Reviews (707) 599-1388 Call Website Photos About

Gabriel’s Italian Restaurant in Eureka

4.2 (270)

Bars Italian Restaurants Catering Food and Drink Suppliers Caterers Event Planners Fine Dining Restaurants Mobile Caterers Wedding Services

Call Direction Website Reviews

(707) 599-1388 Direction Website Reviews

About

Gabriel’s Italian Restaurant is a bar in Eureka, CA.

Gabriel’s Italian Restaurant Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.2

(270 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Aazhie Ryakes -Google user

10 months ago

Very cozy and mellow atmosphere. Restrooms are upstairs, old building is refurbished and very quaint. Service was super friendly and helpful. Small plates were great, all pasta and ravioli and everything was well plated and tasted fantastic. Creme Brule was great dessert to share!

Atmosphere: 5

Judy Rice -Google user

7 years ago

Crab night was wonderful! All four in our party enjoyed every bite and the friendly service. Can't pick a favorite dish.

Johnna Tunnyhill -Google user

8 years ago

Bartender makes a mean nonalcoholic drink... Great pasta dishes. Lovely atmosphere, music.

Sarah Romero Pavon -Google user

2 years ago

Lovely anniversary dinner @ Gabriel’s tonight in Eureka! 🤍 We got fried artichokes for our appetizer which were absolutely delicious - served with a side of crème fraiche. My husband got the New York steak and I got the fettuccine alfredo. Oh and can’t forget...Read More

Dine inDinner$30–50Atmosphere: 5

Heck N' Frick -Google user

7 months ago

I came to Gabriel's this past Valentines with my partner, and it was such a great experience. The service was really nice, the server was very charming (I wish I could remember his name 😅), and he checked on us the perfect amount. Not too often, not too infrequently. And when we finished dinner, we didn't feel rushed to leave at all. We were allowed to sit and enjoy the rest of our wine. I really enjoyed the atmosphere here. The lighting was soft and warm toned, making it feel very comfortable and intimate. The tables were arranged so that the ceiling lights wouldn't be directly above your head, but in the spaces between tables. Loved that. Their menu features tons of local seafood. One of the appetizers we had was steamed Manila clams in a garlic butter wine sauce with cherry tomatoes. Delicious umami sauce with the fresh lemon and cherry tomatoes, it was very bright and refreshing. Perfect for a starter. The other appetizer we got was fried polenta with mushrooms; my partner said it was some of the best polenta he's had. The side Caesar salad was good, I thought it was the perfect amount of dressing and cheese. The only thing with the food that I was disappointed in was the seasonal vegetables served with my entrée. It was lightly battered black cod served with Jasmine rice and the said seasonal vegetables. I usually love seeing seasonal veggies on the menu, so I was looking forward to that aspect of the meal. The disappointment came from the fact that my plate had a generous portion of roasted carrots and one single brussels sprout. The carrots were very tasty and well cooked, I'm just a bit sad I didn't get more variety, at least a couple more brussels sprouts. I understand that our reservation was closer to the end of when they were seating people (it was 8:30, they stopped seating at 9), so I get that they may have just been running low on their veggies at that point. That's the only thing that I can say that's not positive, though. The picture here was my entrée that I talk about. My partner has no complaints about the pasta dish he ordered, Frutti de Mare, aka fruit of the sea. It featured prawns, cod, and little mini shrimps. He actually made himself eat it all in one sitting because it was so good. I had leftovers, and the staff boxed my food for me. The wine selection was good, we thoroughly enjoyed a bottle of a New Zealand Sauvinon Blanc called Sea Cove that pared excellently with the seafood dishes. Highly recommend if you love seafood and want a fine dining experience to celebrate a special occasion.

Dinner$30–50Atmosphere: 5

David Wiblin -Google user

2 years ago

We were recommended Gabriel's and many others by the hotel. We're certainly glad we made this choice. Leo, our waiter for the night, was a consummate professional and helped four choosy diners to get the perfect meals and wine. Not terribly busy, so we made...Read More

$30–50Atmosphere: 4

Christy Stoddard -Google user

3 years ago

I had Fettuccine Frutti De Mare pan-fried cod, prawns, shrimp, mushrooms, garlic, wine & butter sauce, ate most of the generous portions of seafood at the restaurant. I couldn't eat it all & it was even better the next day! I heated in a pan...Read More

Dine inDinner$20–30

Jillian Kennedy -Google user

6 years ago

Delicious drinks and take out was phenomenal! Chicken Parmesan was the best we have ever had, perfect seasoned, lots of cheese and the spaghetti was the icing on top of the cake! Great place, will go back again.

David DesForges -Google user

a week ago

This is the best place to eat in Eureka. Amazing food and a phenomenal wine and spirits selection. The owner really knows his bourbon and scotch!

$30–50Atmosphere: 5

Danny Gatton -Google user

3 months ago

Let me just say that this is a gem. Please if nothing else go and get a drink at their superbly stocked and professionally tended bar. If you like rare liquors, you will be delighted. You will want to stay for dinner once you smell...Read More

$20–30Atmosphere: 5

Jen Hogan -Google user

2 months ago

Gabriel's is delicious and if you like Italian food it's a must-do in Eureka. Our awesome server Stanson recommended an appetizer, I cant remember the name but I normally would have never tried it and I'm so glad I did because it was delicious. The servings...Read More

Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talkNo wait

Samuel Galatian -Google user

3 months ago

The service is fantastic, our server was very attentive, but not too much and incredibly knowledgeable about anything on the menu. The filet mignon and veal parmesan are both DELICIOUS and highly recommended. The atmosphere was nice and relaxing. There was music playing through the...Read More

$50–100Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talk2 people, 3-4 peopleNo wait

Tobi Gronberger -Google user

a month ago

1. They let us dine even though it was late and saved us! 2. The food was great and came fast 3. The staff was super kind and speedy. Definitely recommend :)

Atmosphere: 5No wait

Kathi Ayala -Google user

3 months ago

Perfect service. Food was the best. I had the steamed clams, wow. Amazing. Lots of fresh bread. Best ever martini. Home made pasta, what an experience.

