Guide
9 months ago
We booked this reservation about 5 weeks in advance to celebrate my birthday. The atmosphere was quaint and welcoming. The food was delicious, very rich in flavor and well portioned. Although, food and drink were slightly overpriced we were willing to overlook it due to...Read More
Food: 4/5Service: 3/5Atmosphere: 4/5
Ashley Gibson
Ashley Gibson
a year ago
We couldn’t have had a better experience if we tried! Our server, Brian, was fantastic and incredibly knowledgeable about the menu. The food was DELICIOUS and worth every penny. Anyone leaving a negative review pertaining to prices should consider the price of items prior to...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Tyler Vidmar
Tyler Vidmar -Local Guide
a year ago
My girlfriend and I spent our evening here tonight for our anniversary dinner and the experience was great. Gaetano was fantastic and extremely knowledgeable of the menu. His display and presentation of our dishes was immaculate. We went with the caprese and polpette (meatballs) to...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
David Malik
David Malik
2 years ago
We chose this as my mother is Italian and it was her birthday. Atmosphere and service was EXCELLENT!! Everyone was so nice and helpful. However, we waited over an hour for our food. Which is fine for great things - however I ordered the truffle...Read More
Cleveland May
Cleveland May
2 weeks ago
Mariam Ayane
Mariam Ayane
a week ago
This little restaurant is in great demand. It features tasting menus up to the chef. The food was great in proper portions and there were surprises throughout the meal from the Maitre D’ from Italy.The quality was excellent and service fun but not intrusive.Outstanding friendly...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Emily Reardon
Emily Reardon
a month ago
The service/drinks/apps started off wonderful but then the experience ended up being very disappointing. Our waiter was so impressive and friendly to start but when our entrees were brought out, they put surf and turf in front of my husband. He is allergic to shellfish...Read More
Service: 2/5Atmosphere: 1/5
Nikki Silvestri
Nikki Silvestri
3 months ago
What an amazing experience we had tonight. Logan was our server and he truly made it an experience worth remembering. He was extremely knowledgeable and made great recommendations. The owner’s wine was also amazing. Logan was thoughtful throughout the whole experience. Food was by far...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Emma Marie Thomas
Emma Marie Thomas -Local Guide
a month ago
LOVE. As a pescatarian, there were still great options. The dirty martini was next level tasty and the awesome menu continues with thoughtful and delicious dessert options. GOAT. CHEESE. CHEESE CAKE. unreal. You HAVE to go here if you love a fancy / Italian dinner....Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Anthony Sciprion
Anthony Sciprion
4 months ago
This was by far one of the best meals We’ve ever had. The space is very beautiful. Our server guided us with incredible suggestions and everything we tried was exceptionally made, and you could taste the love/quality of the food. Gatano was extremely hospitable and...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Donte Roberts
Donte Roberts
2 weeks ago
My Wife and I had a very special celebration last night at Amelia's Restaurant. The cozy charming Italian restaurant surprised us in many ways. The first was the amazing menu that they had recently updated. THE GAMBERONI appetizer was what Gaetano assured that it was...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Carrie Rowlands
Carrie Rowlands
4 months ago
We chose Amalia’s to celebrate our wedding anniversary; this was our second visit from two years ago. The first thing I noticed both times was an unpleasant moldy, musty odor. This is an older building; the floors are uneven, so you’ll want to watch out...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 3/5
Amy Hicks
Amy Hicks
6 months ago
We chose Amalia’s to celebrate our 34th wedding anniversary while on an out of town trip. It was everything we enjoy about dining out in an establishment that strives to their make food an experience. Gaetano welcomed us, and stayed with us for the entirety...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
doug rustico
doug rustico
2 months ago
Last night we celebrated a birthday and anniversary and had an amazing experience with Amalias Restaurant. The menu has been updated and there are incredible selections from the chef.Our server Gaetano who was recommended from a dear friend of ours had taste buds on...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Thomas Clark
Thomas Clark
6 months ago
Authentic Italian dining in America is quite rare, and this restaurant offers a genuine experience. Some negative reviews stem from a misunderstanding of Italian dining culture, which is characterized by slow service, small portions over many courses, and wanting American focused dishes. The handmade food...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Amanda
Amanda -Local Guide
a month ago
This privately owned restaurant is a favorite for anniversary dinners. The owner is so humble and kind and they are absolutely authentic italian. You really feel like you are in Italy. Also, if you are a LOTR fan you can nerd out with the owner...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Kerry Urdzik
Kerry Urdzik
7 months ago
Wanted somewhere really special to celebrate our wedding anniversary last evening, and Amalia’s is just that! The food was perfectly prepared and absolutely delicious. All the staff were friendly and our waiter was a super nice guy - attentive and very knowledgeable about the dishes...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Wally Beck
Wally Beck
4 months ago
Named after the grandmother; Amailias takes their cuisine very seriously with a Tuscan flare. The mosche Busch was heavenly and focaccia bread topped with pecorino cheese was very genuine.The food is prepared with care and you can tell by the aromas and freshness of each...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Kyle Lancaster
Kyle Lancaster
3 months ago
We celebrated our anniversary at Amalias Restaurant last night and we were astonished with the incredible service that we received from Gaetano.The descriptions of dishes and stories that accompanied his knowledge was passionate and very interesting.With the Gamberroni and he platted was outstanding.Gaetano shared the...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5
Marianne O'Donnell
Marianne O'Donnell
9 months ago
We were visiting from New York with family who live in Raleigh and they chose to treat us to Amalia’s for dinner! Amalia’s is the quintessential Italian restaurant that has made food their vocation to be enjoyed by everyone who is graced by eating in...Read More
Food: 5/5Service: 5/5Atmosphere: 5/5

Features

Service options

check icon Outdoor seating
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

check icon Fireplace
check icon Great cocktails
check icon Great dessert
check icon Great wine list

Popular for

check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible restroom
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Beer
check icon Cocktails
check icon Coffee
check icon Comfort food
check icon Hard liquor
check icon Organic dishes
check icon Vegetarian options
check icon Wine

Dining options

check icon Dinner
check icon Dessert
check icon Seating

Amenities

check icon Bar onsite
check icon Restroom

Atmosphere

check icon Cozy
check icon Romantic
check icon Trendy
check icon Upscale

Crowd

check icon Family-friendly
check icon Groups
check icon LGBTQ+ friendly
check icon Tourists
check icon Transgender safespace

Planning

check icon Dinner reservations recommended
check icon Accepts reservations

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards

Parking

check icon Free parking lot
check icon Parking

Other

check icon LGBTQ+ friendly