Reviews (305) 664-9271 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Seafood restaurant in Islamorada, FL, offers an unparalleled dining experience. Located at 81532 Overseas Hwy, our American restaurant is dedicated to serving the freshest catches of the day in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Indulge in our mouth-watering seafood dishes, carefully crafted to showcase the rich flavors of the ocean. From succulent fish to savory shellfish, our menu features a wide variety of options to satisfy any seafood craving. At Restaurant is the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a delicious meal. Join us for lunch or dinner and experience the best of Seafood in Islamorada. We look forward to serving you!

Islamorada Fish Company Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.3
(5101 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Nina's Crafthouse
Nina's Crafthouse -Google user
a week ago
We talked to Jill to set up having a small wedding at their place and it ended up being absolutely perfect. They had setup everything beautifully with the help of the family for decorations and it rained horribly but then Jill wennys, Jamie, and Marissa...Read More
DinnerAtmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talkSuitable for all group sizes
Antonio Perez Coss
Antonio Perez Coss -Google user
3 weeks ago
100% recommended 👍 This is one of the most beautiful restaurants in The Florida Keys! The food is great but the place, atmosphere and vibes will make the day! They have live music and special shows on saturdays evenings, I personally recommend to go with enough time to...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
John Murray
John Murray -Google user
2 months ago
If you are wondering where to go for a GREAT dinner, look no further than the Islamorada Fish Company. We arrived just before sunset and had a delicious meal with a gorgeous view. But what made the food and sunset even more spectacular was our...Read More
$50–100Atmosphere: 5
David Brosius
David Brosius -Google user
2 months ago
Islamorada Fish Company is a restaurant / Marina with amazing views and a relaxed atmosphere with viewing of tarpon and nurse sharks in the center area. The menu has casual and more fancy choices as well. There is live Caribbean style music many...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
Lenore Erickson
Lenore Erickson -Google user
Edited 5 months ago
Great meal!! I had the lobster w mashed potatoes and my boyfriend had the chicken parm w asparagus and mashed potatoes. It was 8:30 pm when we arrived, we got sat on the water by the bar near the kitchen. Server was an older guy,...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
Michelle Hill
Michelle Hill -Google user
2 months ago
Great food. If you're lucky, Maureen will be your server. She's wonderful! Thank you for threatening experience Maureen!
Klara Raymond
Klara Raymond -Google user
4 months ago
Located by the original Bass Pro Shop, plenty of parking and an amazing atmosphere. Sitting outside, you can see the large tarpon fish in the water. There was some live music there. We only stopped in for a quick bite, ordering the Wahoo Dip, the...Read More
$30–50Atmosphere: 5No wait
Big Lou
Big Lou -Google user
4 months ago
Can never go wrong here. You can pull in on your boat or drive in. Great Key Lime Colada BTW our server Will is always amazing. Out stop on drive down thru the keys always
Lunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5Moderate noise2 peoplePlenty of parkingFree parking lot
David Troncoso
David Troncoso -Google user
4 months ago
Had a great day on the water so we took our catch over to IFC for their mouth-watering seasoning and special touch. Never disappointed, can't beat the open Bay view, the school of resident tarpon, the live music and the amazing service. Thanks Destani!
Lunch$20–30Atmosphere: 5Suitable for all group sizesLive musicPlenty of parkingFree parking lot
Daniel Ocampo
Daniel Ocampo -Google user
7 months ago
Great place. The perfect connecting moment with nature. It was surrounded by an amazing ambiance where delicious food and incredible customer service make your experience a very special one. It is definitely a must do when going down to the keys.
Dine inBrunch$100+Atmosphere: 5
Jorge Sotres
Jorge Sotres -Google user
2 months ago
