Reviews (305) 664-0640 Call Direction Website Photos About
Call Direction Website Reviews

About

Chef Michael's, the premier Restaurant in Islamorada, FL, offers an exceptional dining experience in a cozy and intimate setting. Located at 81671 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, our establishment is dedicated to providing top-notch cuisine and outstanding service. At Chef Michael's, we take pride in our carefully crafted menu, featuring a range of delectable dishes that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. From classic favorites to innovative creations, our culinary team uses only the freshest ingredients to ensure a truly unforgettable meal. Whether you're in the mood for a romantic evening out, a family gathering, or a casual night with friends, Chef Michael's is the perfect destination. Our warm and inviting atmosphere, combined with our commitment to excellence, makes us the go-to Restaurant in the area. Join us for a truly exceptional dining experience at Chef Michael's, where every bite is a delight and every moment is a memory to cherish.

Chef Michael's Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review
4.7
(701 Reviews)
5
4
3
2
1
[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon rating iconrating iconrating iconrating iconrating icon Select a rating
Overall
Drop files here

OR

Allowed file types: .jpg, .jpe, .jpeg, .gif, .png, .bmp, .ico
(You can upload 10 files)
Please drag & drop the files to rearrange the order
Phil Daniels
Phil Daniels -Google user
a year ago
5/25/24 - Chef Michael's is fantastic! This was our first visit, but we'll definitely return whenever we're in Islamorada. We started with the Lion Fish appetizer because it's an invasive species and we're trying to do our part to help the Florida Keys...Read More
Dine inDinner$100+Atmosphere: 4
NUP
NUP -Google user
9 months ago
This place has stood the test of time and is better than ever! Tonight, they had swordfish, wahoo, triple tail, grouper, and, of course, hogfish. Everything was fantastic, including the desserts. I was able to order a trio of wahoo swordfish and hogfish. What a...Read More
Dine inAtmosphere: 5Triple Tail in Adriatic Sauce, Seared Tuna Tatiki
Steven Baryluk
Steven Baryluk -Google user
8 months ago
Great tasting food. On the pricey side, but you’re getting what you pay for. Good size portions (especially if you get the prime rib special!!)
Dine inDinner$50–100Atmosphere: 5
Nicole Fernandez
Nicole Fernandez -Google user
3 years ago
Our favorite place to splurge in the keys. We got the shrimp & conch fritter appetizer, seafood pasta, hogfish Juliette, and key lime pie. We’d give 10 stars if we could. All the food is incredibly fresh and comes out perfect. Seafood pasta had almost...Read More
Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)
Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor) -Google user
2 years ago
Best restaurant in Islamorada, if your looking for a fancy date night or a place for celebration this is your spot! Incredible fish to choose from & the steak is out of this world. We started with the lion fish and it was incredible! Forget...Read More
Dine inDinner$50–100Hogfish & Eggs, Shrimp and Lobster Ceviche
Aaron Dumas
Aaron Dumas -Google user
4 years ago
The upscale setting is a nice change of pace from the laid back beach options we had for our other meals. The food is good, ascetic is spot on however this was not the best food we had in my opinion. Square grouper...Read More
Dine inDinner
Vera J
Vera J -Google user
3 years ago
BEST RESTAURANT IN ISLAMARODA!!! Everything we had was super delicious!!! Service is excellent!!! Great ambience!!! Would definitely come back again when we come down to the keys. First of all, surprisingly good bread 🥖 it’s rare to get some good bread in Florida but man this...Read More
Dine inDinner$50–100
Nancy Clancy
Nancy Clancy -Google user
3 months ago
We have been dining at Chef Michael’s on our anniversary for years and it’s always a wonderful experience. This time we were seated in what used to be their porch area (it is enclosed). I personally prefer sitting in the bar area and...Read More
$50–100Atmosphere: 5No special eventNo waitIndoor dining area, Bar area
Alexandra Aldrich
Alexandra Aldrich -Google user
5 months ago
Chef Michael’s is a wonderful way to celebrate a birthday! Food, service and intimate atmosphere made it very special for our family to get together and enjoy a meal. The Trilogy special, the seafood pasta and duck were all excellent!!!
$50–100Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talk3-4 people, 5-8 peopleNo waitPlenty of parkingFree parking lotRight in the heart of Islamorada!
Soyge Baez (Soy)
Soyge Baez (Soy) -Google user
3 months ago
Delicious. Deserves le detour! Great wine selection.
$50–100Atmosphere: 5Reservations recommendedIndoor dining areaPlenty of parking
David Junkins
David Junkins -Google user