$30–50Atmosphere: 5

Damon mcpherson -Google user

3 months ago

One of the best restaurants in town! The staff and service is always amazing and the food is incredible.

Dinner$30–50Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talk

Valerie Kelsay -Google user

Edited a year ago

Great food , pleasant and cozy atmosphere for date night or just walking around old town for a bite to eat. Great choice of wine and cocktails. Cool breeze upstairs with the door propped open and we tried every dessert they had on...Read More

Dine inDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Fettuccine Alfredo, White Chocolate Creme Brulee, Sweet Potato Fries, Cabernet SauvignonSomewhat recommendPlenty of parkingFree street parkingNo events down there during this weekend and parking was great but this is within walking distance of a lot of apartments and hotels tooThey have two floors and the ground floor is good for wheelchairs

Valerie Kelsay -Google user

a year ago

If I could give them a 6 star review I would! They were shirt staffed for thr evening and yet they were organized and worked their little hearts out taking care of everyone as quickly and professionally as they could, with a...Read More

Dine inDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Tiramisu, Fettuccine Alfredo, White Chocolate Creme Brulee

Camille Summers -Google user

a year ago

We ordered the handmade brisket ravioli and Linguine Del Mare and it was fantastic! Live classical guitar and even some Opera. The service was fantastic, the wine was outstanding!

Atmosphere: 5

John Broderick -Google user

a year ago

Wow! Haven't been in years and I'm wondering why! Amazing and well made Italian food. Everything is fresh and prepared on point. The night we went they had a live guitarist and singer performing. Great drinks and wine. The servers were extremely good and...Read More

$20–30Atmosphere: 5

Janet Green -Google user

a year ago

We had such an extraordinary dinner last night. Gabriel’s has never disappointed but last night with the power out downtown we had the pleasure of dining with a full house by candlelight. Our waiter went above and beyond bringing out course after course hot and...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Tori Hammer -Google user

10 months ago

Oh the good was wonderful❤️ the crab raviolis and artichoke heart fritters were to die for. The filet mignon was cooked to perfection and just melted in your mouth.

Harue Seki -Google user

3 years ago

Get the Salmon Ravioli, especially if you love lemon. Your welcome. Excellent and friendly service, very accommodating (they set us up outside to allow our pup to dine with us, even though they didn’t have the patio set up, they graciously …

Glo Kennard -Google user

2 years ago

The food here is to die for. I just had their salmon ravioli and it was exquisite. The prices are a little high for us poor people but I think fair given the quality. Everything I have eaten here has been a party for the...Read More

Zelda Mealhouse -Google user

Edited a year ago

Family owned and ran. I love all of them so much.. I have been going to Gabriel's since they opened, almost 24 years ago. It is absolutely amazing food with large portions and a full bar. Everyone that works …

Gary Colby -Google user

a year ago

First of all the best part about the entire evening was the guitar player who sang opera! Unbelievably talented person that you must hear! The food was excellent. I had a New York steak that was perfectly cooked medium rare. The appetizers …

Scott Lucas -Google user

3 months ago

Excellent Service and atmosphere. Food was very tasty

$…

Meghan -Google user

3 years ago

The ambience is lovely, it’s like being transported in time. On our second occasion an absolute amazing guitarist was serenading the room. The food is spectacular- from seafood to steak. You really cannot go wrong. It …

Katherine Loyd -Google user

a year ago

We were visiting Eureka for a few days and thankfully found this place to eat. We had the Chicken Mushroom Linguini and it was delicious. The service was great. We had a nice window seat. No complaints at all.

Ganesh B -Google user

a year ago

Excellent service, food and ambience (including some live Italian music 😊). Shrimp appetizer, pasta dishes were delicious. Portion sizes are generous. …

Dawn Baker -Google user

a year ago

The service and food were fantastic. The tirimisu absolutely knocked it out of the park! The filet mignon was cooked to perfection, and the pasta was amazing. Absolutely would recommend.

Features

Service options

Outdoor seating

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

Highlights

Great coffee

Great dessert

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Comfort food

Happy hour food

Hard liquor

Organic dishes

Small plates

Vegetarian options

Wine

Dining options

Dinner

Catering

Dessert

Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite

Restroom

Atmosphere

Cozy

Romantic

Trendy

Upscale

Crowd

Family-friendly

Groups

Tourists

Planning

Dinner reservations recommended

Accepts reservations

Payments

Checks

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

High chairs

People Also Search

Bars Italian Restaurants Catering Food and Drink Suppliers Caterers Event Planners Fine Dining Restaurants Mobile Caterers Wedding Services

Gabriel’s Italian Restaurant in Eureka

Contact

About

Gabriel’s Italian Restaurant Review Summary

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

Features

Service options

Highlights

Popular for

Accessibility

Offerings

Dining options

Amenities

Atmosphere

Crowd

Planning

Payments

Children

People Also Search

Contact

Gabriel’s Italian Restaurant in Eureka

Contact

About

Gabriel’s Italian Restaurant Review Summary

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

Features

Service options

Highlights

Popular for

Accessibility

Offerings

Dining options

Amenities

Atmosphere

Crowd

Planning

Payments

Children

People Also Search

Contact

Related Search Eureka

People found Bars by searching for…

Find best businesses