Reviews (631) 331-9200 Call Website Photos About

Old Fields Restaurant Port Jefferson in Port Jefferson

Is this your business?

4.5 (646)

New American Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Steak Houses

Call Direction Website Reviews

(631) 331-9200 Direction Website Reviews

About

Old Fields Restaurant Port Jefferson is a new american restaurant in Port Jefferson, NY.

Old Fields Restaurant Port Jefferson Review Summary

The summary is generated by AI, based on reviews.

Reviews & Ratings

Leave a Review

4.5

(646 Reviews)

[bip_review_summary]

Leave a Review

Thiago Prado -Google user

a year ago

Mac and cheese was 10/10. Calamari was pretty damn good too. Burger was very enjoyable but not mind blowing. Would return. A bit too dark inside for my personal liking but I'm sure it's part of there design.

Dine inDinner$30–50Atmosphere: 4The Old Fields Burger, Mac and Cheese, S'Mores Brownie SundaeSomewhat difficult to find parkingPaid parking lotWd got lucky but when we left there were several cars looking for parking.

Simone Fazio -Google user

3 years ago

This place is excellent! I’m writing this review after my fourth dinner in three years, and I can say that the quality of the place and the food is excellent. I drove almost two hours from Brooklyn to have dinner here. Staff is friendly and...Read More

Dine inDinner$30–50

Nic Ross -Google user

a year ago

Okay...wow! I have a friend in Port Jeff that I was visiting and we decided to go out for dinner this weekend. Although I'm vegetarian, I'm not picky with places and can always find something on the menu to eat! She recommended Old Fields and told me it's their favorite local Steakhouse. I was sure I'd probably only find a side or so to eat and was okay just eating later on. It was raining out but it was so warm and cozy inside! I immediately realized how packed the place was and the dim lighting inside made for the best dinner vibes!! As I got there and looked at the menu, I realized how many vegetarian options they had available. There was also a fireplace close to our table that made us feel extra cozy and our table had cute table lights that went perfect w/ the fall cocktails & restaurant aesthetic. I loved that they had so many specials and features. They had a specials menu for food that night as well as three seasonal fall cocktail options. To start, I had the pumpkin martini which was very sweet but definitely "fall-y" and yum! Maybe get it as a dessert cocktail. For apps to share, we got the night special stracciatella & fig flatbread as well as the zucchini chips. We loved both! The flatbread with the figs & balsamic was perfect and the zucchini chips breading was sooo flavorful and delicious with the dipping sauce they give you. For my entree, they had a "Mezzi Orecchiette" which was Orecchiette pasta with a summer vegetable medley in a lemon cream sauce. This was the best thing I had! The lemon cream sauce was so creamy and rich and paired perfect with the fresh vegetables and pasta. I would definitely go back just to have this again. For dessert, we were already so full but decided to get a creme brulee. Of course this was delicious and had maraschino cherries on top - my fav! We ended the night drinking cocktails by the fire. The other thing I noticed was how good the service was. I can't remember her name but our server was so upbeat and fun and had so many recommendations for us. Everything came out fast and all of the wait staff & bussers were efficient. This place surprised me and ended up being a fantastic surprise that I needed to review, thank you!

Dine inDinner$50–100Atmosphere: 5Zucchini ChipsHighly recommendVegetarian menu or section, Clearly labeled vegetarian dishesI was worried about not finding many vegetarian options but there were plenty and they all tasted amazing!So many vegetarian options!Plenty of parkingPaid parking lot

BusyB -Google user

a year ago

What a fantastic meal! Started with the pumpkin martini which was amazing. Then I had the beets salad which was extremely delicious, and then had the salmon which was cooked to perfection! Our waitress was extremely friendly and efficient. We walked in without...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Ashley Alvator -Google user

2 years ago

I can’t begin to say enough amazing things about this place! Every time I go here I have the best experience and I always receive the highest quality service. My go to meal is the Organic Wild King Salmon with Brussel Sprouts it’s perfection!! It...Read More

Dine inDinnerAtmosphere: 5French Onion SoupPlenty of parkingFree parking lot, Free street parking

Al D -Google user

2 years ago

This Establishment is extremely well run. They went out of their way to make my wife and I have an extremely pleasant time on our anniversary dinner. The food was amazing, the wait staff even better… And the manager often came over to...Read More

Dinner

Sam M -Google user

6 years ago

This was my first time going to this establishment, and it was the first of many. Firstly, the atmosphere was lovely, and was very beautiful on the inside and out aesthetically. There is also plenty of room for seating and there was no wait. Secondly,...Read More

Bob Dielman -Google user

Edited 6 months ago

Updated March 2025: I had a great meal with my son last night. I received my usual warm welcome upon arrival and great service from Nick at the bar. We always have a great experience at Old Fields in Port Jefferson. Thanks so...Read More

Dine inDinner$30–50Atmosphere: 5

rachael kaplan -Google user

8 months ago

Love this restaurant! Hate the new menu. Where is the turkey burger? Fried chicken night? Brussels sprouts? So disappointed with the new menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Leila McGrath -Google user

2 years ago

Perfectly cooked, moist salmon. Delicious vegetables. Fresh Caesar salad with delicate dressing & sugared pecans. Tender burger that is not overstated. French onion soup could sport more onions & less salt. Polite staff.

