Reviews (765) 593-1212 Call Website Photos About

Steve Alford All American Inn in New Castle

Name: Steve Alford All American Inn in New Castle
Address: 21 E Executive Dr, New Castle, Indiana, 47362, US
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.2

Is this your business?

4.2 (362)

Hotels

Call Direction Website Reviews

(765) 593-1212 Direction Website Reviews

About

Steve Alford All American Inn is a hotel in New Castle, IN.

Steve Alford All American Inn Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.2

(362 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

LeAnna Becker -Local Guide

6 years ago

Ryan

6 months ago

I stayed here for Route 66 at NCMP in early May.This is a fine hotel and conveniently located nearby the track. Despite its older look/age, it's a well maintained property and clean overall. No continental breakfast unfortunately but no worries, there are several breakfast places...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

Karen Lichtenberg

a year ago

We absolutely loved our stay here!! The front desk attendant was so kind and helpful. She shared good places to eat and fun activities in the area. Our room was clean and tidy and smelled nice. There are basketball hoops outside and they have basketballs...Read More

Mikyla chapp -Local Guide

a year ago

This place is great! They have mini fridges and microwaves in the room and a bunch of streaming services available on the TV. They had real keys instead of the plastic key cards which was a fun surprise. There's a bunch of memorabilia on the...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

Forrest McPhail -Local Guide

a year ago

We have stayed in this hotel four times in the last 25 years or so. It is well-maintained: everything is nice, clean, working, and the atmosphere wholesome. The beds and pillows are comfortable. The theme of Steve Alford's college and NBA career memorialized on the...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

marna cross

2 years ago

We saw the billboard and stopped after the previous exit’s hotels were all full. When I called for availability the lady was very cheerful and helpful. The hotel was very nice. We enjoyed looking at all the basketball memorabilia. The room was clean and...Read More

Gayle Rice

4 years ago

Incredible staff that goes to every measure to make you feel at home. They literally went out of their way to help us after our transmission failed in our car on the interstate. They made us feel like family. The hotel is clean...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

Adam Machida -Local Guide

4 years ago

I just needed an affordable and decent room for my family for one night as we were in town for a wedding. We got both. Not an extravagant room, but very nice for the price. Quiet hotel with friendly and helpful staff. Pretty cool place...Read More

Amy Murphy -Local Guide

a year ago

On October 2nd I called the raintree inn where I normally go to rent a room for whatever reason and they were completely full so I went to steve Alfred inn and rented a room for one night I agreed to pay. I checked out...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Location: 5/5

Dick Ruehle

4 years ago

We along with family members were in New Castle to attend a funeral. When I went on the Internet to reserve a place I finally decided on this Motel. I was not disappointed. From the moment I walked in to get my room the lady...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

Jeff Schroeder

a year ago

Extremely happy with their service. They were very helpful and cooperative when we had any issues at all. We were in town to see my ailing mother in law who passed while we were in town. They went beyond duty to make sure our...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

Ken Wright -Local Guide

2 years ago

Nice, comfortable local owned Hotel. Lobby well appointed with basketball memorabilia from basketball coach Steve Alford.Next door to Steak n Shake restaurant.Clean room, comfortable beds. Mini fridge in room. Community Coffee in lobby.

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 4/5

Heidi Schettino

5 years ago

Driving thru at night and needed to get off the road and sleep. The room was newly remodeled and clean. The hotel is non-smoking, the room had no left over odors from previously guests smoking. Linen was soft and clean. The night was quiet. Breakfast...Read More

Al R

3 years ago

Perfectly adequate for an overnight stay, clean, and very well priced. Friendly, helpful staff. There is a table on the back patio where I could eat dinner or work outside the room in a covid-safe environment, weather permitting. All the basketball memorabilia in the public...Read More

Jason “Mixmaster Jazzy Jay” Jarvis

5 years ago

Was looking for places last minute for a trip back home. Must say this was not our first choice, however glad we did make the decision. The staff were simply amazing and the new remodeled Room was clean, nice and comfortable. This is not a...Read More