3 years ago
The best meal I had in Islamorada and it's not even close. There were some people who commented expressing frustration about needing a reservation. But, this is a pretty small restaurant and they wouldn't be able to operate effectively without reservations. This includes the bar...Read More
sarah app
sarah app -Google user
2 years ago
Was just there celebrating our five year wedding anniversary and had the most amazing meal! The service, food, and dessert were all exceptional - HIGHLY recommend the Salted Caramel Cheesecake Brûlée!!
Dine inDinnerAtmosphere: 5
Bill RB
Bill RB -Google user
2 years ago
Outstanding meal, great atmosphere, very friendly and courteous staff. Went for dinner, was able to get a reservation the same day, but not much available as most time slots were already booked. Great inside atmosphere, nice ambiance not overwhelming, but definitely a nicer look and feel than...Read More
Dine inDinner$50–100Chardonnay
Janeandmel
Janeandmel -Google user
2 years ago
Have had Chef Michael’s on the list for several years after reading lots of good things on a Boat Owner’s Fishing Forum. Also researched and saw lots of different reviews on google. May have been the best meal I’ve had in the Keys....Read More
Dine inDinner$50–100
Cameron Seagle
Cameron Seagle -Google user
4 years ago
Exceptional! Certainly one of the best seafood restaurants in the Keys, a place that has no shortage of them. Had grouper prepared Juliette style which is topped with Chardonnay butter, almonds, scallops, and shrimp. Easily one of the best fish preparations I’ve ever had in...Read More
Isabel Ortiz
Isabel Ortiz -Google user
5 months ago
Chef Michael's restaurant is truly a gem in the Keys! The ambiance is inviting, and the decor beautifully complements the culinary experience. The standout feature, without a doubt, is the exceptional service provided by Ashley. She always goes above and beyond to ensure that every...Read More
Atmosphere: 5
Sarah Empson
Sarah Empson -Google user
2 months ago
We visit year after year and always amazing! They are able to accommodate hook and cook of huge proportions. We brought 14 lobster and 1 large grouper and it took about 20 mins for the kitchen to prepare it all different ways. I would recommend...Read More
$100+Atmosphere: 5Reservation requiredNo special eventNo wait
Kris Wild
Kris Wild -Google user
3 months ago
Every single visit to the keys we eat dinner here. I know a 5 star rating is unbelievable but it truly is deserved! It was my husband’s birthday last weekend and we had the best dinner ever!
$50–100Atmosphere: 5Reservations recommendedNo waitIndoor dining areaPlenty of parkingFree parking lot
Kas Mosko
Kas Mosko -Google user
4 months ago
My husband and I decided to try something new and drove from BPK to dine at Chef Michael's on a busy Saturday night- with no reservation we were still seated within 45 minutes (the restaurant is small). We started our dinner we a garden salad, big...Read More
Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talkNo special eventSomewhat recommendVegetarian menu or sectionVegetarian black bean soup to die for. Ciabbata bread with a delish olive oil, vegetarian plate can be turned into vegan and it is still very good. Vegan dessert was splendid as well.
Christina Hoff
Christina Hoff -Google user
4 months ago
Nice restaurant. I had fish, coconut rice & vegetables. The coconut rice had a nice flavor. The fish was light & mild. The vegetables were good but too much butter for me. Little priced on the high side. Not much parking throughout this area.
$50–100Atmosphere: 5Moderate noise1 person, 2 people, Suitable for all group sizesNo wait

Features

Service options

check icon Takeout
check icon Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

check icon Great cocktails
check icon Great coffee
check icon Great dessert
check icon Great wine list

Popular for

check icon Dinner
check icon Solo dining

Accessibility

check icon Wheelchair accessible entrance
check icon Wheelchair accessible parking lot
check icon Wheelchair accessible restroom
check icon Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

check icon Alcohol
check icon Beer
check icon Cocktails
check icon Coffee
check icon Comfort food
check icon Healthy options
check icon Vegetarian options
check icon Wine

Dining options

check icon Brunch
check icon Dinner
check icon Dessert
check icon Seating

Amenities

check icon Restroom

Atmosphere

check icon Casual
check icon Cozy
check icon Romantic
check icon Trendy
check icon Upscale

Crowd

check icon Groups
check icon Tourists

Planning

check icon Reservations required
check icon Dinner reservations recommended
check icon Accepts reservations

Payments

check icon Credit cards
check icon Debit cards

Children

check icon High chairs
check icon Kids' menu

Parking

check icon Free parking lot
check icon Free street parking

People Also Search