Andrea Mariano Ramirez -Google user

2 years ago

I went to Old Fields this week for a friend's birthday dinner. After hearing such great things I was really excited to try this place and it did not disappoint! The restaurant itself is tucked away in a cute corner and inside the warm furniture...Read More

Dine inDinner$50–100Atmosphere: 5French Onion Soup, S'Mores Brownie Sundae, Braised Short Rib RisottoSomewhat difficult to find parkingPaid parking lot

Alan Krull -Google user

3 weeks ago

Dinner for three. Everyone raved about all dishes from appetizers to desserts and side orders. I advance-ordered a larger cut of rib steak. I was asked how I would like it prepared and it was cooked to perfection. Staff was exceptionally accommodating on the phone...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Christine Clark -Google user

5 months ago

Had dinner here for the first time last night. Walked in at about 8:00 and we were seated right away. It was nothing short of phenomenal! Calamari was the most tender we’ve ever had! We ordered a filet and a ribeye and both were cooked...Read More

Dine inDinner$100+Atmosphere: 5

Maureen -Google user

2 months ago

We hosted 25 people for a rehearsal dinner on a Friday night in June. Alison could not have been more helpful with the advanced planning, being sure there was a vegan option and with a changing headcount! She offered options of a private...Read More

$100+Atmosphere: 5Skirt Steak, Fish, Mashed Potatoes, The Old Fields Burger, Buttermilk Fried Calamari, Old Fields Salad, Fried Zucchini ChipsBar area, Private dining roomHighly recommendPlenty of parkingThere is a ramp to get into the restaurant. And staff jumped to hold the door.

Des C -Google user

2 months ago

Just picked up take out. The bartenders Nick and JD were awesome. While waiting for my food I meet a nice couple who came in from CT, Diane and Norman. The food was spot on. I got filet mignon with creamed spinach. Cooked to perfection....Read More

Atmosphere: 5

James Frankini -Google user

4 months ago

Went for Mother's Day; what a treat. My wife was thrilled as the calamari was GF and delicious, as was everything. I had a Ribeye which was like butter. They had a super reasonable Mother's Day buffet special but since this...Read More

$50–100Atmosphere: 5

Kat Dom -Google user

6 months ago

We were looking for a new place to have drinks/apps in PJ and remembered Old Fields. Drinks & food were great.....Service was fantastic! The bartender, Nick, was very hospitable which we really appreciated!! Wish the menu, especially apps, were a little more extensive bc we...Read More

Atmosphere: 4

Chris L -Google user

6 months ago

10/10 the service here is top notch. The cocktails are great, order one of their curated drinks. Food was hot fresh and tasty! Their desserts are also not to be missed.

Atmosphere: 5

Philip Gape -Google user

7 months ago

What a FANTASTIC first dining experience!! The food was phenomenal, not a thing we ordered that was not fresh and delectable! The service is what took the entire experience up several notches...Kasey, Michael, and the lovely bartender made us feel at home and were incredibly...Read More

Atmosphere: 5

Magdalenka -Google user

5 months ago

I really like it there. Everything was just perfect and food was delicious! I will be back thats for sure! The restaurant looks unique and very pretty. Thank you!

Dine inDinner$50–100Atmosphere: 5Fries, The Old Fields Burger, Buttermilk Fried Calamari, Beer Battered Onion RingsPlenty of parkingFree parking lot

Features

Service options

Outdoor seating

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Fireplace

Great coffee

Great dessert

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Comfort food

Happy hour drinks

Happy hour food

Hard liquor

Healthy options

Late-night food

Private dining room

Small plates

Vegetarian options

Wine

Dining options

Lunch

Dinner

Dessert

Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Cozy

Romantic

Trendy

Upscale

Crowd

Family-friendly

Groups

Tourists

Planning

Dinner reservations recommended

Accepts reservations

Payments

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Children

Good for kids

High chairs

Kids' menu

Parking

Free parking lot

Paid parking lot

Parking

People Also Search

New American Restaurants Restaurants with Outdoor Seatings Steak Houses

Old Fields Restaurant Port Jefferson in Port Jefferson

Contact

About

Old Fields Restaurant Port Jefferson Review Summary