Reviews (904) 589-3110 Call Website Photos About

0:32

Benitos Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Middleburg

Is this your business?

4.2 (167)

Italian Restaurants

1 Videos

5 Images

Call Direction Website Reviews

(904) 589-3110 Direction Website Reviews

About

Benitos Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant located in the heart of Middleburg, FL. We are dedicated to serving authentic, traditional Italian cuisine with a modern twist. From classic pasta dishes to gourmet pizzas, our menu is designed to satisfy any appetite. At Benitos Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, we take pride in using only the freshest ingredients, sourced locally whenever possible, to ensure the highest quality of flavor and presentation. Our chefs are passionate about creating dishes that are both delicious and visually appealing. Whether you're in the mood for a romantic dinner, a family night out, or a casual gathering with friends, our cozy and inviting atmosphere is the perfect setting. Our friendly and attentive staff are dedicated to providing exceptional service, ensuring a memorable dining experience for all. Visit us today at 2219 County Rd 220 Ste 317, Middleburg, FL 32068 and taste the difference for yourself. We look forward to serving you!

Benitos Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.2

(167 Reviews)

5

4

3

2

1

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Silvia Gavidia-diaz -Google user

11 months ago

The dinner was amazing! We had the shrimp cocktail and the pasta combo! It was delishus and filling! A great restaurant for a girls night out! Also our waitress Felisha was very kind and professional and offer her favorites dishes on the menu.

Dine inDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5

Shana Lindsey -Google user

a year ago

Last night we had the pleasure of dining at Benito’s. Everything was outstanding from the food to the service to the cleanliness of the restaurant. The food….wow, wow, wow. The garlic rolls they give you to start your meal were so light and fluffy with...Read More

Dine inDinnerAtmosphere: 5Salad, Pasta Combo

Amy Norris -Google user

Edited 6 months ago

Absolutely love this place!!!! Great atmosphere, food,and service!!!

Rose Sheffield -Google user

3 months ago

This place is a must try. Best service and the food is amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Kelly Kinney -Google user

2 years ago

The food is exceptional and made from scratch. Service always exceeds expectations and the ambience is nice. Tonight I had linguine with red clam sauce. Superb. This would be my first choice to take clients.

Dinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5

Allison Davis -Google user

a week ago

Benitos is a vary good restaurant to relax and have good company and conversation with people . But the food is always so good Every time i need comfort this is where I go. I love this restaurant

Atmosphere: 5

Melanie Friesen -Google user

a month ago

I have followed this restaurant in Jax almost 20 yrs. Great Lunch Buffet & garlic rolls!

Food:…

Cindy Gibson -Google user

a month ago

My husband & I tried Benitos for lunch yesterday. They had an awesome lunch buffet for only $11.99. It was great to get to try a variety of their pastas. All of it had delicious flavors. I am now hooked on their Italian donuts. We...Read More

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5No wait

Kevin Gibson -Google user

a month ago

My wife and I visited a couple of days ago. We were very impressed with the food quality on the buffet. Everything was very fresh and tasty. We will definitely be going back. I had seen that a couple of people gave one star reviews....Read More

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5No wait

Dayton Crawford -Google user

3 months ago

Food was delicious and buffet was at a great price. Highly recommend this to anyone who wants a nice quite atmosphere and comforting food. Service was great! Never saw the bottom of my glass. Will be coming again.

Atmosphere: 5

Christian Rodriguez -Google user

3 weeks ago

The food and the portions were amazing, let's support more local restaurants. They have specials and the prices are great, highly recommend the Zeppole dessert.

Take outDinner$1–10Atmosphere: 5Reservations not required

NTIM8STRANGER -Google user

3 months ago

I love this place! And Chef John's buffet dishes are so delish and he NEVER disappoints. I can't wait to return. As a matter of fact, I'm on my way now.

Dine inAtmosphere: 5

Jeanne Stock -Google user

3 weeks ago

The buffet is awesome. The best Italian food I have ever had. The eggplant is wonderful.

Dine inBrunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Tiramisu, Lasagna, Garlic Rolls, Chicken ParmPlenty of parkingFree parking lot

R. Whitaker -Google user

11 months ago

This is authentic fresh Italian, no frozen, canned etc., made fresh daily. The buffet was excellent. Everything our party of 3 tasted was so good. Could not find anything we did not like about this place. The chicken Regina was so tasty with the best...Read More

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5Pasta Combo, Cheese Pizza, Chicken Alfredo

Laura Schofield -Google user

4 months ago

Stopped in for the buffet. The food and service is awesome as always. I love Italian buffet because you can try a little bit of everything.