Great food and the services were excellent. Kids love to feed the tarpons.
Atmosphere: 5
David Gomes
David Gomes -Google user
2 months ago
Excellent food and drinks in the heart of Islamorada. The whole yellowtail snapper was cooked perfectly and tasted so good! The bartender made solid drinks as well.
$50–100Atmosphere: 4Quiet, easy to talk3-4 peopleIndoor dining area, Bar area, Outdoor patio / terracePlenty of parkingFree parking lot
PRT COOL SERVICE INC
PRT COOL SERVICE INC -Google user
2 months ago
“At The First Company, the food is excellent and the service is very kind and attentive. A perfect place to enjoy a moment of relaxation.
$30–50Atmosphere: 5Walk-ins onlyQuiet, easy to talk3-4 people
Valerya Henao
Valerya Henao -Google user
a month ago
Drove down from Broward for a day trip, and decided to end our day with some smoked wahoo dip we had heard was great. Not only was the dip great, but Ms Janet, was on her Ps and Qs with the excellent service. She payed...Read More
$20–30Atmosphere: 5Moderate noise3-4 people, Suitable for all group sizes
Thor Burge
Thor Burge -Google user
2 months ago
Nevena was absolutely Amazing waitress ! She was very attentive and gave the Best Service Ever ! Even Gave my daughter a baby shark in her drink ! Ticket 120019
Atmosphere: 5
Megan Stanton
Megan Stanton -Google user
Edited 5 months ago
In my opinion, I absolutely love this place! I’d recommend it to anyone who is going to the keys. The food was delicious. The green beans and wahoo was delicious. The atmosphere was great some tables are right on the water. It had a beautiful...Read More
Dine inDinner$30–50Atmosphere: 5
Whitney Teague
Whitney Teague -Google user
2 months ago
Just had this delicious pasta dish and it did not disappoint! The sauce was rich and creamy with just the right amount of seasoning, and the shrimp were perfectly cooked. The cherry tomatoes added a nice burst of flavor, and the toasted garlic bread on...Read More
$30–50Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talk2 peopleNo special eventPlenty of parkingFree parking lot
Anonymous
Anonymous -Google user
a month ago
Went here a week or two back (August 3) while on vacation with family. Food was amazing and fresh! Service was great! You can even buy some bait off the menu to feed the massive 8’ tarpon! They’ll snatch it up real quick and it’s fun...Read More
Atmosphere: 5Moderate noise3-4 people
Krystal Jones
Krystal Jones -Google user
4 months ago
The bartender was very nice and friendly. She made great margaritas. We ordered the peel n eat bay shrimp. They were very tasty, then she told us that we could feed the shrimp peels to the fish. THAT was fun!! If you haven't been, I...Read More
Carol Nahyma Castellon
Carol Nahyma Castellon -Google user
2 months ago
The sunset is amazing and then stay for the food. Best service ever, Rafael was the best, he made the best recommendations. Had the tacos with grilled and fried grouper. DELICIOUS! Thanks Rafael for the amazing service and recommendations.
Atmosphere: 5

Features

Service options

check icon Outdoor seating
check icon Delivery
check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in

Highlights

check icon Fast service
check icon Great beer selection
check icon Great cocktails
check icon Great coffee
check icon Great dessert
check icon Great wine list
check icon Live music

Popular for

check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible restroom
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Beer
check icon Cocktails
check icon Coffee
check icon Comfort food
check icon Happy hour drinks
check icon Happy hour food
check icon Hard liquor
check icon Healthy options
check icon Late-night food
check icon Quick bite
check icon Small plates
check icon Wine

Dining options

check icon Brunch
check icon Lunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Catering
check icon Dessert
check icon Seating

Amenities

check icon Bar onsite
check icon Restroom

Atmosphere

check icon Casual
check icon Cozy
check icon Romantic
check icon Trendy

Crowd

check icon Groups
check icon Tourists

Planning

check icon Accepts reservations

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards

Children

check icon Good for kids
check icon High chairs
check icon Kids' menu

Parking

check icon Free parking lot
check icon Free street parking
check icon Parking