Steve German -Local Guide

10 months ago

Nice people and good prices for room. Clean rooms and very comfortable. Thanks for my pleasant stayRooms: Clean neat comfortableNearby activities: Basketball Hall of FameSafety: Quite sleepy town

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

Sierra Moore -Local Guide

2 years ago

The best place to stay in New Castle.I've stayed here twice, and each time, the staff was friendly and professional. Also, the rooms are always clean.I stayed Thanksgiving weekend, and I accidentally left my baby's homemade quilt in the room after checking out. I called...Read More

CHRISTOPHER IANNIELLO

2 years ago

This place has gone WAY downhill. We checked in and found FECES on the bathroom floor. We were moving to another room and it had DRIED URINE all over the toilet. We then were moved to a 3rd room which ended up...Read More

Rooms: 1/5Service: 1/5

LeeAnne McCoy

4 years ago

My family loved this motel. The night we stayed in their suite was the highlight of our cross country trip! Very clean and one of the most comfortable beds I have ever slept on. Very friendly service and very affordable rates. ...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

dorothy obrien

4 years ago

I came to New Castle overnight a few nights ago and honestly was a bit nervous when I couldn't find the typical Holiday Inn or anything. I found this hotel and the reviews were pretty good out of the few Hotels New Castle had...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

haward fender -Local Guide

3 years ago

This is an independent hotel comparable to a upper line Quality Inn and such, but with a twist. Lots of Basketball memorabilia from the career of Steve Alford. Don't know who he is? Neither do I, but he was important to the game throughout his...Read More

Dana DeLano

3 years ago

The only convenience to this hotel stay was how close it was to the track that we were spending most of our weekend. Our room (2 bedroom suite) was dirty, smelled of mildew, the utensils in the drawer were covered in some kind of gunk...Read More

Rooms: 1/5Service: 3/5Location: 4/5

Michelle Reed -Local Guide

5 years ago

We stayed four nights recently, and will definitely be back next time we are in New Castle. Great value! The property and rooms are clean and well maintained, the beds and pillows are very comfortable, the complimentary breakfast is great, and the staff is wonderful.They...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

Gayle Rice

4 years ago

The staff is incredible! Went out of their way for us when our car's transmission failed on I 70, near the exit to New Castle. April and Noel truly were Lifesavers for us. Traveling during the pandemic is stressful and they...Read More

Theresa Burris

3 years ago

I have been staying at this hotel for over 5 years now when I come and visit my granddaughter in Spiceland. This place has always been clean, safe, friendly, helpful, and comfortable. The prices are very reasonable and I have never had a problem with...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

Crow T. Robot

2 years ago

Came down to see a friend’s play at Guyer Opera House. Stayed two nights at this hotel. Had a standard room with a king bed. Room was very clean and comfortable! If I come down for another play, I will definitely stay here, again!Jim McDonnell—Flat...Read More

Denise Jurosko

8 years ago

Stayed at another area hotel a year ago and this one is much better. After last year's experience, we came straight to the room to inspect it and was happy with its cleanses. The hotel is older but...Read More

Lacy Taylor

7 years ago

Staff were super friendly and helped fix the problem. Unfortunately our original rooms air conditioner was busted and it was 82 degrees. When this was mentioned to staff she was very apologetic, and switched our room. She mentioned that this is a known issue of...Read More

Catherine Dorney -Local Guide

7 years ago

Great room! Cozy and roomy and clean. Friendly staff. Lots of basketball photos and memorbilia. Only a few minutes off I 70 with restaurants and a Wal-Mart right there. Heads and tails above their neighbor which I stayed at the week before on business. Spend...Read More

Nick Megel

2 years ago

Stayed here on Saturday April 23, 2022, we stayed in the King Suite and we’re very pleased. Suite had two bedrooms a living room area and a Kitchen area, room was very clean and there was a stove with cooking utensils for a extended stay...Read More

Rooms: 5/5Service: 5/5Location: 5/5

Features

Other

Free parking

Free breakfast

Free Wi-Fi

Breakfast

Star rating

Amenities

Free Wi-Fi

Free breakfast

People Also Search

Hotels

Steve Alford All American Inn in New Castle

Contact

About

Steve Alford All American Inn Review Summary