$10–20Atmosphere: 52 people

Dana West -Google user

2 months ago

The absolute BEST Italian food anywhere around Jacksonville. It’s well worth a visit! And Melissa was fantastic!

Dinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Tiramisu, Salad, Caesar Salad

Brooke Nettles -Google user

7 months ago

Great little spot that I’m so glad we found! Decided to give this place a try after seeing they have a lunch buffet offered from 12-3. It was delicious and so affordable. Friendly service & delicious food. We will be back

Dine inLunch$10–20Atmosphere: 5

Lloyd Sargent -Google user

7 months ago

5 star from the moment we sat down. So many menu choices it was hard to choose. The rolls, the Tortellini and the tiramisu were all delicious!!! When you go ask for Florella, she was awesome. Hope you enjoyed...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Mark Szwabo -Google user

5 months ago

Great friendly, accommodating family italian restaurant. We had young children and owner and servers were so chill and helpful, make sure you try the francese OMG! Thank you for great family feeling!

Atmosphere: 5

Terri Chappell -Google user

10 months ago

Food and service were excellent! We shared the Calamari, Margarita Pizza, and the Eggplant Parmesan. Delicious! We even had the $6.00 Tiramisu, (great price) also delicious. Their wine list could use a little work but everything else was chef’s kiss! Definitely will be returning....Read More

Dine inDinner$20–30Atmosphere: 5Tiramisu, Cheese Pizza

Holly Cornelius -Google user

7 months ago

Last minute decision for dinner turned out to be the best decision today. Blackened chicken tortellini, Stromboli and Tiramisu all delicious and the service from Florella was outstanding. We left with enough food for another meal. We will be back!!!!

Dine inDinner$30–50Atmosphere: 5Tiramisu, Chicken Alfredo

Gwendolyn Green -Google user

2 months ago

There are large Supreme pizza was very good and the hot bar had a lot of things to choose from all in all very good

$10–20Atmosphere: 5Quiet, easy to talkSuitable for all group sizesIndoor dining area, Outdoor patio / terrace

Amanda W -Google user

11 months ago

We have been wanting some good Italian food and let me tell you that they hit it out of the ball park. My husband and I had the lunch buffet. There was a nice variety of dishes to chose from. My favorite was the Alfredo...Read More

Cliff Baker -Google user

6 months ago

Benito’s lunch Buffett is amazing. One of my favorite things to get here is the pizza. It is soo good. I like that I can try different things on the Buffett to see if I would want to get the dish at dinner some other...Read More

Jeff Aboumrad -Google user

a year ago

I am extremely impressed with the food and service. We did the buffet, but there were many things on the menu I'd order. Buffet was very nice with several classic dishes plus pizza. I loved the friendly and attentive server, too. She was...Read More

Rebecca Wells -Google user

3 months ago

We went on Father's day, and had the buffet. It was so good, can't wait to come back.

Dori Craven -Google user

a year ago

The pizza here is amazing! One of the best NY style I’ve ever eaten. The crust and toppings were perfect. I love the take out pizza special, It’s a Great value. The pizza crust is a little thin but I really like it that way....Read More

James Henson -Google user

a year ago

Picked up and order this evening and it was absolutely amazing as always. This was the first time I’ve actually walked in as we normally Uber or Door dash out dinners from here. The lasagna and their meatballs are the best I’ve ever had. ...Read More

Tina Houser -Google user

a year ago

Everything from the moment we walked in the door was excellent. Nice clean restaurant with very pleasant staff. The Blackened Chicken Alfredo was amazing, and a nice change of pace from traditional Alfredo. The pasta combo gave my husband a little taste of multiple dishes....Read More

Judy Hartung -Google user

a year ago

Got the lunch buffet. It was very got. I tasted some of everything. The gentleman helping us was very friendly and efficient. He was right there whenever we needed anything. Went with 4 other ladies. We will be back.

Features

Service options

Outdoor seating

Curbside pickup

No-contact delivery

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Coffee

Comfort food

Wine

Dining options

Lunch

Dinner

Catering

Counter service

Dessert

Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Cozy

Crowd

Family-friendly

Groups

LGBTQ+ friendly

Transgender safespace

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

High chairs

Kids' menu

Parking

Free parking lot

Free street parking

Parking

Other

LGBTQ+ friendly

People Also Search

Italian Restaurants